Some people believe that the best way to reduce crime is to give criminals longer prison sentences. Others think there are better alternative ways to reduce crime.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons and a definite opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
Reducing crime is a goal for every society, but people disagree about how to do it. Some believe that the answer is longer prison sentences, while others think there are better alternatives. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who favour longer sentences argue that they work in two ways. Firstly, they keep criminals off the streets for longer, so they cannot commit more crimes during that time. Secondly, they act as a deterrent: if people know that a crime will be severely punished, they will be too afraid to commit it. This view sees tough punishment as the most direct way to make society safer.
However, others argue that prison alone does not solve the problem, and may even make it worse. Many criminals, they point out, re-offend as soon as they are released, which suggests that prison does not reform them. These people believe that it is better to deal with the causes of crime, such as poverty, poor education and drug addiction, and to help criminals to find jobs and change their lives, so that they do not offend again.
In my opinion, longer sentences are not the best answer on their own. I believe that some punishment is necessary, especially for serious crimes, but that preventing crime in the first place, and helping offenders to reform, are more effective in the long run.
In conclusion, although longer prison sentences have some benefits, I believe that tackling the causes of crime and reforming offenders is a better way to make society safer.
261 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that gives the deterrence argument its due before challenging it with evidence on re-offending, and argues convincingly for prevention and rehabilitation. Good vocabulary and a clear, qualified position. (Note: a stray typo, 'supposters', is the kind of slip a Band 7 writer might make under time pressure.)
How best to reduce crime is one of the oldest questions in politics. One camp argues that the answer is simple and tough: longer prison sentences. Another insists that prison is not the solution, and that smarter alternatives work better. In my view, while punishment has its place, the second camp is closer to the truth.
The case for long sentences is intuitive and has real force. While a criminal is locked up, they cannot offend against the public, and the prospect of years behind bars is, supposters argue, a powerful deterrent that frightens would-be criminals into staying honest. There is a satisfying clarity to the idea that crime should simply be met with firm punishment.
Yet the evidence for this is weaker than it appears. If long sentences truly deterred, the countries with the harshest penalties would have the least crime, which is often not the case. More troubling still is the problem of re-offending: a large proportion of prisoners commit further crimes soon after release, which suggests that prison frequently fails to reform, and may even harden people, teaching them to be better criminals.
This is why I favour the alternative approach, which is to tackle the root causes of crime – poverty, poor education, addiction and lack of opportunity – and to focus, within the justice system, on genuinely rehabilitating offenders so that they can build honest lives. Prevention and reform address why crime happens, rather than merely punishing it after the fact.
In conclusion, although firm punishment is necessary for serious offences, I believe that reducing crime in the long term depends far more on tackling its causes and reforming offenders than on simply lengthening sentences.
280 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that fully concedes the force of the incapacitation and deterrence arguments before dismantling them with the observations that most crime is not coolly calculated and that prison can be 'a school for crime'. Nuanced, evidence-minded and persuasive.
Whenever crime rises, a familiar cry goes up: lock them up, and for longer. It is an emotionally satisfying response, and there is a serious argument behind it. But I have come to believe that the instinct to reach first for longer sentences, however understandable, mistakes the nature of the problem, and that the alternatives its critics propose are, on the whole, the wiser path.
The argument for long sentences is not empty. There is a plain logic to incapacitation – a prisoner cannot burgle a house – and the threat of severe punishment surely deters at least some people some of the time. For the most dangerous offenders, lengthy imprisonment is both just and necessary, and no sensible person would empty the prisons.
And yet, as a general strategy for reducing crime, it runs into stubborn facts. The deterrent effect of ever-longer sentences turns out to be surprisingly weak, because most crime is impulsive or desperate, committed by people who are not calmly weighing the penalty. Worse, prison all too often functions as a school for crime, releasing people more damaged, more embittered and more skilled in wrongdoing than when they entered – which is why rates of re-offending are so dismayingly high.
The alternatives are less dramatic but, I think, more effective: attacking the conditions that breed crime – poverty, failing schools, addiction, hopelessness – and reshaping the justice system around rehabilitation rather than mere punishment. These are slower and less satisfying than a tough headline, but they address causes rather than symptoms.
In conclusion, I accept that punishment, including imprisonment, has a necessary place, particularly for serious crime. But the belief that we can simply imprison our way to safety is, I am convinced, mistaken; lasting reductions in crime will come from prevention and reform, not from ever-longer sentences.
302 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 lists reasons; Band 8 questions the evidence that prison deters.
Examples: Band 7 mentions re-offending rates.
Vocabulary: 'too afraid to commit it' (6), 'a powerful deterrent' (7).
Depth: Band 7 stresses tackling the causes of crime.
Conclusion: both favour prevention; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Discuss both longer sentences and the alternatives.
Give the reasons for each view (deterrence, reform).
Mention re-offending and the causes of crime.
Make your own opinion clear.
Use a separate paragraph for each view.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.