Some people believe that scientific research should be paid for and controlled by governments rather than by private companies.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear answer, with reasons on both sides and relevant examples. Language is simple but mostly correct. Ideas are sensible, though they aren't developed in depth.
Scientific research is very important for the future of the world, and it needs a lot of money. Some people think that governments should pay for it and control it, and not private companies. I agree with this view to a large extent, but I think that private companies also have a part to play.
There are good reasons for governments to control research. Firstly, governments work for all the people, while companies only want to make a profit. For example, a drug company may not want to do research on diseases that only affect poor countries, because it cannot make money from them. A government can spend money on this because it helps people. Secondly, some research is expensive and it takes a long time, like space research or the study of climate change. Companies do not want to wait many years for a result, but governments can.
However, private companies also have some advantages. They often work faster than governments, because they have less paperwork. They also compete with each other, and this gives us new products such as better phones and medicines. During the Covid pandemic, private companies made vaccines very quickly, although governments gave them some money too.
In conclusion, I think that governments should pay for and control most important research, especially research on health and the environment, because it helps everyone. But private companies should also continue to do research, because they can bring new ideas and produce things quickly. Both of them are necessary.
251 words
Why this is Band 7: Well-developed argument, using good examples (the internet, GPS). It has a strong structure and a clear conclusion. Good vocabulary ('basic research', 'private expertise').
Scientific research requires vast sums of money, and there is much debate about who should provide it. Some argue that this should be the responsibility of governments alone. While I believe that public funding is essential, I do not think that private companies should be excluded from this work.
The case for government control is a strong one. Private firms exist to make a profit, so they tend to concentrate on what will sell, rather than on what society needs most. This explains why relatively little has been spent on treatments for diseases that mainly affect poor countries. Governments can also afford to support basic research, which may not produce any practical benefit for decades. Many of the most important discoveries of the last century, including the internet and GPS, came from publicly funded projects. In addition, public research is usually published openly, whereas companies are likely to keep their results secret.
Nevertheless, the private sector has a valuable part to play. Companies are often far better at turning a discovery into a useful product, because they have the money and the motivation to do so. The speed with which Covid vaccines were developed showed what can be done when public funds are combined with private expertise. Furthermore, government control is not without its problems. Politicians may favour projects that win votes, or stop research which they find inconvenient.
In conclusion, I partly agree with the statement. Governments should fund basic research and set clear rules on safety and honesty, but private companies should also be encouraged to develop useful products. The best results seem to come from cooperation between the two.
272 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that changes the question in a useful way. It uses striking examples (tobacco, Soviet biology). It has very precise and natural language ('bear fruit', 'Where profit and human need diverge').
It is often assumed that research paid for by governments serves the public, while that paid for by companies serves only the shareholders. There is some truth in this, but the reality is rather more complicated, and I would argue that the most useful question is not who should control science, but which kind of science each is best placed to do.
There are certain kinds of work that only the state is likely to pay for. Basic research can take decades to bear fruit, and the benefits are often impossible to predict, or to keep private. No company would have spent public-sector sums on the early work which led to the internet, or to the mRNA technique behind recent vaccines. Similarly, the market will never give much attention to a disease that kills poor people. Where profit and human need diverge, as they frequently do, it would be foolish to depend on private funding. The record of industry-funded research is also a warning in itself, as the tobacco companies demonstrated for many years.
Yet it does not follow that governments should have a monopoly. Political control has its own dangers, as any scientist who has worked on climate change under a hostile administration can confirm. Soviet biology was set back by a generation because the state insisted upon a theory which happened to suit its ideology. Companies, meanwhile, have the discipline and the funds to do what universities rarely do well, which is to turn an idea into something that can be made in large quantities at a reasonable price.
I therefore disagree with the idea of exclusive government control. A healthy system requires public money for the long term and private money for the application, with independent regulators who ensure that the results of both can be trusted.
300 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Introduction: Band 8 challenges the assumption behind the question.
Examples: 'phones and medicines' (6), 'the internet and GPS' (7), 'Soviet biology' (8).
Weakness of government: Band 6 doesn't mention any; Bands 7 and 8 do.
Vocabulary: 'make a profit' (6), 'private expertise' (7), 'a monopoly' (8).
Solution: Band 8 adds the need for independent regulators.
Tips for this task
Look for a middle position, but make sure that it's clear.
Use real examples only if you're sure about them.
Consider the weaknesses of your own side.
Don't simply say that companies are bad. Say why they behave as they do.
Make your conclusion follow from your arguments.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.