In many countries, young people are leaving villages and small towns to live in big cities.
What problems does this cause, and what can be done to solve them?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both parts of the question are answered, with a logical structure and a personal example. Ideas are relevant but simple, and linking is mechanical ('The first problem', 'First', 'Second'). Vocabulary is everyday ('costly', 'good life'), with some awkward phrasing.
Nowadays many young people move from their villages to big cities because they want good jobs and a better life. This is creating many problems for both villages and cities. In this essay I will discuss these problems and give some solutions.
The first problem is for the villages. When the young people leave, only old people are living there, and there is nobody to work on the farms. For example, in my state Punjab many farmers have no one to help them because their sons went to the city or foreign countries. Also, the shops and schools in villages are closing because there are not enough people. The second problem is for the cities. There are too many people in the cities, so the houses are very costly and the traffic is very bad. Many young people have to live in small rooms, and they also pay a lot of rent.
There are some solutions to these problems. First, the government should create more jobs in small towns by opening factories and offices there. If people get a good job near their home, then they will not go to the cities. Second, the government should improve the facilities in villages, like schools, hospitals and internet. Nowadays, many people can work from home on the internet, so a good connection can help them to stay in their village.
In conclusion, young people moving to the cities causes problems for the villages and the cities. The government should make more jobs and improve facilities in the small places, so people can have a good life there too.
266 words
Why this is Band 7: Well organised, with clear topic sentences and developed ideas ('ageing population', 'puts a strain on'). Solutions are linked to the problems, and there are few errors. Fairly predictable compared with Band 8.
In many parts of the world, young people are increasingly leaving rural areas in search of opportunities in large cities. Although this is understandable, it has created serious problems for both the places they leave and those they move to. This essay will consider these problems and suggest some possible solutions.
The most obvious effect is on the countryside. As young people leave, villages are left with an ageing population and a shortage of workers, particularly in agriculture. Local shops, schools and bus services may then close because there are too few customers, which makes these places even less attractive. At the same time, big cities come under great pressure. The arrival of so many new residents pushes up the cost of housing, increases traffic and puts a strain on public services such as hospitals.
There are, however, ways of dealing with these issues. The most effective solution would be to create more employment outside the major cities. Governments could offer tax reductions to companies which set up offices or factories in smaller towns, for example. Secondly, investment in rural services is essential. If villages had reliable internet access, good schools and decent healthcare, young people would have fewer reasons to leave, and many could even work from home for companies based elsewhere.
In conclusion, the movement of young people to cities harms rural communities and overcrowds urban areas. Although this trend cannot be stopped completely, governments can slow it by encouraging employers to move to smaller towns and by improving services in the countryside.
255 words
Why this is Band 8: Develops a clear line of reasoning ('vicious circle'), with insight into cause and effect. Solutions are specific and relevant to today's world. Vocabulary is precise and natural ('overloads transport networks', 'economically viable'), and the conclusion adds a final thought.
The drift of young people from the countryside to major cities is one of the defining social trends of our time. While each individual decision may be perfectly rational, the combined effect has been to weaken rural communities while placing an increasing burden on urban ones. Fortunately, there are practical steps that could be taken to reduce the damage.
For villages and small towns, the loss of their younger residents can start a vicious circle. With fewer people of working age, farms struggle to find labour, and shops and schools lose the customers and pupils they need to survive. Once these services have gone, the area becomes still less appealing, and those who remain, who are often elderly, may find themselves increasingly isolated. Cities, meanwhile, face the opposite problem. Rapid growth drives up rents, overloads transport networks and hospitals, and may force newcomers into poor-quality housing on the edge of town, far from the opportunities that attracted them in the first place.
The key to tackling this is to give young people a genuine choice about where to live. Above all, this means bringing work to smaller communities. Since the pandemic, many office jobs can be done from anywhere, so reliable high-speed internet may now be the single most valuable investment that a rural area can receive. Governments could also use tax incentives to persuade employers to set up outside the capital, and they could move some of their own departments, as several countries have already done. Finally, cities themselves need to plan ahead, by building affordable homes close to public transport.
In short, this movement of people cannot and should not be reversed by force. However, by making rural life economically viable and urban growth better managed, societies could ensure that moving to the city is a choice rather than a necessity.
303 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Structure: all three have problems and then solutions, but Band 8 also connects them with one main idea, giving people a choice.
Ideas: Band 6 says shops close; Band 8 explains how this makes the area less attractive and leads to further decline.
Solutions: Band 6 says 'create more jobs'; Band 8 says how: internet, tax incentives, moving government departments.
Vocabulary: 'very costly' (6), 'pushes up the cost of housing' (7), 'drives up rents' (8).
Tone: Band 6 says what 'should' be done; Band 8 weighs what is realistic.
Tips for this task
A problem and solution essay needs clear paragraphs: one for problems, and one for solutions.
Make sure each solution answers a problem you mentioned.
Say how a solution would work, and who would do it.