Famous people such as film stars and sports players have a lot of influence on young people today.
Is this a positive or a negative development?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with positive and negative points and relevant examples. Language is simple, with good organisation.
Today, young people follow famous people on social media, and they often want to be like them. Many of them copy the clothes, the hairstyles and even the behaviour of film stars and sports players. In my opinion, this has some good effects, but I think that the negative effects are more important.
There are some positive points. Some famous people can be good examples for young people. For example, a sports player who works very hard can show that you can succeed if you practise every day. Some film stars also support good causes, such as helping poor children or protecting the environment, and their followers may want to help too. They can also encourage young people to talk about important problems.
However, there are also many negative points. Firstly, famous people often show a life that is not real. They have expensive clothes and cars, and young people may feel sad because they cannot have these things. Secondly, some of them advertise unhealthy things such as soft drinks, and young people buy these because they trust them. Thirdly, some famous people behave badly, for example by taking drugs or by fighting, and young people may think that this is acceptable. Young people may also think that being famous is the only thing that matters, and they may not work hard at school.
In conclusion, although some famous people are good examples, I think that their influence is mostly negative. Parents and teachers should help young people to choose better role models, such as doctors, scientists or people in their own family.
263 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-argued answer, using good evidence about mental health. Good range of vocabulary ('self-esteem', 'undervalue', 'think critically'). Very clear conclusion.
With the growth of social media, film stars and sports players have become an important part of young people's daily lives, and their opinions and habits are often closely copied. In my view, this influence has its benefits, but it is on balance a negative development.
There is no denying that some celebrities have a positive effect. Sports stars can show the value of discipline and of hard work, and many young people take up a sport as a result of watching them. Others use their fame to support worthwhile causes, and to draw attention to issues such as mental health or climate change, which might otherwise be ignored. When a popular figure speaks openly about depression, for example, it can help a teenager to feel less alone.
However, I believe that the harmful effects are more significant. Much of what young people see online is an unrealistic picture of wealth and beauty, which has been carefully edited, and this can damage their self-esteem. A number of studies have linked heavy use of social media to anxiety among teenagers, particularly girls. Celebrities are also paid large sums to promote products, including fast food and gambling apps, to an audience that is too young to judge them. Perhaps most worrying is the message that fame and money are the main goals in life, which may lead young people to undervalue education and ordinary work.
In conclusion, although a few famous people provide inspiring examples, I think that their overall influence is more negative than positive. Young people need to be taught to think critically about what they see, and families and schools should offer them more realistic role models.
278 words
Why this is Band 8: A lively, original essay with memorable phrases ('carry them around in a pocket'). It uses a local example very well, and it has a sophisticated argument about achievement.
There has always been a certain fascination with the famous, but never before has a teenager been able to carry them around in a pocket, and to see what they have for breakfast. This new closeness has given celebrities a degree of influence which their predecessors could not have imagined, and although it has done some good, I believe that it is doing more harm.
To be fair, the picture is not entirely negative. A generation of young Indian girls took up cricket and wrestling after seeing women succeed in them, and that is no small achievement. Celebrities have also broken some important silences. When a famous actor talks openly about depression, it does more to change attitudes than any number of government leaflets. People who would never read a report on climate change may at least listen to someone they admire.
The trouble lies in what this influence is mainly used for. It is, for the most part, used to sell things. A young person looking at these accounts is shown a stream of perfect bodies and expensive holidays, which are presented as an ordinary life. They are rarely told that the image was edited, or that the post was paid for. The effect on self-esteem is by now well documented. Even more damaging is what the system teaches about achievement. A student who looks at someone who has become rich for being famous may reasonably wonder what the point of studying chemistry is. Fame, after all, is the one form of success that does not require anybody to be good at anything.
I would therefore regard this development as largely negative. We cannot stop young people from admiring the famous, but we can teach them to ask who is paying for what they see.
296 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 explains what's new about today's influence.
Positive example: 'a sports player' (6), 'a teenager... less alone' (7), 'Indian girls took up cricket and wrestling' (8).
Argument: Band 8 points out that this influence is mainly used to sell things.