Some people say that everyone should eat less meat, for the sake of their health and the environment.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion, with relevant reasons and a sensible exception. Language is simple and accurate, and it's well organised.
These days, many people say that we should eat less meat, because it is better for our health and for the environment. In my opinion, I mostly agree with this idea, although I do not think that everyone needs to stop eating meat completely.
First of all, eating too much meat can be bad for our health. Red meat in particular has a lot of fat, and doctors say that it can cause heart disease and some other illnesses. People who eat more vegetables, fruit and beans are often healthier. In my country, many people have been vegetarians for hundreds of years, and they live healthy lives.
Secondly, producing meat is bad for the environment. Cows produce a gas which causes global warming, and they need a lot of land and water. In some countries, forests are cut down in order to make space for cattle. If people ate less meat, there would be more land to grow food, and there would be less pollution.
However, there are some reasons why it is not possible for everyone. In some places, such as very cold countries, people cannot grow many vegetables, so they need meat. Meat is also a good source of protein and iron, especially for children. For poor people, a little meat may be very important for their health.
In conclusion, I believe that most people in rich countries should eat less meat, because it is good for their health and for the planet. They do not have to stop eating it, but they could eat it only a few times a week. I think that this is a good balance.
272 words
Why this is Band 7: Well developed, with good vocabulary ('saturated fat', 'cut down'), and it separates the arguments clearly. It has a thoughtful conclusion.
There is growing pressure on people to reduce the amount of meat in their diet, on both health and environmental grounds. I largely agree with this view, particularly as it applies to people in wealthy countries, although I would not say that it should apply to everyone.
The health argument is reasonably strong. A number of studies have linked high consumption of red and processed meat to heart disease and to certain types of cancer. A diet based mainly on vegetables, grains and pulses tends to be lower in saturated fat and higher in fibre, and those who follow it often enjoy better health. Millions of people in India have lived on such diets for generations.
The environmental case is even clearer. Raising animals, especially cattle, uses very large amounts of land and water, and it is responsible for a significant share of the world's greenhouse gas emissions. In parts of South America, forest continues to be cleared for grazing. Even a modest reduction in meat consumption by large numbers of people could have a considerable effect.
Nevertheless, it would be wrong to demand the same of everyone. For people in many poorer communities, meat, fish or eggs may be one of the few available sources of protein and vitamins, and they already eat far less than the average person in the West. In some regions, too, the land is not suitable for growing crops, and keeping animals may be the only way of producing food.
In conclusion, those who currently eat large quantities of meat have good reasons to cut down, but this advice should not be applied without considering people's circumstances.
273 words
Why this is Band 8: An original opening, which focuses on the word 'everyone'. It has a nuanced view of the health evidence, strong arguments on fairness, and an amusing ending.
My grandmother, who never read a study in her life, ate meat about six times a year, at weddings. My cousin in Toronto, who has read quite a lot of them, eats it six times a week. The advice that 'everyone' should eat less meat makes very little sense to the first of those people, and I think that it makes a great deal of sense to the second. So my answer is that I agree, but that the word 'everyone' is where the difficulty lies.
For people who are eating as my cousin does, the evidence is fairly hard to dispute. The health case is real, if sometimes overstated: heavy consumption of red and processed meat is associated with higher rates of heart disease and of some cancers, though the size of these effects is often exaggerated in newspaper headlines. The environmental case is far stronger. Beef in particular requires a remarkable amount of land and produces far more greenhouse gases than almost any other food. It is difficult to see how the world can reach its climate targets if meat consumption continues to rise as it has been doing.
But consider who is being told to change. A child in rural Africa or in parts of India who has a little milk, an egg or some fish is not part of this problem. In fact, for such a child, those foods may make the difference between normal growth and permanent damage. In dry areas where nothing else will grow, herding is not a lifestyle choice, but the only available way to turn grass into food. To tell such people to eat less meat, because of emissions that were largely produced by others, is rather unjust.
The sensible version of this advice is thus much narrower: those who eat the most should eat less, starting with beef. That, as it happens, would take us back to something more like my grandmother's habits, except perhaps for the weddings.
328 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 contrasts a grandmother and a cousin.
Evidence: Band 8 says that the effects are sometimes exaggerated.
Fairness: Band 8 discusses who produced the emissions.