3 passages · 40 questions · 60 minutes · all reading tests
Free: read the whole test now. When you start answering, sign in with your email to get your band and the answers.
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 1–13, which are based on Reading Passage 1 below.
Between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries, scurvy is thought to have killed some two million sailors, more than storms, shipwrecks and battle combined. Its progress was horribly familiar to anyone who went to sea. After two or three months without fresh food, a sailor grew tired and listless. His gums swelled and bled, old wounds reopened, and in time he died, often quite suddenly. When George Anson set off around the world in 1740 with about 1,900 men, some 1,400 did not come back, and the great majority of those were killed by scurvy. What is puzzling is not that the disease was so deadly, but that a cure which was in effect known for centuries took such a long time to be adopted.
The story that is usually told is simple, and it has a clear hero. In 1747, James Lind, a Scottish naval surgeon aboard HMS Salisbury, took twelve sailors with scurvy and divided them into six pairs, giving each pair a different remedy: cider, sulphuric acid, vinegar, sea water, a mixture of spices, or two oranges and a lemon each day. Those eating citrus fruit recovered rapidly, one being fit for duty after six days. It is often described as the first controlled clinical trial in history, and it was certainly an impressive one. But it is a mistake to imagine that it settled the matter. In fact, Lind himself seems not to have fully grasped its significance.
When Lind published his Treatise of the Scurvy in 1753, he buried his finding in a book of several hundred pages, and he offered a complicated theory in which the disease was caused by a blockage of the skin's pores in damp sea air, with citrus simply being one of several things that might help. He also tried to preserve lemon juice for long voyages by boiling it down to a thick concentrate, known as a rob. Unknown to him, heating destroys a large part of the active ingredient, and the rob failed to work well. It is hardly surprising that the Admiralty, faced with a host of competing cures, did not rush to act. Malt was favoured by a number of leading physicians, and Captain Cook, whose crews famously suffered little from scurvy, gave much of the credit for this to malt and sauerkraut. His reputation may have delayed progress, as the true reasons for his success probably lay in his habit of taking on fresh food at every opportunity.
It was not until 1795, more than forty years after Lind's book, that the Royal Navy finally began issuing lemon juice to all of its sailors, largely as a result of the efforts of Gilbert Blane, a physician who had the ear of those in authority. The effect was dramatic. Scurvy almost vanished from British ships, and some historians have argued that this gave the navy a decisive advantage in blockading France during the Napoleonic Wars, as its ships could stay at sea for many months. The nickname 'limey' for a British sailor came from this practice, although it was based on a later and much less fortunate decision.
In the middle of the nineteenth century, for reasons of economy and imperial trade, the Navy switched from Mediterranean lemons to limes from its own Caribbean colonies. Nobody knew that limes have only about half as much of the active substance, and the juice was also piped through copper tubing, which damages it further. At about the same time, steam power was shortening voyages, so that any failure of the treatment was largely concealed. It was only when polar expeditions began at the end of the century, involving long periods with no fresh food, that the disease returned. Men on Robert Scott's expedition to the Antarctic in 1902 developed scurvy, even though they had lime juice. Medical opinion at that point had drifted so far from the truth that the cause was widely thought to be tainted meat. The knowledge had actually been lost.
The true explanation finally emerged by accident. In 1907, two Norwegian researchers, Axel Holst and Theodor Frølich, were studying a different disease, and they happened to choose guinea pigs as their subjects. By chance, guinea pigs are among the very few animals that, like humans, cannot make their own vitamin C. Fed on a diet of grain, they developed what was clearly scurvy, and it could be cured with fresh vegetables or lemon juice. Had they used rats, which produce the vitamin themselves, the discovery might have been delayed for years. It remained only to identify the substance. In 1932, Albert Szent-Györgyi and Charles King independently isolated vitamin C, or ascorbic acid, the name of which literally means 'without scurvy'.
The history of scurvy is a useful corrective to the idea that medical knowledge advances in a straight line. A remedy that was tested and effective could be misunderstood, ignored, and then actually forgotten. This was not simply a matter of stupidity on the part of those concerned. As long as nobody understood the mechanism, it was perfectly reasonable to weigh Lind's small experiment against the claims of respected doctors and against the experience of a captain as distinguished as Cook. Without a theory which could explain why one fruit differed from another, there was no way of knowing what had gone wrong when a treatment appeared to fail.
1Scurvy caused more deaths among sailors than all other dangers at sea put together.
2Lind's trial was immediately recognised as a major advance by other doctors.
3Lind understood clearly that citrus fruit was the only effective treatment.
4Cook's ships carried more fresh citrus fruit than any others at the time.
5Blane was personally acquainted with Lind.
