Some people believe that governments should spend public money on supporting the arts, such as music, painting and theatre. Others argue that this money would be better spent on public services, such as healthcare and education.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are covered, with a clear opinion and relevant reasons. The language is simple but accurate, and the essay is well organised.
People have different opinions about whether the government should spend money on the arts, or on public services like hospitals and schools. In this essay, I will discuss both views before giving my own opinion.
On the one hand, some people think that the government should support the arts. Music, painting and theatre are an important part of a country's culture, and they make people's lives richer and more enjoyable. If the government does not give money, some theatres and museums may close, and poor people will not be able to enjoy them. The arts also bring money to a country, because tourists come to visit famous museums and shows.
On the other hand, many people believe that public services are more important. Health and education are things that everyone needs, and they can be a matter of life and death. If a hospital does not have enough money, people may not get the treatment they need. These people think that it is wrong to spend money on paintings when some people cannot see a doctor or go to a good school.
In my opinion, both the arts and public services are important, but if the government has to choose, then public services should come first. Health and education are basic needs, while the arts, although valuable, are less essential. However, I think the government should still give some money to the arts, because a country needs culture as well as hospitals.
In conclusion, while the arts are important, I believe that public services should be the government's main priority.
260 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced, well-developed discussion, with good vocabulary ('a privilege of the wealthy', 'necessities') and a nuanced conclusion that funds both.
There is an ongoing debate about how governments should divide their limited budgets, and in particular whether the arts deserve public funding when services such as healthcare and education are always in need of more money. Both positions are reasonable, but on balance I believe that essential services must take priority.
Those who support funding the arts make some strong points. A nation's culture is part of what makes it worth living in, and the arts enrich people's lives in ways that cannot easily be measured. Without public support, many museums, orchestras and theatres would simply close, and access to them would become a privilege of the wealthy, since only they could afford the full cost. There is an economic argument too, as galleries and festivals attract tourists and create jobs.
Nevertheless, the case for prioritising public services seems to me the stronger. Healthcare and education are not luxuries but necessities, on which people's lives and futures directly depend. When a hospital lacks staff or a school lacks books, the consequences are immediate and serious in a way that the closure of a theatre, however regrettable, is not. Faced with a genuine choice between the two, most people would, quite rightly, choose the hospital.
In my view, however, this does not mean abandoning the arts altogether. The sums involved are usually small compared with health and education budgets, and a civilised society should be able to afford both. The arts should be funded, but not at the expense of services that people cannot do without.
In conclusion, while the arts deserve support, I believe that essential public services should come first when resources are limited.
275 words
Why this is Band 8: A powerful personal opening and a subtle argument that questions the premise. Very natural style, with memorable lines ('run out of ambition').
A few years ago, my city closed its only public library to save money, and used some of the savings to help keep the local hospital open. At the time, I thought this was obviously the right decision, and in a narrow sense it was. But I have since watched what the loss of that library did to the neighbourhood around it, and it has made me suspicious of the very question this essay asks, which treats the arts and public services as rivals for the same pot of money.
The argument for putting services first is, on its face, unanswerable. Nobody ever died for want of an orchestra. When the choice is between a painting and a life-saving operation, only a fool would hesitate. The arts, however wonderful, are not necessities in the way that medicine and schooling are, and in a poor country, or in a genuine emergency, this settles the matter completely.
And yet I have come to think the dilemma is largely a false one. The sums spent on the arts are, almost everywhere, tiny beside the vast budgets of health and education; cutting them entirely would barely dent the deficit, while doing real damage. More importantly, the distinction between 'essential' and 'inessential' is less clear than it looks. What is a school, if not a place where children are introduced to music, stories and art? The library my city closed was not a luxury for the comfortable; it was where the poorest children did their homework, and where lonely old people found company.
My own view, then, is that public services must come first when there is a true conflict, but that such conflicts are rarer than politicians like to pretend. A society that can only afford hospitals, and never a concert or a library, has not run out of money so much as run out of ambition. The right answer is almost always to fund both, and to be suspicious of anyone who insists that we must choose.
334 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with the writer's own city.
Argument: Band 6 ranks the two; Band 8 challenges the either/or framing.
Example: Band 8 uses the closed library to show the overlap.
Vocabulary: 'important' (6), 'necessities' (7), 'a false one' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 argues that genuine conflicts are rare.
Tips for this task
Discuss both views before giving your opinion.
Explain why services might be seen as more essential.
Give the economic and cultural arguments for the arts.
Use a real example if you can.
Make your own position clear in the conclusion.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.