With so much information now available online, some people think that public libraries are no longer necessary.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion, with three good reasons and a local example. Language is simple but clear, and there's a good structure. Ideas aren't developed in much depth.
Today, we can find almost any information on the internet very quickly. For this reason, some people think that we do not need public libraries any more. I do not agree with this view, because libraries are still useful for many people.
It is true that the internet has many advantages. It is fast and it is available at any time. Students can read articles at home, and they do not have to travel to a library. It also has much more information than any library can keep. Because of this, fewer people visit libraries than before, and some governments may think that they are a waste of money.
However, I think that libraries are still very important. Firstly, not everybody has a computer or a good internet connection, especially poor people and old people. In a library, they can use a computer for free, and they can also get help from the staff. Secondly, a library is a quiet place to study. Many students in India live in small houses with big families, and they cannot study at home. In my town, the library is always full of students who are preparing for their exams. Thirdly, information on the internet is not always correct, but books in libraries are usually more reliable.
In conclusion, although the internet is very useful, I disagree that libraries are no longer necessary. They are important for poor people and for students, and governments should continue to support them. A town without a library would be a poorer place.
255 words
Why this is Band 7: Clear position with a strong counter-argument section. Good cohesion ('Admittedly', 'To begin with') and vocabulary ('far from universal', 'isolated'). Few errors.
The growth of the internet has made it possible to find information within seconds, and this has led some people to question whether public libraries still serve any purpose. While I accept that their role has changed, I strongly disagree with the idea that they have become unnecessary.
Admittedly, the case against libraries has some force. Most information is now available online, and it is often more up to date than anything on a library shelf. Students can download articles from home, and e-books can be borrowed without leaving the house. At a time when public money is limited, it is understandable that some governments consider these buildings to be an expensive luxury.
However, this argument overlooks a number of important points. To begin with, access to the internet is far from universal, and those without it are often the people who need information the most. For them, a library may be the only place to use a computer, apply for a job or get help with an online form. Libraries also provide a quiet place to study, which is particularly valuable for students who live in crowded homes. In addition, trained librarians can help people to find reliable sources, at a time when there is so much false information online. Finally, they offer activities for children and for elderly people, who might otherwise be quite isolated.
In conclusion, the internet has not replaced libraries, but has changed what they are for. Rather than closing them, governments should invest in turning them into modern community centres, where everyone can have equal access to knowledge.
264 words
Why this is Band 8: Challenges the assumption behind the question. It has original ideas ('without being expected to buy anything') and natural, sophisticated language ('a relic of the past', 'lost their monopoly').
It has become common to hear that public libraries are a relic of the past, kept alive by nostalgia in an age when everything can be found on a phone. I believe that this view rests on a misunderstanding of what libraries actually do, and that it would be a serious mistake to allow them to close.
The argument assumes that a library is simply a store of information, and if this were true, it would indeed be out of date. No building can compete with the internet for the sheer quantity of material. But information has never been all that libraries offer. They are among the very few places left where a person can spend the day without being expected to buy anything. For a student from a crowded home, an elderly person living alone or a new immigrant trying to fill in a government form, this is of enormous importance. Their value is not fully appreciated by those of us who have a quiet room and a fast connection of our own.
There is a further point about the internet itself. Having a great deal of information is not the same thing as being well informed. Search engines give us what is popular, or what someone has paid to show us, and false claims can spread easily. A good librarian can teach a child how to tell a reliable source from an unreliable one, and this skill has never been more necessary. It is true that some libraries have failed to change, and that fewer people borrow books than they once did. This, however, is a reason for modernising them, not for closing them.
In short, libraries may have lost their monopoly on information, but they have kept their purpose. Any society that values equal opportunity should think very carefully before it gets rid of them.
308 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 8 says that the question misunderstands what libraries are.
Ideas: only Band 8 notes that you don't have to buy anything there.
Internet: Band 6 says that it's not always correct; Band 8 explains why.
Vocabulary: 'a waste of money' (6), 'an expensive luxury' (7), 'a relic of the past' (8).
Solution: Bands 7 and 8 suggest modernising them.
Tips for this task
Give the other side some credit before you argue against it.
Think about who would be hurt by the change.
Use a local example, if you have one.
Don't say that everybody has or hasn't got something. Use 'many' or 'most'.
Your conclusion should sum up your view, and not add new ideas.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.