Some people think that children should be allowed to choose the subjects they study at school, while others believe that all the main subjects should be compulsory for everyone.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons and a sensible, balanced opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
There is much debate about whether children should be free to choose the subjects they study at school, or whether all the main subjects should be compulsory. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who believe children should be able to choose argue that children learn best when they are studying something they are interested in. A child who is allowed to study the subjects they enjoy will be more motivated, work harder, and be happier at school. They also point out that children have different talents, and that forcing a child who loves art to study a subject they hate, such as mathematics, is a waste of everyone's time.
On the other hand, many people believe that the main subjects should be compulsory. They argue that there are some things, such as reading, writing and basic mathematics, that everyone needs in life, whatever they go on to do, and that children are too young to know what will be useful to them later. If children could choose freely, they might drop important subjects simply because they were difficult.
In my opinion, the best approach is a mixture of both. I believe that the core subjects, which everyone truly needs, should be compulsory, at least until a certain age, but that children should also be given some choice, and more and more freedom to choose as they get older and know themselves better.
In conclusion, although children should have some choice, I believe the most important subjects should be compulsory, as they are too valuable for a child to be allowed to drop.
269 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that gives both views their due and argues for compulsory core subjects with growing choice, resting on the distinction between a 'core' and the rest. Good vocabulary and a clear, qualified position.
Should children be free to choose what they study at school, or should the main subjects be compulsory for all? Both sides of this old debate have real force, and in my view the wisest answer is a careful balance between the two.
The case for choice rests on a simple truth: children learn best when they are genuinely engaged. A child allowed to pursue subjects they love will be more motivated, work harder and be far happier than one forced through subjects they dread. Children also have very different gifts, and there is something wasteful, even cruel, in compelling a budding artist to struggle for years with advanced mathematics they will never use or enjoy.
Yet the case for compulsory subjects is just as strong. Some knowledge – reading, writing, basic mathematics, an understanding of the world – is simply essential for every adult, whatever path they take, and it would be wrong to let children opt out of it. Moreover, children are not always the best judges of what will matter to them later; left entirely free, many would drop difficult but important subjects, and come to regret it.
My own view is that the answer lies in distinguishing a core from the rest. The essential subjects that everyone truly needs should be compulsory, at least up to a certain age, guaranteeing that no child leaves school without them. Beyond that core, children should be given real choice, and steadily more of it as they grow older and come to understand their own talents and interests.
In conclusion, while children should certainly have a growing freedom to choose, I believe the essential core subjects must remain compulsory, as they are too important to be left to a child's passing whim.
292 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that frames the issue as a 'genuine tension' and resolves it by distinguishing a compulsory core from a widening band of choice that grows with the child's age. Nuanced, balanced and well-argued.
At the heart of this familiar school debate lies a genuine tension: between the obvious truth that children learn best what they love, and the equally obvious truth that some things must be learned whether they are loved or not. Rather than side wholly with freedom or with compulsion, I want to argue that the sensible path runs between them.
The case for letting children choose is rooted in motivation, which is the engine of all real learning. A child studying something that fascinates them works willingly and remembers what they learn; a child dragged through a hated subject often learns little but resentment. Given how widely children's talents differ, there is a real waste in forcing every future musician through advanced science, or every future scientist through years of a language they will never speak.
And yet the case for a compulsory core is, to me, decisive at the foundational level. There are things – literacy, basic mathematics, a grasp of how the world works – that every adult simply needs, regardless of the life they lead, and no child should be permitted to leave school without them. We should also be honest that a ten-year-old is in no position to judge what their thirty-year-old self will wish they had learned; total freedom would see difficult but vital subjects quietly abandoned.
The resolution, surely, is not freedom versus compulsion but both, in the right proportions and at the right ages. A compulsory core guarantees every child the essentials; a widening band of choice, growing as the child matures and comes to know themselves, harnesses the power of genuine interest. The young child needs mostly the former; the older student can safely be trusted with more and more of the latter.
In conclusion, I believe the essential subjects must be compulsory for all, but that, beyond this core, children should be given an increasing freedom to follow their own interests – a balance that serves both what they need and what they love.
333 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 lists reasons; Band 8 distinguishes a 'core' everyone needs from the rest.
Examples: both mention motivation and core skills; Band 7 develops them.