Some people think that public transport should be free for everyone.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Clear opinion, with reasons and a personal example, and it considers both sides. The structure is clear, but linking is simple. There are minor errors ('if it was free'), and vocabulary is everyday.
In many cities, traffic and pollution are big problems, and some people suggest that buses and trains should be free for everyone. I partly agree with this idea, because it has some good points, but there are also some problems.
Firstly, free public transport would help people who do not have much money. In my city, many poor workers spend a large part of their salary on going to work by bus. If it was free, they could use that money for food and for their children's education. Secondly, if the transport was free, more people would leave their cars at home. This would reduce traffic and also pollution, and the air would be cleaner. For example, some people I know drive their cars only because they think it is the same price as the bus.
However, there are also some problems with this idea. Buses and trains cost a lot of money to run, and the government would have to pay for it. The money would come from taxes, so people who never use public transport would also have to pay. Also, if buses are free, then they will become very crowded, and the service may become worse. Some people may also not take care of the buses because they did not pay anything.
In my opinion, public transport should not be free for everyone, but it should be cheap. Students, old people and poor people should travel free, because they need help the most, but others can pay a small amount.
In conclusion, free transport has benefits, but I think that a low price with free travel for some groups is better.
274 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position with well-developed points, including real examples. It uses good vocabulary ('serious burden', 'on low incomes') and reasoned counter-arguments. Accurate, but less analytical than Band 8.
With traffic and pollution increasing in cities all over the world, some people argue that public transport should be provided free of charge. Although I can see the attraction of this idea, I only partly agree with it, as I believe that it would be better to focus on improving services and helping those in need.
There are certainly some strong arguments in favour of the idea. It would be a great help to people on low incomes, for whom the daily cost of travel can be a serious burden. It might also encourage some drivers to leave their cars at home, which would reduce traffic and improve air quality. Some cities, such as Tallinn in Estonia and the whole of Luxembourg, have already introduced free travel, which shows that it can be done.
However, there are serious difficulties. Transport systems are extremely expensive to run, and without income from fares, governments would have to find the money from taxes or else reduce services. Furthermore, evidence suggests that many of the new passengers would be people who previously walked or cycled, rather than drivers, so the effect on traffic may be small. For many car owners, the main reason for not using buses is that they are slow and unreliable, not that they cost too much.
In my view, therefore, it would be more effective to spend the money on making public transport faster and more frequent, while offering free or cheap travel to students, older people and those on low incomes. In conclusion, free transport for everyone sounds attractive, but a better service would do more to change people's habits.
271 words
Why this is Band 8: A strong argument that weighs fairness against the environmental claim, showing why one is stronger than the other. Language is precise ('eat up a significant share', 'much weaker than it first appears'). The conclusion is memorable and follows from the argument.
Making buses and trains free for everybody is an idea that has obvious appeal. It promises to help the poor, reduce traffic and clean up the air, all with a single policy. Nevertheless, while I sympathise with these aims, I doubt that abolishing fares altogether is the best way of achieving them, and I would argue that the money could be better spent.
The case for free travel is strongest on grounds of fairness. For low-paid workers, transport can eat up a significant share of their income, and it may even limit the jobs they can take. Removing this cost would be a real benefit to them, and it would also simplify the system, as there would be no need for tickets or inspectors. Several places, including Tallinn and Luxembourg, have adopted such schemes, and they are clearly popular with residents.
The environmental argument, however, is much weaker than it first appears. Studies of these schemes have generally found that many of the new passengers are people who used to walk or cycle, with relatively few drivers giving up their cars. This is hardly surprising. People generally choose to drive because it is quicker and more convenient, and a free bus that is slow, crowded and infrequent will not change this. Moreover, fares provide much of the money for running these systems, so losing them could mean cuts in the very services which are needed to attract drivers.
A better approach, in my view, would be to direct help to those who need it, through free or low-cost passes for students, pensioners and people on low incomes, and to invest the rest in frequency and reliability. In short, for most passengers, the real problem with public transport is not its price, but its quality.
294 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Analysis: Band 8 separates the fairness argument from the environmental one.
Evidence: Bands 7 and 8 refer to real examples; Band 6 only to people that the writer knows.
Solution: all three suggest targeted help, but Band 8 connects it to quality.
Vocabulary: 'a large part of their salary' (6), 'a serious burden' (7), 'eat up a significant share' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8's last sentence changes how we see the question.
Tips for this task
'To what extent' can be answered with 'partly', but explain which part you accept.
Think about what a policy is trying to achieve, and whether it would really do it.
Mention a real example only if you are sure of it.
Use 'would' when you discuss imaginary policies: 'It would help'.
Avoid 'If it was free'; use 'If it were free' in formal writing.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.