Some people think that all school students should wear a uniform.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with two developed reasons and a counter-argument. The structure is clear, though linking is formulaic. Errors are present ('waste time ... to choose'), but they don't block communication.
In many countries, students have to wear a uniform when they go to school. Some people think that this should be a rule for all students. I agree with this idea for several reasons, which I will explain in this essay.
Firstly, uniforms make all the students equal. If there is no uniform, the students from rich families will wear expensive clothes and the poor students may feel bad. For example, in my school everybody wore the same blue shirt, so nobody could see who was rich or poor. This helps the children to be friends with each other. It also stops bullying, because some children laugh at others if their clothes are old.
Secondly, uniforms save time and money for families. Parents do not need to buy many clothes for school, and children do not waste time in the morning to choose what they will wear. Uniforms also give students a feeling of discipline, and it helps them to focus on their study and not on fashion.
On the other hand, some people say that uniforms stop children from showing their personality. It is true that young people like to choose their own clothes. Also, some uniforms are expensive and they are not comfortable in hot weather. But I think that students can show their personality in other ways, for example in sports or art, and after school they can wear what they like.
In conclusion, I strongly agree that all students should wear a uniform at school, because it makes them equal, and it saves money for their parents.
261 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear and qualified position, well-organised ideas and good vocabulary ('feel inferior', 'sense of belonging'). Ideas are sensible, and it has a practical suggestion. Few errors.
School uniforms are compulsory in many countries, but in others, students are free to wear what they choose. In my opinion, the advantages of uniforms are greater than the disadvantages, so I largely agree that students should wear them, although schools should be careful about the kind of uniform that they require.
The main argument in favour of uniforms is that they reduce the differences between students from different backgrounds. When everyone is dressed in the same way, there is less pressure to own fashionable clothes, and children from poorer families are less likely to be made to feel inferior. Uniforms may therefore help to reduce some forms of bullying. They can also be cheaper for parents in the long term, since there is no need to buy so many different outfits, and they save time in the morning.
In addition, wearing a uniform can create a sense of belonging to a school community. It may also help students to separate school from free time, and to take their studies more seriously.
However, some critics say that uniforms restrict young people's freedom to express their personality, and that they can be costly and uncomfortable. These are fair points, particularly in the case of older teenagers. For this reason, I believe that uniforms should be simple, affordable and suited to the local climate, and that senior students might be given more choice.
In conclusion, I believe that uniforms benefit students by reducing inequality and building a sense of community, as long as they are practical and not too expensive.
258 words
Why this is Band 8: A subtle position that supports uniforms while rejecting exaggerated claims. Develops reasons with care, using a general reference to research. Vocabulary and grammar are flexible and natural ('marker of wealth', 'hardly a magic solution').
Whether children should be required to wear a uniform to school is a question that arouses surprisingly strong feelings. Supporters see it as a way of promoting equality and discipline, while opponents regard it as an unnecessary restriction. On balance, I am in favour of uniforms, at least for younger pupils, although I believe that some of the claims made on their behalf are exaggerated.
The strongest argument concerns fairness. Children can be cruel about differences in clothing, and a family which cannot afford the latest brands may find that their child is excluded. A simple uniform removes one obvious marker of wealth from the classroom, and it spares parents and children a daily source of pressure. It also has a practical value, as it gives pupils a sense of belonging, and makes it easier for staff to identify who should be on the premises.
That said, uniforms are hardly a magic solution. Children soon find other ways to show their status, through phones or shoes, and research has generally failed to show that uniforms improve behaviour or examination results to any significant degree. There is also the cost to consider. Where parents are forced to buy expensive items from a single approved supplier, the policy can end up harming the very families it was intended to help.
For these reasons, I think that schools should adopt a uniform, but only one that is simple and cheap, and which can be bought from ordinary shops. Teenagers, who are learning to make their own decisions, might reasonably be allowed more flexibility. A uniform is a modest tool which is useful for reducing certain pressures, and it should be treated as nothing more than that.
283 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 'strongly agree'; Band 8 'in favour, but some claims are exaggerated'.
Reasons: Band 8 explains how a uniform removes a 'marker of wealth'.
Counter-argument: Band 8 goes further by showing how uniforms might harm poor families.