In some countries, young people are now expected to do a period of unpaid work for the community, such as helping elderly people or cleaning public spaces, as part of their school education.
Do the advantages of this outweigh the disadvantages?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with relevant advantages and disadvantages and an example. The language is simple but accurate, and the essay is well organised.
In some countries, students have to do unpaid work for their community as part of school. For example, they might visit old people or clean parks. In my opinion, this idea has more advantages than disadvantages.
There are several benefits. First, students learn important things that they cannot learn in a classroom. When they help elderly people, they learn to care about others, and they understand the problems that old people have. This can make them kinder adults. Second, it is good for the community. Parks become cleaner, and lonely people get company. Everybody benefits from this. Third, it can help students in the future, because they get real experience, and this looks good when they apply for a job or university.
However, there are also some disadvantages. The main problem is time. Students today are very busy with their studies and their exams, and this extra work takes time away from that. Some students may also do the work badly, because they are forced to do it and they do not really want to be there. In this case, it is not very useful for anyone.
In my opinion, these problems are not very serious. Schools can give students only a few hours each month, so it will not harm their studies. And even if some students do not enjoy it at first, many of them will change their minds once they see that they are helping real people.
In conclusion, I believe that the advantages of community work for students are greater than the disadvantages, as long as the amount of time is reasonable.
266 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-balanced and developed argument, with good vocabulary ('breed resentment', 'community cohesion') and a thoughtful treatment of the compulsion issue.
In a number of countries, a period of unpaid community service has become a compulsory part of school life, with students expected to help the elderly or to improve public spaces. Although this policy has some drawbacks, I believe that its benefits clearly outweigh them.
The main advantage is educational, in the broadest sense. Young people who spend time helping others develop a sense of responsibility and an understanding of lives very different from their own, which no textbook can provide. A teenager who regularly visits an isolated elderly person, for instance, is likely to grow into a more thoughtful and considerate adult. There are also clear benefits for society: valuable work gets done, and the gap between the generations, which has widened in many places, is narrowed.
The disadvantages, while real, seem to me less weighty. The most obvious is the pressure on students' time, given how demanding modern schooling has become. There is also a reasonable objection that forcing people to 'volunteer' is a contradiction, and that compelled service may breed resentment rather than genuine kindness. Some students will inevitably do the minimum required.
However, these problems can largely be managed. The time involved need only be a few hours a month, which is unlikely to harm anyone's studies. As for the issue of compulsion, my own experience suggests that attitudes often change once the work begins and the results become visible; what starts as an obligation can become a source of real satisfaction.
In conclusion, despite the concerns about time and compulsion, the gains in character and community cohesion are significant, and in my view they outweigh the costs.
272 words
Why this is Band 8: A memorable personal opening and a subtle argument, that the forced encounter is the real point. Very natural style and a precise, qualified conclusion.
My school required every student to spend an afternoon a week, for one term, helping at a local day centre for elderly people. I resented it enormously at the time. Years later, it is one of the few things from school that I am genuinely glad to have been made to do. That small contradiction lies at the heart of this debate, and it largely explains why I think the policy is a good one, despite its obvious flaws.
The case against is not frivolous. The word 'unpaid' does some quiet work here: society is, in effect, extracting free labour from the young, and dressing it up as education. There is a real risk, too, that compulsory kindness is no kindness at all, and that a resentful teenager mopping a floor badly helps nobody, while learning only that such work is a punishment. And the time has to come from somewhere, usually from study or rest, both of which are already under pressure.
Yet I think these objections, though fair, miss what such schemes are actually for. Their value lies precisely in the fact that the students would not otherwise have chosen to go. Left to themselves, most young people never spend time with the very old, or see the parts of their town that are usually kept out of sight. The scheme forces an encounter that would never happen naturally, and it is that encounter, rather than the work itself, that does the educating. The floor being mopped matters far less than the conversation that happens while it is being mopped.
My conclusion, then, is a qualified yes. The advantages do outweigh the disadvantages, but only if the scheme is designed to bring young people into genuine contact with others, rather than simply to provide a source of cheap labour. Get that right, and the occasional resentful teenager is a price well worth paying.
315 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with the writer's own school experience.
Argument: Band 6 lists benefits; Band 8 argues that the forced encounter is the point.
Counter-argument: Band 8 takes the 'free labour' objection seriously.
Vocabulary: 'important things' (6), 'a sense of responsibility' (7), 'compulsory kindness' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 gives a condition for its 'yes'.
Tips for this task
Decide clearly whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages.
Give real examples of the community work and its effects.
Deal honestly with the problem of forcing people to 'volunteer'.
Think about who benefits and who does the work.
Make your conclusion follow from your argument.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.