6The change to limes was made partly in order to save money.
11Why was the choice of guinea pigs in 1907 important?
12What does the writer say about those who ignored Lind's result?
13What is the main idea of the passage?
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 14–26, which are based on Reading Passage 2 below.
A Few scientific ideas of recent decades have travelled as far beyond the laboratory as the claim that trees talk to one another. Popular books, documentaries and even films have described forests as vast cooperative societies in which ancient 'mother trees' nurture their offspring, sending them food through a hidden network of underground fungi. It is an image of great beauty, and one that seems to have changed how many people feel about forests. The question which is now being asked with growing urgency, by a number of forest ecologists themselves, is how much of it is actually supported by the evidence.
B That fungi and plants live in close association is not in doubt. Around 90 per cent of land plants form relationships known as mycorrhizas, in which the fine threads of a fungus enter or wrap around the roots. The fungus, which can spread far through the soil, gathers water, nitrogen and phosphorus, and passes some of these to the plant. In return, the plant supplies sugars, produced through photosynthesis. This much has been understood since the nineteenth century, and it is one of the foundations of modern ecology. What is more recent is the suggestion that a single fungus can connect the roots of several different trees, in what are called common mycorrhizal networks, and that materials move between them along these links.
C The modern debate began with a paper which appeared in the journal Nature in 1997. Suzanne Simard, then working in British Columbia, grew young Douglas fir and paper birch seedlings together in forest soil. She gave them carbon dioxide that had been labelled with different radioactive forms of carbon, and she then measured where it ended up. Carbon had moved in both directions between the species, and the birch appeared to give more to the fir than it got in return, especially when the fir was shaded. On its cover, the journal coined the phrase 'the wood wide web'. Later research by Simard and her colleagues mapped the fungal genes on a Douglas fir plot, and reported that large old trees were linked to dozens of younger ones.
D The story then grew considerably in the telling. In her best-selling memoir of 2021, Simard wrote of trees recognising their own kin, and sending them more carbon as they die. The German forester Peter Wohlleben, in his hugely popular book The Hidden Life of Trees, went further still, using frankly human terms for the friendships and parenting that he described. Many readers came away with the impression that this was now settled science, and that it had clear implications for how forests ought to be managed. Scientific bodies and governments have begun citing the networks in their policies on forest protection.
E In 2023, a review in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution, led by Justine Karst of the University of Alberta, delivered a sharp challenge. Karst, who had herself published on mycorrhizas, and two colleagues examined the field work on which three common claims were based. They concluded that the evidence that such networks are widespread in forests was thin, since mapping has been done in only a handful of species and places, often using a limited number of samples. Studies which reported that seedlings grew better when linked to mature trees had often failed to rule out other explanations. For example, roots and fungi might simply have absorbed resources from the surrounding soil, without any direct transfer. Only about half of the relevant studies found a positive effect, and many showed a neutral or even a harmful one.
F Their sharpest words were reserved for the way the science has been reported. They found that citations of the original field studies had become increasingly positive over time, and that a large proportion of papers described the results in stronger terms than the evidence warranted. Whether trees direct resources to their relatives, or use networks to warn one another of insect attacks, were claims which were based on just a few experiments, mostly on seedlings in pots. Karst stressed that she was not saying that the networks do not exist or that they have no importance, merely that the existing data do not justify the confidence with which they have been presented. Simard, for her part, has responded that the field is young, that much of her work has been repeated, and that it would be dangerous to wait for perfect proof before changing the way forests are logged.
G It is worth stepping back to consider why this debate has been so heated. Part of the reason is practical: forestry decisions, such as how many old trees should be left when an area is cut, are at stake. But the deeper issue may concern the kinds of story we find attractive. A forest of cooperating families is an appealing alternative to the older picture of nature as merely competitive, and those who wish to protect forests have an obvious reason to welcome it. Yet evolutionary theory offers good reasons to be cautious, as a fungus has its own interests, and it may be moving carbon for its own benefit, not for that of the tree. The case for protecting old forests, as many on both sides point out, is strong without needing these networks at all, since such forests store large amounts of carbon and shelter many species. It may be that the science will be best served by keeping those two questions apart.
14Paragraph B
15Paragraph C
16Paragraph D
17Paragraph E
18Paragraph F
19Paragraph G
20A delay in acting on the science could cause harm.
21Older trees may recognise their relatives.
22Only a small range of species has been properly mapped.
23Relationships between trees can be described in human language.
Experiments claiming that seedlings benefit from links to older trees have not excluded the possibility that materials came from the 24. Claims about warnings between trees rest on a few studies, mostly of seedlings in 25. There is also the point that a 26 may act in its own interests, and not those of the tree.
