Some people think that public transport should be free for everyone.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear partly-agree position with relevant reasons on both sides, and well organised. Language is mostly simple ('big problems', 'a lot of money'), and some ideas are not fully developed.
Public transport is very important in all cities, because many people use it every day. Some people say that buses and trains should be free for everybody. I agree with this idea to some extent, but I think that it is not possible for every person.
There are some good reasons for free public transport. Firstly, if buses are free, more people will leave their cars at home. This will reduce traffic and pollution, which are big problems in cities like Delhi. Secondly, it will help poor people, because they spend a lot of their money on travel. If they do not have to pay for this, they can use the money for food and for education for their children. Also, it will be easier for old people and students to go out.
On the other hand, public transport costs a lot of money. The government has to pay for drivers, fuel and new buses. If people do not pay any fare, the government must collect more tax, and this is not fair to people who never use the bus. Another problem is that free buses can become very crowded and dirty, because people do not respect something that is free.
In my opinion, the best idea is to make public transport free only for some people, such as students, old people and people with low incomes. Other people can pay a small fare. In this way, the government will have enough money, and the people who need it most will be helped.
In conclusion, I partly agree with free public transport, but I think that it should be only for some groups in society.
275 words
Why this is Band 7: A consistent position with well-developed arguments on both sides. Good vocabulary ('take up a large part of their budget', 'targeted approach') and a practical alternative. Few errors.
Traffic congestion and air pollution are major problems in many cities, and it has been suggested that making public transport free for all would help to solve them. While I can see the attraction of this idea, I only partly agree with it, as I believe that the costs would outweigh the benefits unless it were targeted carefully.
There are clear arguments in favour of free travel. It would encourage some drivers to leave their cars at home, which would reduce both traffic and emissions. It would also be of great help to people on low incomes, for whom fares can take up a large part of their budget, and it would make it easier for them to get to work or to look for a job. Elderly people and students would also benefit from greater independence.
However, there are also strong objections. Running buses and trains is very expensive, and if passengers paid nothing, the money would have to come from higher taxes or from cuts to other services, such as health care. Those who never use public transport, including many people in rural areas, would be paying for something that they do not use. In addition, without any income from fares, the quality of the service could fall, and buses could become overcrowded.
A more sensible policy, in my opinion, would be to offer free or reduced travel to those who need it most, such as students, the elderly and people on low wages, while others continue to pay a reasonable price.
In conclusion, although free public transport has obvious appeal, a targeted approach would achieve most of the benefits at a much lower cost.
277 words
Why this is Band 8: A strong line of argument that weighs the two main claims and finds one weaker. It uses an example briefly and accurately, and its language is precise and natural ('shut people out of jobs', 'precisely what keeps people in their cars').
The idea of abolishing fares on public transport is an appealing one, and a handful of places, including Luxembourg, have actually put it into practice. However, while I accept that such a policy could bring real benefits, I am not convinced that it represents the best use of public money for most countries.
Supporters generally make two arguments. The first is environmental: if travel were free, it is claimed, motorists would abandon their cars, thus easing congestion and cleaning the air. The second concerns fairness, since fares represent a far greater burden on the poor than on the wealthy, and a lack of affordable transport can effectively shut people out of jobs. This second argument seems to me by far the stronger of the two.
The environmental case is less persuasive than it first appears. Evidence from cities that have tried free travel suggests that many of the new passengers were previously walking or cycling, rather than driving. Drivers tend to care more about speed, comfort and reliability than about price. This points to a deeper problem: fare revenue pays for a large share of the cost of many systems, and if it were removed, governments would be forced either to raise taxes or to accept poorer services. Yet a poor service is precisely what keeps people in their cars.
It would therefore be wiser to spend public funds on making transport frequent and dependable, and to direct free or cheap travel at those who truly need it, including students, pensioners and the unemployed.
In short, I disagree with the idea of free travel for everyone. The aim of helping the least well off is a worthy one, but it can be achieved more cheaply and fairly in other ways.
290 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 and 7 partly agree; Band 8 argues against, and it explains which claim is stronger.
Evidence: Band 8 says who the new passengers actually are.
Vocabulary: 'will help poor people' (6), 'people on low incomes' (7), 'the least well off' (8).
Cohesion: Band 8 links paragraphs by idea ('This points to a deeper problem').
Solution: all three propose targeting. A sensible alternative is a good way to end.
Tips for this task
'To what extent' lets you partly agree, but you must be clear how far.
Don't only list points for and against. Say which matter most.
Think about who pays. Most 'free' things are paid for by someone.
Use real examples only if you are sure of them, and keep them short.
Your final paragraph shouldn't introduce a brand-new argument.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.