Some people believe that children should be allowed to choose what they study at school. Others think that the subjects should be decided by adults.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, and a clear opinion is given, with a simple personal example. Well organised, but ideas are general, and the language is simple.
School is very important in the life of every child. Some people think that children should choose their own subjects, but other people think that teachers and parents should decide. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, some people believe that children should have a choice. If a child likes a subject, they will study harder and they will get better marks. For example, my younger brother loves drawing, and he is very happy in his art class, but he does not like history. If he could choose, he would enjoy school more. Also, when children make their own choices, they learn to be responsible.
On the other hand, many people think that adults should decide. Children are too young to know what they will need in the future. If a child does not choose maths, it can be very difficult for them to get a good job later. Teachers have a lot of experience, and they know which subjects are important for everyone. Also, some children will choose only easy subjects, because they do not want to work hard.
In my opinion, adults should choose the main subjects for young children, such as language, maths and science, because everyone needs these. But when students are older, for example fifteen or sixteen, they should be able to choose some subjects that they are interested in.
In conclusion, both views are reasonable. I think that the best way is for adults to choose for younger children, and for older students to have more freedom.
262 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position based on age, with both sides developed. Good vocabulary ('take responsibility', 'close doors', 'set curriculum'). Accurate and logically organised.
There is some debate about who should decide what children learn at school. While some people argue that the choice should be left to the children themselves, others believe that adults are in a better position to make this decision. In my view, the answer depends largely on the age of the child.
There are clear arguments in favour of giving children a choice. Students tend to work harder and to achieve more in subjects that they enjoy, and forcing them to study something that they dislike can make them lose interest in school altogether. Having a say in their education also teaches young people to make decisions, and to take responsibility for the results. My brother, for example, became far more confident once he was allowed to focus on art.
However, there are also strong reasons for adults to decide. Young children have little idea of what they may need in later life, and they may avoid difficult subjects like mathematics, which are essential for many careers. Without a broad education, they could close doors for themselves at an early age. Teachers and education experts have the experience to know what a well-educated person needs to learn.
In my opinion, younger children should follow a set curriculum, which provides them with basic skills in language, mathematics and science. As they get older, though, they should be given gradually more freedom to choose, so that by the age of about fifteen, they can begin to follow their own interests.
In conclusion, although adults should make most of the decisions in the early years, older students will benefit from having more control over what they study.
275 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful, well-argued essay that goes beyond the obvious ('Children can only choose among things they know about'), and it raises the issue of equality. Language is flexible and natural.
How much say children should have in their own education is a question that divides parents and teachers alike. Some maintain that young people learn best when they follow their interests, while others insist that such decisions are properly the responsibility of adults. I would argue that the choice between these views is less important than the question of when each one applies.
Those who favour student choice have a good deal of common sense on their side. A child who is interested in a subject will work harder at it without being told to, whereas one who feels forced will often do only what is needed to get by. Choice can also build a sense of ownership: those who have chosen a path are more inclined to stay on it when it gets difficult.
Yet the argument for adult direction is, in my view, stronger than it may first appear. Children can only choose among things they know about, and much of the purpose of school is to introduce them to subjects that they would never have discovered by themselves. A twelve-year-old who gives up physics because it seems difficult is making a decision whose consequences she cannot possibly understand. There is also a question of equality, as children from educated homes are likely to receive better advice about such choices than those from poorer ones.
The sensible approach, then, is to treat choice as something to be earned over time. In the early years, a broad common curriculum gives every child the same foundation. From about the age of fourteen or fifteen, students can start to specialise, with proper guidance.
In short, children should be given more say as they grow older, but only after adults have made sure that they know what there is to choose from.
300 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: all three say that it depends on age, but Band 8 calls choice 'something to be earned'.
Ideas: Band 8 points out that children can't choose subjects that they don't know about.
Vocabulary: 'they will study harder' (6), 'tend to work harder' (7), 'do only what is needed to get by' (8).
Fairness: only Band 8 raises the question of children from poorer homes.
Examples: Band 8's twelve-year-old makes a general point clearer.
Tips for this task
Give your own view in the introduction, so that the examiner knows where you're going.
One short personal example is plenty.
When you discuss one side, avoid giving your view until the end of that paragraph.
Think of a less obvious reason for each side.
Make sure that your conclusion says the same as your introduction.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.