Some countries charge an entrance fee to their national museums and galleries, while others allow free entry.
Do the advantages of charging visitors outweigh the disadvantages?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear answer, with both sides and a personal example. Ideas are relevant but simple, and the structure relies on 'Firstly' and 'Secondly'. Vocabulary is everyday, with few errors. The solution is only briefly mentioned.
Museums and art galleries are important places for the culture of a country. In some countries, people have to pay to enter these places, but in other countries they are free. In my opinion, there are some advantages of charging a fee, but I believe that the disadvantages are greater.
The main advantage of an entrance fee is that it gives money to the museum. Museums need a lot of money to look after their old objects, pay the staff and repair the buildings. If visitors pay, then the government does not have to spend so much tax money, and this money can be used for other things such as hospitals. Also, tourists who visit from other countries do not pay tax, so it is fair that they should pay something.
However, there are more disadvantages. Firstly, many poor families cannot pay the fee, especially if there are a lot of children. For this reason, only rich people will be able to learn about the art and history of their own country, and this is not fair. Secondly, people go to a museum less often if they have to pay. If it is free, they can visit for half an hour during their lunch time, or go many times to see one exhibition. For example, in my city there is a free museum, and I went there many times when I was a student, and it made me interested in history.
In conclusion, although the money from fees is useful for museums, I think that museums should be free, because they belong to all the people. The government should pay for them, or they can ask for donations from visitors.
280 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position, with well-organised reasons and a relevant real example. Good vocabulary ('burden on taxpayers', 'drawbacks', 'better-off'). It offers practical alternatives, but it is less analytical than Band 8.
Whether national museums should charge for admission is a question that many governments have to consider. While entrance fees can provide a valuable source of income, I believe that their disadvantages outweigh the benefits, as they limit access to something which should be available to everyone.
There are certainly some advantages to charging visitors. Maintaining historic collections is extremely costly, and income from tickets can help to pay for conservation, new exhibitions and staff. This reduces the burden on taxpayers, many of whom may never set foot in a museum. It also seems reasonable that foreign tourists, who do not contribute through taxes, should pay towards what they enjoy. Some people would also argue that visitors value something more if they have paid for it.
Nevertheless, the drawbacks are more serious. The most important is that fees discourage people on low incomes, so that a nation's heritage becomes something only the better-off can enjoy. There is evidence for this from Britain, where visitor numbers rose sharply at many national museums after charges were dropped in 2001. In addition, free entry encourages a more casual kind of visit. People can drop in to see one painting, and school groups can come without worrying about the cost. Such regular contact is what creates a lifelong interest in culture and history.
In my view, museums can find other ways to raise money, including shops, cafes, special exhibitions and donations. Tourists could also be charged separately, as happens in some countries. In conclusion, although fees bring in useful income, this does not justify the loss of access for ordinary people.
266 words
Why this is Band 8: Strong, thoughtful argument. It recognises that the fairness point works in both directions, and it answers the question directly by weighing the size of the gains and losses. Language is precise ('disproportionately', 'instructive', 'sacrificed').
Keeping a national collection safe and on display is an expensive business, and it is hardly surprising that many governments have turned to the visitor to help pay for it. Although there is some force in this argument, I would contend that the gains from general admission charges are modest when compared with what is lost, and that there are better ways of achieving the same end.
The case for charging rests largely on fairness and finance. Not everybody uses museums, and those who do are disproportionately well-off, so there is something odd about asking a low-paid worker to subsidise the leisure of a wealthy visitor through taxation. Likewise, it seems reasonable that overseas tourists, who form a large part of the audience in major capitals, should make a contribution. Ticket income is also relatively stable, and it is not dependent upon the priorities of the government of the day.
However, these arguments overlook how people actually behave. Even a modest fee changes the nature of a visit, turning it into an occasion that must be justified, instead of something one can simply wander into for half an hour. Its effect is greatest on precisely those whom museums most need to reach, namely families on low incomes and young people with no habit of visiting. The British experience is instructive here: when charges were removed from national museums in 2001, attendance rose dramatically. And because admission fees usually cover only a small share of running costs, a great deal of access is sacrificed for relatively little revenue.
A sensible compromise is available. Permanent collections can be free for residents, while income is raised through temporary exhibitions, commercial activities and, where it is practical, a charge for foreign visitors. This approach preserves what is most valuable, which is the idea that a nation's heritage belongs to all of its people.
309 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Weighing: Band 8 says how much is gained and how much is lost.
Idea: Band 8 notes that fee income is a small share of running costs.
Example: Bands 7 and 8 use Britain; Band 8 uses it as part of the argument.
Vocabulary: 'poor families' (6), 'people on low incomes' (7), 'those whom museums most need to reach' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 offers a compromise and links it to a principle.
Tips for this task
'Do the advantages outweigh the disadvantages?' needs a clear yes or no.
Give more than a list. Explain why one side is more important.
Discuss the side you disagree with fairly, as this makes your argument stronger.
Use a real example only if you are sure of the facts.
Offering a realistic solution can show mature thinking, but it must not replace your answer.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.