Some people think that it is more important for children to learn practical skills, such as cooking and repairing things, than to study subjects like history and geography.
Do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position with reasons on both sides and a personal example. Language is simple but mostly accurate. It's well organised.
Some people think that children should learn practical skills like cooking and repairing things, and that these are more important than subjects like history and geography. I do not completely agree with this view, as I think that both kinds of learning are important.
Practical skills are certainly useful. In daily life, everybody has to eat, and it is cheaper and healthier to cook your own food. It is also useful to know how to repair things in your home. Many young people today cannot do these things when they leave home, and they spend a lot of money on takeaway food and on paying other people. For example, when my cousin moved to another city for his job, he could not even make tea.
However, I think that subjects like history and geography are also very important. History teaches us about the past, so that we can understand why the world is like it is today. Geography teaches us about other countries and about problems such as climate change. These subjects help children to become educated people who can understand the news and think about the world. Without this knowledge, they will not be able to vote wisely. They are also needed for many jobs, for example teaching or working in tourism.
In conclusion, I disagree that practical skills are more important than these subjects. Schools should teach both of them, because children need to learn how to look after themselves and also how to understand the world. A good education should prepare them for all parts of life.
260 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced and well-developed essay. Good range ('in short supply', 'a broad understanding'), with a very clear conclusion.
It is sometimes argued that schools spend too much time on academic subjects, and that children would benefit more from learning practical skills. Although I can see the value of such skills, I do not agree that they are more important than subjects such as history and geography.
There is a strong case for teaching practical skills. Many young adults now leave home with no idea of how to cook a healthy meal or to change a fuse, and this costs them time and money. Such lessons can also be very valuable for those who do not do well in traditional subjects, as they give them a chance to succeed. Indeed, skilled tradespeople are in short supply in many countries, so this kind of training could lead directly to a good job.
Nevertheless, I believe that academic subjects offer something that practical skills cannot. History helps young people to understand how their society came to be what it is, and it teaches them to question what they are told. Geography gives them a knowledge of the wider world, along with the issues that face it, such as migration and climate change. In a democracy, citizens need this kind of understanding if they are to make sensible decisions. It is also worth noting that many practical skills can be learned at home or from the internet, whereas a broad understanding of the world is much harder to pick up alone.
In conclusion, while practical skills deserve a place in the school timetable, they should not replace academic subjects. Schools should aim to produce young people who are able to cook a meal and also to understand the news.
277 words
Why this is Band 8: An original and thoughtful argument, asking what schools are for. It has very natural language ('a form of snobbery', 'see through a politician'), and a memorable final sentence.
Those who complain that schools produce young people who can discuss the causes of the First World War, but who cannot boil an egg, have a point. I have met some of them. Yet I think that the argument rests on a false choice, and if we really did have to choose, I would not put practical skills first.
Let me begin by accepting what is right in this view. Practical skills are undervalued, and this is a form of snobbery. A child who is good with her hands is too often made to feel stupid, even though a society depends on electricians at least as much as it depends on lawyers. Knowing how to cook and how to fix things also gives people a very real kind of independence, and it can save them a good deal of money. There is little doubt that most schools could do more in this area.
But the question is what a school is for. Almost anybody can learn how to cook from a parent, a friend or a video, when they need to. Nobody is likely to stumble upon the history of their country, or to learn on their own how the climate works, or why some nations are rich and others are poor. These are things that most people will only ever meet at school. Moreover, they are what makes it possible for someone to read a newspaper with understanding, and to see through a politician who is misrepresenting the past. A person who can fix a tap but who has no sense of history is rather easily fooled.
I would therefore say that practical skills deserve far more respect and a little more time, but not at the expense of subjects that open up the world. The aim of a school is not just to help children to survive, but to help them to understand what they are surviving in.
320 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 starts with a lively example.
Argument: only Band 8 says that history is something that people won't learn elsewhere.
Respect: Band 8 raises the question of snobbery.
Vocabulary: 'very useful' (6), 'in short supply' (7), 'undervalued' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 finishes with a clear statement about what school is for.
Tips for this task
Say clearly whether you agree or disagree.
Accept what's right about the other side.
Give examples of practical skills, and of what history teaches.
Avoid saying that one kind of subject is useless.
Finish with a sentence that sums up your position.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.