3 passages · 40 questions · 60 minutes · all reading tests
Free: read the whole test now. When you start answering, sign in with your email to get your band and the answers.
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 1–13, which are based on Reading Passage 1 below.
The sea otter is the smallest of the marine mammals, and it has the thickest fur of any animal: up to a million hairs per square inch. Unlike seals and whales, it has no layer of fat for insulation, relying instead on air trapped in this dense coat, and on a metabolism so rapid that it must eat about a quarter of its body weight each day. These two characteristics, as it turned out, were to determine its fate. The first made it one of the most valuable animals in the world, and the second gave it an influence over its environment out of all proportion to its size.
Before the eighteenth century, perhaps 150,000 to 300,000 sea otters lived along the rim of the North Pacific, from Japan through Alaska to Mexico. The expedition led by Vitus Bering in 1741 brought back furs to Russia, which started a commercial rush. Over the following century and a half, Russian, British, American and Spanish traders hunted the animals along the entire coast, selling the pelts in China at enormous profit. By the time that an international treaty gave the sea otter protection in 1911, only around a thousand to two thousand animals remained, scattered in about a dozen isolated groups. In many regions, they had disappeared altogether, and in California they were believed to be extinct until a small group was found near Big Sur in the 1930s.
It took many years for the ecological consequences of this slaughter to be recognised. In the early 1970s, a young American biologist, James Estes, was working in the Aleutian Islands, where some islands had recovered their otter populations and others had not. He and his colleague John Palmisano were struck by the visible contrast between the two. Around Amchitka, which had many otters, the sea was filled with towering forests of kelp, a giant brown seaweed. Around Shemya, which had none, the sea bed was almost bare, except for a carpet of spiny sea urchins. In a paper that was published in 1974, they offered a simple explanation. Sea otters eat urchins, and urchins eat kelp. Remove the otter, and the urchins multiply, unchecked, and graze the forest down to the rock.
This pattern, in which a predator shapes a whole ecosystem through the animals it eats, became one of the best-known examples of what ecologists call a trophic cascade. The sea otter is often described as a keystone species: one that has an impact far greater than its abundance would suggest. And the effects extend well beyond the urchins. Kelp forests provide shelter and food for a wide range of fish, seabirds and invertebrates, and they reduce the force of the waves that strike the shore. They also absorb carbon dioxide. One estimate, published in 2012, suggested that otters may allow kelp forests in the North Pacific to take up considerably more carbon than they could if urchins were left to graze, although the amount that remains permanently stored is not known.
Yet ecosystems rarely stay as simple as the first accounts imply. During the 1990s, Estes and his colleagues noticed that otter numbers in parts of the Aleutians, which had recovered well, had suddenly begun to fall, by up to 90 per cent in some areas. There was no evidence of disease, and no shortage of food. The researchers came to suspect killer whales, which had been seen attacking otters, something that had rarely been observed before. Their hypothesis, which remains controversial, is that the whales had turned to this small prey after their normal food, seals and sea lions, had declined. If that is right, then a change far out in the ocean had made its way down to the shallow coastal waters, leaving the urchins free to spread once more.
Equally unexpected findings have emerged from an estuary in California. Elkhorn Slough has been heavily polluted by fertiliser from nearby farms, which normally causes algae to grow on the leaves of seagrass and smother them. Seagrass there should have been in decline, and yet researchers discovered that it was thriving. A team led by Brent Hughes traced this to the otters, who had recently returned to the area. The otters were eating crabs, the crabs had been eating the sea slugs, and these sea slugs cleaned the seagrass by feeding on the algae. Thus the top predator was, in effect, counteracting the damage caused by pollution, in a way which no one had predicted.
Today, sea otters number over 100,000, but their recovery is uneven, and it is not universally welcomed. Otters eat large quantities of shellfish, and in Alaska and Canada, they compete directly with the people who catch crabs, clams and sea urchins for a living. These communities may have had many generations without otters and have built a livelihood on a situation that was itself the result of overhunting. Conservationists may regard the return of the otter as nature being restored, but to a fishing family, the same event may look like the loss of their income. Studies in British Columbia have attempted to weigh up these costs and benefits, with some concluding that the increased value of finfish, tourism and carbon storage could in time exceed the losses. Those gains, however, do not necessarily go to the people who bear the losses.
1Sea otters are protected from the cold mainly by a layer of fat.
2Traders sold most of the otter furs in Europe.
3At one time, Californian sea otters were thought to have died out.
4Estes and Palmisano initially went to the Aleutians to study kelp.
5It is certain that kelp forests permanently store large amounts of carbon as a result of otters.
6Killer whales have been shown beyond doubt to be the cause of the Aleutian decline.
Aleutian Islands
Elkhorn Slough
Conflict
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 14–26, which are based on Reading Passage 2 below.
