Some people believe that children should start learning a foreign language at primary school, while others think it is better to wait until secondary school.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position (start young) with relevant reasons on both sides. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
There is much debate about the best age for children to start learning a foreign language. Some people think they should start young, at primary school, while others think it is better to wait until secondary school. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who believe children should start young have strong arguments. It is well known that young children learn languages much more easily than older people; they pick up new words and sounds quickly, and without the fear of making mistakes that holds older learners back. Many believe that if you want someone to speak a language really well, with a good accent, they must start as a young child.
On the other hand, some people think it is better to wait. They argue that young children have enough to learn already, in reading, writing and number, and that adding a foreign language could be too much. They also point out that older children can learn more quickly in some ways, because they can understand the grammar and rules of a language, which young children cannot.
In my opinion, the benefits of starting young are too great to ignore. I believe children should begin a foreign language at primary school, but in a fun, gentle way, through games and songs, rather than through serious study, so that it does not become a burden. The serious study can come later.
In conclusion, although there are arguments for waiting, I believe it is better for children to start learning a foreign language at primary school, because young children learn languages so naturally and so well.
271 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that gives both views their due and argues for a playful early start, resting on the young learner's natural advantage. Good vocabulary ('free of self-consciousness') and a clear, qualified position.
At what age should a child begin a foreign language – in the early years of primary school, or later, at secondary school? Both sides of this debate have real evidence behind them, but on balance I believe an early start is better, provided it is done in the right way.
The case for starting young is powerful, and rests on a well-established fact: young children absorb languages with an ease that adults can only envy. They soak up new sounds and words almost without effort, and, crucially, they are free of the self-consciousness and fear of error that so often hold older learners back. It is widely accepted that to acquire a truly native-like accent, one must begin very young, as the ability to do so seems to fade as we grow up.
Those who argue for waiting are not without a point, however. Young children already have a great deal to learn, in reading, writing and arithmetic, and there is a risk of overloading them. They also note that older children can, in some ways, learn faster, because they can grasp the rules and grammar of a language in a way that is beyond the very young.
My own view is that the natural advantage of the young learner is simply too valuable to waste. I believe children should meet a foreign language at primary school, but through songs, games and play rather than formal grammar lessons, so that it is a pleasure, not a burden. The serious, rule-based study can follow later, building on those early, joyful foundations.
In conclusion, while there are arguments for waiting, I am convinced that a playful early start at primary school makes the most of children's remarkable natural gift for languages.
290 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that grounds the case in the 'window' for language learning, gives the waiting view a fair hearing, and resolves the tension by distinguishing a playful early start from formal study. Vivid and persuasive.
Few things reveal the strange brilliance of the young mind more clearly than the ease with which a small child picks up a language, and that fact sits at the heart of the question of when children should start a foreign one. Some would begin at primary school, others would wait for secondary; I come down firmly, though not unconditionally, on the side of starting early.
The argument for an early start is rooted in how human beings actually learn languages. There appears to be a window, in the early years, during which children absorb a language almost effortlessly, catching its sounds and rhythms in a way that becomes steadily harder as we age; it is why a child can arrive in a new country speaking not a word and be fluent, accent and all, within a year, while their parents struggle for a decade. To let that window close unused seems a genuine waste.
The case for waiting deserves a fair hearing. Young children are already busy mastering reading, writing and number, and there is a real danger of piling on too much. And older children do have one advantage: they can understand the explicit rules of grammar, which baffle the very young, and so can make rapid progress of a different kind.
But these objections, I think, argue less against an early start than for a particular kind of one. The answer is not to drill five-year-olds in grammar, but to let them meet a language as they meet their own – through songs, games, stories and play, soaking it up for pleasure. The formal study can come later, resting on those easy early foundations.
In conclusion, children should begin a foreign language at primary school, but playfully rather than formally, so that we make the most of a natural gift that, sadly, does not last.
308 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 states young children learn easily; Band 8 explains the 'window' for accent.
Examples: both mention accent and grammar; Band 7 develops them.
Vocabulary: 'pick up words quickly' (6), 'absorb a language effortlessly' (7).
Depth: Band 7 stresses a playful early start, not formal study.
Conclusion: both favour starting young; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Discuss both an early and a later start.
Give reasons for each (ease of learning, understanding grammar).
Consider how the language should be taught to the young.
Make your own opinion clear.
Use a separate paragraph for each view.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.