In many cities, governments spend large amounts of money on building new roads. Some people think this money would be better spent on improving public transport.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Why this is Band 6: Answers the question, gives both views and an opinion, with clear paragraphs. Ideas are not developed in much depth, and there are errors ('traffic jam', 'less cars', 'government improve'). The linking is mechanical ('First of all', 'Moreover').
Nowadays traffic is a big problem in many cities, and governments are spending a lot of money for new roads. Some people believe that this is the right way, but other people think public transport should get this money. In this essay I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, new roads have many benefits. First of all, more roads can reduce traffic jam because cars have more space to move. For example, in my city Ludhiana a new flyover was made and now people reach the market more quickly than before. Also, roads are necessary for business because trucks carry goods from one place to another place. If the roads are bad, the goods will be late and companies lose money.
On the other hand, many people say that public transport is better. The main reason is that one bus can carry many people, so there are less cars on the road. This also reduce pollution, which is a serious problem in big cities now. Moreover, not everybody has a car. Poor people and students depend on buses and trains, so if the government improve them, it will help these people too. In Delhi, the metro is very popular because it is cheap and fast and many people leave their car at home.
In my opinion, public transport is more important than new roads. Although roads are also needed, I think that if we make more roads then more people will buy cars and the problem will come again. Therefore, government should spend more money on buses and metro trains, and this will be better for people and environment.
275 words
Why this is Band 7: Both views are well developed with relevant examples, and the position is clear. Cohesion is natural, and vocabulary is good ('congestion', 'freight', 'affordable alternative'). There are few errors, although the range is less sophisticated than Band 8.
Traffic congestion has become a daily problem in many cities, and governments often respond by building more roads. While some people support this approach, others argue that the money should instead be used to improve public transport. In this essay, I will look at both opinions before explaining why I favour the second.
Those who support new road construction point out that roads are essential to the economy. Goods reach shops and factories by lorry, and delays cost businesses a great deal of money. In addition, many people live in places which are not served by trains or buses, particularly in the suburbs and rural areas, so they have little choice but to drive. A new bypass or flyover can therefore save these people a considerable amount of time and reduce the amount of heavy traffic passing through residential streets.
On the other hand, there are strong arguments for investing in buses and trains. A single train can carry as many passengers as hundreds of cars, while taking up far less space, which is an important consideration in a crowded city. Good public transport also reduces air pollution, and it benefits people who cannot afford a car or are unable to drive, such as students and the elderly. The Delhi Metro is a good example, since it has given millions of commuters a quick and affordable alternative.
In my view, public transport should be the priority. Experience in many cities shows that new roads quickly fill up, as they encourage more people to drive, so the benefit is often only temporary. That said, some road building will always be necessary, especially for freight. Overall, however, governments would achieve more lasting results by making public transport so convenient that people choose to use it.
293 words
Why this is Band 8: A clear position from the first paragraph, with ideas developed by precise reasoning ('induced demand', 'a problem of space'). Vocabulary is precise and natural and sentences are varied and accurate. The final paragraph qualifies the opinion instead of just repeating it.
As urban populations grow and congestion worsens, city authorities face a difficult decision about how to spend their transport budgets. Although there is a case for building additional roads, I would argue that public transport offers far greater long-term benefits.
The argument for new roads rests largely on economic grounds and on the realities of how people live. Businesses depend on the reliable movement of goods, and in most countries the final stage of almost every delivery is made by road. Furthermore, many households, particularly those in outlying districts, have no practical alternative to the car, and for them a new ring road or bypass can mean a real improvement in the quality of daily life. It can also bring relief to residential neighbourhoods by diverting heavy vehicles away from their streets.
Nevertheless, those who favour investment in public transport have, in my opinion, the more persuasive case. The central problem is one of space: a city simply cannot accommodate an unlimited number of private cars, whereas a metro line can move tens of thousands of passengers an hour using a fraction of the land. There is also considerable evidence of what planners call induced demand, meaning that new roads tend to encourage additional car journeys until they become as congested as the old ones. Public transport, by contrast, cuts emissions and gives mobility to those who are too young, too old or too poor to drive. The transformation of commuting in cities with new metro systems, such as Delhi, illustrates how quickly behaviour can change when a reliable alternative exists.
This is not to suggest that road building should stop altogether, since freight and rural access will continue to require it. However, in densely populated cities, spending should be directed mainly towards buses and trains, as this is the only approach that tackles the cause of congestion rather than merely delaying its return.
314 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 gives its opinion only at the end; Band 8 signals it from the introduction and keeps it clear.
Development: Band 6 lists a reason and a short example; Bands 7 and 8 explain why the reason matters.
Vocabulary: Band 6 uses general words ('big problem', 'many benefits'); Band 8 uses precise phrases ('outlying districts', 'induced demand').
Cohesion: Band 6 relies on 'First of all' and 'Moreover'; Band 8 links ideas with reference words and meaning ('This is not to suggest...').
Grammar: Band 6 has frequent small errors; Band 8 uses complex sentences with very few errors.
Tips for this task
This is a 'discuss both views' question: you must cover both sides and give your own opinion.
Spend five minutes planning. Decide on your opinion and one or two main ideas for each view.
One well-explained idea with an example is better than three short undeveloped ideas.
Do not memorise an introduction. Examiners do not count memorised language, and it will not fit the question.
Leave three minutes to check verb endings, singular and plural forms, and articles.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.