Some people believe that wealthy countries should give much more financial aid to poorer countries. Others think that this aid does more harm than good.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, and a clear opinion is given, with relevant examples. Language is simple but mostly accurate, and it's well organised.
Today, there is a big difference between rich and poor countries. Some people think that rich countries should give more money to poor countries, but other people think that aid can be harmful. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my own opinion.
On the one hand, there are good reasons for giving more aid. Many people in poor countries do not have enough food, clean water or medicine. Rich countries have a lot of money, so they can help them. For example, foreign aid has helped to reduce diseases like malaria in Africa, and many children's lives have been saved. Rich countries have also become rich partly by using poor countries in the past, so I think that they have a duty to help.
On the other hand, some people say that aid can cause problems. Sometimes the money does not reach the people who need it, because corrupt politicians keep it for themselves. Also, if a country always gets help, it may depend on it, and it may not try to develop its own businesses. Some aid also has conditions, so the poor country must buy goods from the rich country that gave the money.
In my opinion, rich countries should give more aid, but they should be careful about how they do it. The money should go to projects such as schools and hospitals, and they should check how it is spent. Aid should help poor countries to stand on their own feet, rather than making them dependent. If this is done, then it will help everyone.
263 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-developed discussion using a named critic and real examples (smallpox). Good range ('moral duty', 'exploitation', 'tied to the interests'). Clear and thoughtful opinion.
The question of whether rich countries should increase their financial aid to poorer nations has long been debated. While some argue that it is a moral duty, others claim that aid can actually hold countries back. In my view, aid is valuable, but its effectiveness depends greatly on how it is given.
Those who support aid point to its clear successes. Programmes to provide vaccines and clean water have saved millions of lives, and the eradication of smallpox is one of the great achievements of international cooperation. Many also argue that rich countries have a particular responsibility, since their wealth was partly built on the exploitation of colonies, and since they are also largely responsible for the climate change that now threatens the poorest nations.
Critics, however, make some serious points. Economists such as Dambisa Moyo have argued that large flows of aid can encourage corruption, by giving governments a source of money that does not depend on their citizens. It may also harm local businesses, as when free food from abroad puts local farmers out of work. In addition, a good deal of aid is tied to the interests of donor countries, and it may be used to buy their goods or to gain political influence.
In my opinion, these criticisms show that aid needs to be reformed, not abandoned. Rich countries should concentrate on health and education, where the evidence of success is strongest, and they should work directly with local organisations. They should also remove the trade barriers that make it difficult for poor countries to sell their goods. If done properly, aid can make a real difference, although it can never be a complete solution to poverty.
281 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that questions how the debate is framed. It has strong examples and very precise language ('a legacy of colonial rule', 'a subsidy for the donor's own industries'), and it ends with a clear practical point.
Few subjects in international affairs produce such strong disagreement as foreign aid. To its supporters, it is both a moral duty and a practical success. To its critics, it is at best a waste, and at worst a form of harm. Having looked at both sides, I believe that the argument is often badly framed, since 'aid' covers such a variety of things that no general judgement of it is possible.
The case for giving more is powerful. Smallpox no longer exists, largely because of international health programmes, and vaccination has saved tens of millions of children's lives at a remarkably low cost. It is hard to argue with such results. Moreover, the rich world can hardly claim to have no responsibility, as many of the poorest countries' borders, debts and institutions are a legacy of colonial rule, and the droughts now affecting them are largely the result of other people's emissions.
Yet the critics cannot simply be dismissed. Writers such as Dambisa Moyo and William Easterly have shown that decades of support for governments have often made things worse, for a leader who is funded from abroad has little need to listen to his own people. Food aid has at times ruined the very farmers it was supposed to help. And a considerable part of what is described as generosity is in fact a subsidy for the donor's own industries, or a way of buying influence.
The sensible conclusion is that we should stop asking whether aid works, and ask which kinds of aid work, and where. The evidence strongly favours specific and measurable programmes in health and education, and it does not favour large transfers to governments. I would therefore support an increase, but only in the first category. Rich countries could also do more good by changing their own trade rules than by writing any number of cheques.
311 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Introduction: Band 8 says that 'aid' covers too many things to judge all together.
Evidence: Bands 7 and 8 name real writers and successes.
History: Band 6 mentions it briefly, while Band 8 brings in borders and debts.
Vocabulary: 'stand on their own feet' (6), 'not abandoned' (7), 'measurable programmes' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 finishes with a point about trade rules.
Tips for this task
'Discuss both views' means giving each one a full paragraph.
Give your own opinion clearly, in your introduction or conclusion.
Use a real example, if you're sure about it.
Don't say that aid always works or always fails.
Think about the kinds of aid, not just the amount of money.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.