Some people think that governments should spend money on improving and expanding public transport. Others believe the money would be better spent on building and improving roads.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons and a definite opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
Governments have limited money to spend on transport, and must decide how to use it. Some believe it should go on public transport, like buses and trains, while others think it should go on roads. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who favour spending on roads argue that most people and most goods still travel by road, so good roads benefit almost everyone. Better roads reduce traffic jams, save time, and help businesses to transport their products, which is good for the economy. In areas without good public transport, people have no choice but to drive, so they need good roads.
However, others believe that money is better spent on public transport. They argue that building more roads does not solve traffic, because more roads simply encourage more people to drive, and the roads fill up again. Good public transport, on the other hand, can move large numbers of people efficiently, and it is better for the environment, as buses and trains cause less pollution per person than cars.
In my opinion, money is generally better spent on public transport, especially in cities. I believe that building endless roads is not a real solution, and that good, cheap public transport gives people a genuine alternative to the car, which reduces both traffic and pollution. However, some spending on roads is still necessary, especially in the countryside.
In conclusion, although good roads are important, I believe that, in most cases, investing in public transport is the better choice, as it is more efficient and better for the environment.
264 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that gives the road-building case its due before arguing convincingly for public transport, using the concept of 'induced demand' and the environmental argument. Good vocabulary and a clear, qualified position.
Every government faces the question of how to spend its limited transport budget, and the choice is often posed as a contest between public transport and roads. Both have their advocates and their logic, but in my view the balance tips clearly towards public transport, at least in and around our cities.
The case for spending on roads is straightforward. The great majority of journeys, and of freight, still go by road, so improving roads benefits almost everyone, easing congestion, saving time, and helping the economy to move its goods. In rural areas especially, where public transport is often thin or absent, people depend utterly on their cars, and good roads are not a luxury but a necessity.
Yet the case for public transport is, to my mind, the stronger. The crucial flaw in the road-building argument is that it rarely works: experience repeatedly shows that building more roads simply encourages more people to drive, so that the new roads fill up and congestion returns, a phenomenon known as 'induced demand'. Good public transport, by contrast, can move huge numbers of people efficiently, takes cars off the road, and produces far less pollution per passenger, which matters enormously in an age of dirty air and a warming climate.
My own view is that endlessly building roads is a treadmill that can never be won, whereas investing in fast, cheap, reliable public transport offers people a genuine alternative to the car, and tackles congestion, pollution and cost together. That said, roads cannot be neglected, particularly in the countryside, where no realistic alternative exists.
In conclusion, while good roads remain necessary, I believe that investment in public transport is, in most places, the wiser use of limited funds.
286 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that reframes the choice as non-equivalent, dismantling the road-building case with 'induced demand' while fairly conceding rural dependence on cars. The argument that 'you cannot build your way out of traffic' is sharp and well-supported.
Hand a government a fixed sum for transport, and it faces a revealing choice: widen the roads, or invest in the buses and trains. The decision is usually framed as a simple trade-off, but I have come to think the two options are not equivalent at all, because one of them rests on an assumption that decades of experience have quietly demolished.
The argument for roads is not foolish. Most people and nearly all goods still move by road, so a better road network benefits almost everyone, and in rural areas, where a bus may come twice a day if at all, the car is not a choice but a lifeline. To neglect roads entirely would be to punish those with no alternative.
But the central claim of the road-builders – that more roads mean less congestion – turns out to be very nearly the opposite of the truth. Again and again, new roads have been found to generate their own traffic: made easier, driving becomes more attractive, more people do it, and within a few years the gleaming new road is as jammed as the old one. This 'induced demand' makes road-building, as a cure for congestion, a treadmill that can never be won. Public transport escapes this trap: a single train can replace hundreds of cars, it pollutes far less per head, and, crucially, it offers people a real alternative rather than simply more of the thing causing the problem.
My view, then, is that in cities and their surroundings the money is far better spent on public transport, which addresses congestion, pollution and cost at a stroke, while roads should remain the priority only where no realistic alternative can exist.
In conclusion, though roads cannot be abandoned, I believe the wiser investment, almost everywhere people are concentrated, is in public transport – because you cannot build your way out of traffic, but you can offer people a better way to travel.
324 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 lists points; Band 8 explains why building roads fails to cut traffic.
Examples: Band 7 mentions the roads filling up again.