Some people think that all children should learn to play a musical instrument at school.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position (largely agree) with several relevant reasons and a fair acknowledgement of the other side. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
Music is an important part of life, and some people believe that all children should learn to play a musical instrument at school. I largely agree with this idea, because I believe that learning an instrument has many benefits for children, although I understand that it is not right for everyone.
There are several good reasons for teaching all children an instrument. Firstly, learning music teaches useful skills, such as patience, discipline and concentration, because you have to practise regularly to improve, and these skills help children in all their other subjects too. Secondly, playing music is a wonderful way to express yourself and to enjoy yourself, and it can bring a lot of happiness throughout a person's whole life.
Thirdly, learning an instrument is often a social activity, as children play together in groups and orchestras, which teaches them to work as a team and to listen to others. Many children who learn an instrument at school make friends and gain confidence from performing, which is very valuable.
However, I do understand the other side. Not every child enjoys music, and for some, being forced to learn an instrument could be unpleasant and could even put them off music for life. Musical instruments and lessons can also be expensive for schools to provide for everyone.
In my opinion, every child should at least have the chance to try learning an instrument at school, even if they do not continue with it. In conclusion, although it may not suit everyone, I largely agree that learning a musical instrument should be part of every child's education, because the benefits are so great.
271 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-argued essay that supports teaching an instrument to all while distinguishing opportunity from compulsion, and recognising the costs. Good vocabulary ('self-discipline', 'a lifelong source of joy') and a clear, qualified position.
Music is one of the great pleasures of human life, and many people believe that every child should have the chance to learn an instrument at school. I agree with this view, though I would argue that the goal should be opportunity rather than compulsion.
There are strong reasons for teaching children to play. Learning an instrument is wonderful training in self-discipline and concentration, since there is no way to improve except through patient, regular practice, and these habits carry over into every other area of a child's education. Beyond this, music is a lifelong source of joy and a powerful means of self-expression, and a child who learns to play may gain a pleasure that enriches their entire life.
There are also valuable social benefits. Much music is made together, in bands, choirs and orchestras, which teaches children to cooperate, to listen to one another and to contribute to a shared effort. Performing, too, can give a shy child a real boost of confidence, and the friendships formed through music can be among the strongest.
I do, however, recognise that music does not suit everyone, and that forcing a reluctant child to practise could be miserable and even turn them against music for good. There is also the real cost to schools of providing instruments and lessons for all.
My own view is that the answer is to give every child the genuine opportunity to try an instrument, and real encouragement, without forcing those who truly dislike it to continue.
In conclusion, while it cannot be right to compel every child, I strongly agree that learning a musical instrument should be offered to all, because its benefits, to the mind, the spirit and the social life of a child, are so great.
293 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that examines the tension hidden in 'should', fully credits the benefits of learning an instrument, and resolves the question by distinguishing 'the chance from the duty' ('open a door, not force every child through it'). Nuanced and persuasive.
Should every child be handed a violin or a recorder at school, whether they like it or not? The idea that all children should learn a musical instrument has obvious appeal, and I broadly support it – but I think the case has to be made carefully, because the word 'should' hides a real tension between opportunity and compulsion.
The benefits of learning to play are genuinely impressive, and go well beyond music itself. Mastering an instrument is a slow, patient business, impossible without regular practice, and in learning it a child quietly acquires self-discipline, concentration and the deep satisfaction of improving at something hard – habits that serve them in every subject and every walk of life. On top of this, music offers a lifelong source of joy and expression, and, made together in bands and choirs, it teaches cooperation and gives many a shy child a priceless dose of confidence.
And yet I hesitate at the word 'all', if it means compulsion. Children are not identical; a few will take to an instrument with delight, many will enjoy it, but some will simply hate it, and forcing those few to grind through years of unwilling practice risks souring them on music forever – the very opposite of what we intend.
The resolution, I think, lies in distinguishing the chance from the duty. Every child should be given a real, properly supported opportunity to learn an instrument, and genuine encouragement to persevere through the difficult early stages, since many who would have loved it never discover this without a push. But those few who, having truly tried, find no joy in it should be free to turn to other things.
In conclusion, I agree that every child should have the chance to learn a musical instrument, because the rewards are so rich – but the aim should be to open a door, not to force every child through it.
320 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 lists benefits; Band 8 argues the real value is the chance, not compulsion.
Examples: both mention teamwork and confidence; Band 7 develops them.
Vocabulary: 'patience and discipline' (6), 'self-discipline' (7).
Depth: Band 7 stresses giving every child the opportunity.
Conclusion: both largely agree; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Make your position clear: how far do you agree?
Give the benefits of learning an instrument.
Acknowledge that it does not suit everyone.
Use examples (teamwork, confidence).
Reach a clear conclusion.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.