Some people believe that zoos are cruel and should be closed. Others think that they are important for education and for protecting animals.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Addresses both views and gives an opinion, with a personal example. Organisation is clear but basic ('On the one hand'). Ideas are relevant but not deep, with some errors in word form and repetition ('they', 'very'). Clear overall.
Zoos are very popular places for families, but some people believe that they are cruel to animals and they should be closed. Other people think they are useful for education and to save the animals. In this essay, I will discuss both of these opinions and give my own view.
On the one hand, many people say that zoos are cruel. Animals like lions and elephants live in a very big area in the wild, but in a zoo they have only a small cage. Because of this, they become unhappy and sometimes they walk up and down all day. I saw this when I went to a zoo with my family when I was young, and I felt sad for a tiger there. Also, some zoos do not give good food and the animals become sick.
On the other hand, zoos also have many benefits. Children can see real animals and they can learn about them, which is not possible from books or television. It makes them more interested in nature, and when they grow up they will want to protect it. Moreover, many animals are in danger now because people are hunting them and cutting forests. Zoos can keep these animals safe and they can help them to have babies.
In my opinion, zoos should not be closed, but the government should make strict rules for them. Animals must have big areas and good food, and bad zoos should be closed. In this way, we can have the benefits of the zoos, and the animals will not suffer.
260 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position from the start, with both sides well developed. A specific example (Arabian oryx) supports the argument. Good collocations ('in captivity', 'endangered species'), but it has less range and subtlety than Band 8.
Zoos have long been a popular family attraction, but there is now considerable debate about whether they should continue to exist. While some people regard them as cruel, others believe they play a valuable role in education and conservation. This essay will discuss both views before explaining why I believe that zoos should remain, but only under strict conditions.
Those who oppose zoos argue that keeping wild animals in captivity is unnatural. Large animals such as elephants, which would travel long distances in the wild, are confined to small spaces, and they often show signs of stress, such as walking repeatedly in circles. Critics also point out that many animals are kept mainly for human entertainment, and that the money earned by zoos does not always benefit the animals.
On the other hand, supporters claim that zoos provide important benefits. Seeing a real animal can have a far greater impact on a child than a picture in a book, and it may encourage an interest in protecting wildlife. Moreover, breeding programmes in zoos have helped to save a number of endangered species. The Arabian oryx, for instance, had disappeared from the wild before animals bred in captivity were returned to their natural home.
In my opinion, the benefits can justify the existence of zoos, but only if the animals' needs come first. Governments should set high standards for living space and care, and species that cannot be kept well, such as elephants, should be moved elsewhere. In conclusion, rather than closing all zoos, we should close the bad ones and improve the rest.
263 words
Why this is Band 8: Opens with a clear framing of the debate and shifts the question ('what kind of zoos'). It challenges the educational argument, and it gives specific examples. Language is rich and precise ('a last refuge', 'repetitive pacing', 'licensed strictly'). The conclusion is a developed, practical position.
Few institutions divide opinion quite as sharply as the zoo. To its critics, it is a prison for innocent creatures, kept there largely for the amusement of the public; to its defenders, it is both a classroom and a last refuge for species facing extinction. I would argue that both sides have a point, and that the real question is not whether zoos should exist, but what kind of zoos we should accept.
The moral case against zoos is a serious one. An animal that would naturally roam across hundreds of kilometres cannot live a full life in an enclosure, however well it is designed, and the repetitive pacing seen in many big cats and elephants suggests real distress. Nor is the educational argument as strong as it may at first appear. Many visitors spend only seconds at each enclosure, and a bored lion asleep behind glass teaches them very little about how that animal actually lives.
Nevertheless, it would be a mistake to overlook what the best zoos have achieved. Some species, including the Arabian oryx and the California condor, might no longer exist without breeding programmes in captivity. Modern zoos also fund research and conservation in the wild, and for many urban children they provide their only direct contact with wild animals, an experience that can inspire a lifelong concern for nature.
In my view, closing all zoos would be a loss, but the present situation cannot be defended either. Zoos should be licensed strictly on the basis of what they contribute to conservation. Animals that clearly suffer in captivity, such as elephants and polar bears, should no longer be kept at all, and those that remain should be there for their species' sake, rather than for our entertainment.
291 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Task: all three cover both views, but Band 8 also questions whether each argument really works.
Examples: Band 6 uses a childhood memory; Bands 7 and 8 use real conservation examples.
Opinion: Band 6 says 'strict rules'; Band 8 says who should stay and why.
Language: 'small cage' (6), 'confined to small spaces' (7), 'cannot live a full life in an enclosure' (8).
Cohesion: Band 8's paragraphs follow on from each other, with 'Nor is', 'Nevertheless'.
Tips for this task
In a 'discuss both views' essay, give each side a full paragraph.
Present the view you disagree with fairly, using phrases such as 'Critics point out that'.
You can take a middle position, but make it specific.
Only use real examples that you are sure of.
Don't copy the question's words in your introduction. Paraphrase them.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.