A High in the Andes, near Lake Titicaca, people began to domesticate wild potatoes at least 7,000 years ago. The wild plants were bitter and in some cases poisonous, and their tubers were small, but over thousands of years, farmers selected and developed thousands of varieties. By the time that the Spanish arrived in the sixteenth century, potatoes were supporting the Inca Empire. The Andean peoples had even invented a method of preserving them, by alternately freezing and drying them in the mountain air, in order to produce chuño, which could be stored for years, and which fed Inca armies on the march.
B The Spaniards were much more interested in Andean silver than in Andean food, and the potato reached Europe without fanfare, probably in the 1570s, on ships returning from South America. It got a cool reception. It was grown from tubers rather than seed, it was not mentioned in the Bible, and it was related to deadly nightshade. Some people blamed it for causing leprosy, and others simply thought that it was only good for feeding animals or the poor. Early varieties, moreover, were suited to the short days of the Andean tropics and produced few tubers in the long days of a European summer, until selection gradually produced plants that were better adapted. For nearly two centuries, it was grown across most of Europe as little more than a botanical curiosity or a crop for the very hungriest.
C That eventually changed, largely as a result of war and hunger. Grain in a field can be seized or burned by a passing army, but potatoes in the ground are hard to find, and peasants began to realise the value of this. Frederick the Great of Prussia ordered his subjects to plant them in the mid-eighteenth century and, according to a popular story, he had them guarded by soldiers in the expectation that people would conclude that they must be valuable and steal them. In France, the chemist Antoine-Augustin Parmentier, who had survived on potatoes as a prisoner of war in Prussia, devoted himself to their promotion after a famine in the 1770s. He presented flowers from the plant to Louis XVI, served dinners made up entirely of potato dishes to influential guests, and is said to have used the same trick with the guards. Whether these stories are true or not, by the early nineteenth century, the potato was a staple food across northern Europe.
D Its significance is difficult to overstate. An acre of potatoes yields far more calories than an acre of wheat, and it needs less labour, and it has enough vitamin C and other nutrients that people can survive on it, together with a little milk. In 2011, the economists Nathan Nunn and Nancy Qian attempted to measure the effect. They compared regions of the Old World which were well suited to growing potatoes with those which were not, before and after its introduction, and they estimated that the crop accounted for around a quarter of the growth in population and urbanisation between 1700 and 1900. According to this analysis, the rise of the West may have owed much to this humble root.
E There was a dark side to this success, and nowhere was it more apparent than in Ireland. By the 1840s, around a third of the Irish population depended almost entirely upon potatoes, and many had little else to eat. They were also growing mainly one variety, the Lumper, and as the plants were propagated from pieces of the tuber rather than from seed, they were all genetically close to identical. When a fungus-like organism, Phytophthora infestans, arrived from the Americas in 1845, it found no resistance. It destroyed the crop within days, and it returned in the years that followed. About a million people died, and a further million or more emigrated. The disaster was not caused by the disease alone, as Ireland continued to export food throughout the famine and the British government's response was grossly inadequate. But it was the dependence upon a single crop which made such a catastrophe possible.
F The lesson has not been entirely learned. The vast majority of potatoes grown commercially today come from a small number of varieties, selected by food processors for uniformity in making chips and crisps. Late blight, as the disease is known, remains the most damaging disease of the crop, and it costs growers billions of dollars a year in losses and chemical treatments. In the 1990s, new and more aggressive strains spread around the world, and some of those have proved resistant to the most effective of the fungicides. Researchers are turning for help to the crop's home, as the wild relatives and traditional varieties still found in the Andes contain genes for resistance. The International Potato Center in Lima maintains one of the world's most important collections of this material.
G Meanwhile, the potato has continued its migration. China is now the world's largest producer, and India is second, and in the developing world as a whole, production has been growing faster than in the rich countries. Chinese authorities have even been promoting it as a staple, alongside rice and wheat, on the grounds that it needs less water and can grow on poor land. For a plant that was once thought fit only for pigs, it has come a very long way from the slopes of the Andes.
14a reason why the crop was safe from enemy soldiers
15a statistical estimate of the crop's contribution to historical change
16a biological reason why the plant at first performed poorly in Europe
17the reason why some experts are interested in old varieties
18a way of storing food for long periods
19factors other than a plant disease which made a disaster worse
20Some Europeans at first distrusted the potato
21It is said that Frederick the Great put guards on potato fields
22Parmentier became an active supporter of the potato
23Modern commercial growers rely on few varieties
24What does the writer say about the Irish famine?
25What point is made about late blight today?
26Why is China promoting the potato?
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27–40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
A fire chief leads his team into a burning house. The blaze appears to be an ordinary kitchen fire, but as they spray water on it, something feels wrong. It does not behave as it should, and the room is hotter than he would expect. Without being able to say why, he orders his men out. Moments later, the floor on which they had been standing collapses. The fire had been raging in the basement beneath them. Asked later how he knew, the chief could only mention a sixth sense. This story was collected in the 1980s by the psychologist Gary Klein, and it has become a favourite among those who celebrate the power of expert intuition.
