Some people think that children should begin learning a foreign language at primary school. Others believe that they should wait until secondary school.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with a clear opinion, and there's a personal example. The structure is clear, using common phrases. Vocabulary is simple, with few errors, and ideas are not deeply developed.
Learning a foreign language is very important in the modern world. Some people say that children should start to learn it at primary school, but other people think that it is better for them to wait until they go to secondary school. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, many people believe that young children can learn languages more easily. Their brains are still developing, and they can copy new sounds very well. For example, I have a young cousin who learned English songs when he was six, and his pronunciation is much better than mine. Also, if they start early, they will have more years to practise, and they will not be afraid of speaking.
On the other hand, some people think that young children should learn their own language first. If they start a foreign language too early, they may get confused, and they may not learn to read and write well in their mother tongue. Secondary school students are more mature, and they can understand the grammar rules better. In addition, some primary schools do not have good teachers for foreign languages, so the students will not learn correctly.
In my opinion, it is better to start at primary school, but the classes should be fun, with songs and games, and not too much grammar. In this way, children will enjoy the language and they will be interested in learning more when they go to secondary school.
In conclusion, although there are arguments on both sides, I believe that an early start is better for most children.
269 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position, with both sides well developed. Good vocabulary ('self-conscious', 'do more harm than good'). It replies to the other side directly. Few errors.
There is some debate about the best age to introduce children to a foreign language. While some people argue that this should happen at primary school, others believe that it is better to wait until secondary level. In my view, an early start is generally preferable, provided that the teaching is suitable for young children.
Those who favour starting early point out that young children have a natural ability to imitate sounds, which helps them to develop good pronunciation. They are also less self-conscious than teenagers, and they are usually happy to speak without worrying about mistakes. Moreover, starting young gives them many more years of study, which is important since it takes a long time to master another language.
On the other hand, those who prefer to wait argue that primary children should concentrate on their own language first, as they need to develop strong reading and writing skills. Older students also have a better understanding of grammar, and they may make faster progress in the early stages. There is the further problem that many primary schools lack teachers who are trained in language teaching, and a poor start may do more harm than good.
Although these are valid points, I believe that the benefits of starting early are greater. In many countries, children grow up speaking two or more languages without any difficulty, which suggests that a second language does not interfere with the first. As long as lessons are based on songs, games and simple conversation, children will gain confidence, as well as a positive attitude to languages.
In conclusion, children should start learning a foreign language at primary school, as long as qualified teachers are available.
280 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful argument, shifting the question from age to quality. Each view is well developed, and it uses the idea that early learners do not always keep their lead. Natural, precise language ('excellent mimics', 'spark a lifelong interest').
At what age should children start to learn a foreign language? For many parents, the answer seems obvious, as everyone knows that young children appear to pick up languages effortlessly. Others, however, are concerned that primary school is too early, and that time would be better spent elsewhere. While I can see the force of both views, I would argue that an early start is worthwhile, but only if it is approached in the right way.
The case for beginning at primary school rests largely on what young learners do well. Children of six or seven are excellent mimics, and they are able to develop an accent which older learners rarely achieve. Just as importantly, they have not yet learned to be embarrassed, so they will happily try out new words in front of the class. A long period of contact with a language can also make it seem like a normal part of life, rather than just another exam subject.
Those who favour waiting have some strong points, too. Children have limited time at school, and those who are still struggling to read and write in their first language may benefit more from extra help with this. Older students, who can think in more abstract ways, often catch up quickly, and research suggests that early starters do not always keep their lead, especially if the teaching at primary level is weak. A child taught by a teacher with poor language skills may simply learn mistakes.
For me, what this shows is that the question of age matters less than that of quality. A couple of hours a week of songs and games with a confident teacher can spark a lifelong interest, whereas dull grammar lessons will kill it at any age. Primary schools should therefore introduce languages wherever they have the staff to do so properly, and should aim for enjoyment above all.
314 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 8 changes the question from age to quality.
Development: Band 6 lists reasons; Band 8 explains them.