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27–40, which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
Do you know how a toilet works? Most people, if you ask them, will say that they do. Ask them to rate their understanding on a scale of one to seven, and they will give a fairly confident score. Then ask them to write out, step by step, what actually happens when the handle is pressed, and something rather embarrassing tends to occur. They begin well, falter, and fall silent. When they are asked to rate their understanding for a second time, their scores drop sharply. This simple procedure, first used by Leonid Rozenblit and Frank Keil at Yale in 2002, revealed what they called the illusion of explanatory depth, and I would suggest that it is among the most important discoveries of recent psychology, for reasons which go well beyond bathroom plumbing.
The illusion is a specific one. Rozenblit and Keil found that it applies most strongly to devices and natural processes, such as how a zip fastener works or why there are tides. It is much weaker in the case of facts, such as the capital of a country, or for stories, such as the plot of a film. When you do not know a capital, you know that you do not know it. Explanations are different. We can look at a zip and see the parts, and that visible surface gives us a feeling of understanding what is in fact only familiarity. Moreover, explanations have a layered structure, so that being able to give the first step feels like knowing the whole thing.
Why should we be so badly misled? Steven Sloman and Philip Fernbach have offered what I regard as the most persuasive answer, in their book The Knowledge Illusion. Human knowledge, they argue, is not stored mainly in individual heads. It is distributed across communities, tools and the environment. No single person knows how to build a modern aircraft, or even a pencil, and yet we use these things without difficulty, because we have access to what others know. Evolution did not equip the individual mind to store detailed models of the world, as this would be costly and largely pointless. The problem is that we fail to notice where our own knowledge ends and that of others begins. We count what is available to us as if it were inside our own minds.
Evidence for this confusion comes from studies of internet use. Matthew Fisher and his colleagues, also at Yale, asked one group of participants to look up the answers to some questions online, and a second group to answer them with no such help. Later, on a completely unrelated set of topics, those who had recently used the internet rated their own knowledge more highly. Astonishingly, the effect was present even when their search had produced nothing useful. Simply having the tool at hand seems to inflate one's sense of personal competence. I find this result troubling. We have built a technology that makes it easier than it has ever been to confuse access to information with mastery of it.
The consequences are most serious in politics. In a 2013 study, Fernbach and his colleagues asked American participants for their views on policies such as a single-payer health system or a national flat tax, and then to explain in detail how the policy would work. Attempting the explanation made people less sure of their understanding, and it also made their positions more moderate. By contrast, when they were asked merely to list their reasons for holding a view, they became no less extreme. This is important. Giving reasons merely allows us to repeat what supports our team. An attempt to explain forces us to confront how little we know. Other work has found that those who are the most strongly opposed to genetically modified foods are also the most confident of their knowledge about them, while they score lowest on actual tests of it.
It would be easy to draw a gloomy conclusion from this, but I think that this would be mistaken. Recognising that knowledge is communal should not lead us to think that individuals are foolish. Dependence on others is not a flaw in human intelligence: it is the source of its power. A surgeon does not need to understand how the steel in her scalpel was produced, and it would be a poor use of her time for her to try. What matters is not that we should each know everything, which is impossible, but that we should have a fairly accurate picture of what we do not know, and that we should know whom to trust.
This has some practical implications. In education, there is a good case for asking students more often to explain, in their own words, rather than merely to recognise a correct answer on a test. In public debate, moderators might get further by asking 'How exactly would that work?' than by asking 'Why do you believe that?'. And each of us could occasionally try the toilet test on our most firmly held opinions. It is not a comfortable experience. Then again, a little discomfort of this kind may be a small price to pay for a more honest relationship with the limits of our own minds.
27What happened in the Rozenblit and Keil procedure?
28According to paragraph 2, why do we misjudge our understanding of devices?
29According to Sloman and Fernbach, the illusion occurs because people
30What was surprising about the study by Fisher and colleagues?
31The significance of the illusion of explanatory depth extends far beyond its original setting.
32The internet has reduced people's ability to concentrate.
33Asking people to give reasons for a political view is as effective as asking for an explanation.
34Relying on the knowledge of others is a weakness in human intelligence.
35Multiple-choice tests should be banned from schools.
Tip: select words in the passage to highlight them in yellow, green or pink, or to add a note. Your highlights and answers are saved on this device until you submit.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.
Jitender SinghFounder & Managing Director
Vikram SinghHead – Quality & Operations
SanjayHead – Tourist Visa Operations
TejaswaniHead – Counselling Team
MahimaHead – Visa Filing & Processing
Pratigya DuttaHead – Student Visa ProcessingFree, no-pressure guidance from a real counsellor who handles your case end to end — from documents to decision.