It is not difficult to see why. There is something deeply attractive in the idea of a kind of knowledge that lies beyond analysis, and business books have made substantial sums by encouraging their readers to trust their gut. Unfortunately, there is another body of evidence that points in just the opposite direction. In 1954, the American psychologist Paul Meehl reviewed about twenty studies which compared the predictions of experienced clinicians with those of simple statistical formulas, on matters such as how patients or students would fare in the future. The formulas did at least as well in almost every case, and often better. Since then, the comparison has been repeated hundreds of times, in fields ranging from medicine to the forecasting of wine prices, and the result has been remarkably consistent. On most occasions, a simple rule beats the confident expert.
How can both of these things be true? For many years, the two camps largely talked past each other. Klein's followers studied professionals such as nurses and firefighters in their working environment, and they were impressed by what they saw. Researchers following Meehl, among them Daniel Kahneman, studied errors of judgement in laboratories and in the records of financial forecasting, and they were impressed by something quite different. It is rather to the credit of both Klein and Kahneman that, in spite of the distance between their positions, they sat down together over several years to try to work out where they disagreed. The resulting paper, published in 2009, is a rare example of what Kahneman called adversarial collaboration, and I regard it as among the most useful things that have been written on this subject.
Their answer is quite simple, and it may be stated in terms of two conditions. Intuition, they argue, is nothing magical; it is pattern recognition. The fire chief had seen thousands of fires, and he had stored up, without being aware of it, a sense of how they normally behave. So when this one failed to match the pattern, he noticed. But for this to be possible, the environment must be sufficiently regular for there to be patterns to learn, and the person must have had long practice in it, with quick and clear feedback on whether he was right. Chess meets these conditions admirably, and so do firefighting and anaesthesia. An anaesthetist knows within minutes when something has gone wrong. The stock market, by contrast, fails them. Its movements are largely unpredictable, and a fund manager can be right for reasons that have nothing to do with skill.
What seems to me most important in this analysis is a point which is easily overlooked: confidence is no guide at all. We naturally assume that someone who is sure of a judgement, and who can give a persuasive account of it, is more likely to be right. Yet the subjective feeling of certainty arises from how well a story hangs together in the mind, not from how good the underlying evidence is. Thus, a stock picker or a political pundit can feel just as much conviction as a fire chief, and the feeling itself offers no way of telling them apart. Nor can the experts be relied on to know the limits of their own expertise. A skilled doctor may have excellent intuition in diagnosis, but the same doctor's long-term predictions about a patient's outcome are likely to be of much less value, even though this distinction will not be felt from the inside.
Some writers conclude from all this that we should replace human judgement with algorithms wherever we possibly can. There is some merit in this view, and those who resist it tend to underestimate how much of what passes for wisdom is merely habit. It has also been argued that formulas cannot be biased, but this is plainly false. An algorithm that has been trained on past decisions will reproduce the prejudices that those decisions contained, and it will do so with an appearance of objectivity that makes these harder to challenge. Formulas also fail badly when the world changes in a way which their designers did not foresee, as anyone who relied on a financial risk model in 2008 will remember. In those circumstances, a person with long experience may notice that something is wrong, while the model carries on without concern.
The practical advice that follows is more demanding than either 'trust your gut' or 'trust the numbers'. Before accepting an expert's intuition, including your own, it is necessary to ask two questions about it. Is this a domain in which there are reliable patterns to be found? And has this person had a real opportunity to learn them? If the answer to either is no, then their confidence should count for nothing, however impressive it may seem. If the answer is yes, then their intuition may be worth a good deal, even if they cannot explain it. The fire chief, it should be remembered, was right, but he was right about fires.
27Klein and Kahneman deserve praise for working together despite their differences.
28Fund managers tend to be less intelligent than fire chiefs.
29How sure someone feels is a poor indication of whether they are correct.
30Doctors are able to sense when their predictions are less reliable than their diagnoses.
31People who oppose the use of algorithms often overrate human judgement.
32Algorithms are free from unfair bias.
33The writer uses the story of the fire chief at the beginning in order to
34What did Meehl's review suggest?
35According to Klein and Kahneman, why does firefighting allow intuition to develop?
36What is the writer's main point about algorithms in the sixth paragraph?
37According to Klein and Kahneman, intuition is based on the ability to recognise ________.
38To develop true skill, a person needs prompt and clear ________.
39A fund manager's success may be due to no more than ________.
40A feeling of certainty comes from the ________ of a story in the mind.
Tip: select words in the passage to highlight them in yellow, green or pink, or to add a note. Your highlights and answers are saved on this device until you submit.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.
Jitender SinghFounder & Managing Director
Vikram SinghHead – Quality & Operations
SanjayHead – Tourist Visa Operations
TejaswaniHead – Counselling Team
MahimaHead – Visa Filing & Processing
Pratigya DuttaHead – Student Visa ProcessingFree, no-pressure guidance from a real counsellor who handles your case end to end — from documents to decision.