Some schools do not allow students to bring mobile phones to school.
Do you agree or disagree with this policy?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion with relevant reasons, and it mentions the opposite view. The language is simple but correct, and it uses a personal example. Well organised.
Nowadays, most children have mobile phones. Some schools have decided that students cannot bring their phones to school. In my opinion, I agree with this rule, for a number of reasons.
Firstly, mobile phones stop students from paying attention in class. When a phone gets a message, students want to look at it immediately, and they do not listen to the teacher. Even if the phone is in the bag, they are thinking about it. In my school, one boy was always playing games under the desk, and his marks became very low. So phones are bad for learning.
Secondly, phones can create problems between students. Some students take photos of others without asking them, and put them on social media. This can make children very sad, and it is a form of bullying. Also, some students have very expensive phones, and those who have cheap phones may feel bad about it. Without phones, students talk to each other and play together in the break, and this is better for them.
Some parents say that their children need phones so that they can call them in an emergency. This is true, but the school has a phone, and parents can call the office. So I think that this is not a strong reason.
In conclusion, I agree that students should not bring mobile phones to school. Phones make it difficult to study, and they also cause problems between students. Children can use their phones when they get home. This is a simple rule, and it will help everyone.
258 words
Why this is Band 7: Clear position and well-developed arguments. Good use of vocabulary ('major distraction', 'valuable time'), and it deals with objections sensibly. Very few errors.
Mobile phones have become a normal part of life, even for quite young children, and this has led some schools to forbid them entirely. I strongly support this policy, as I believe that the disadvantages of having phones in school are much greater than the advantages.
The main reason is that phones are a major distraction. Even when students are not using them, the possibility of a message makes it difficult for them to concentrate, and research has shown that test results often improve in schools that ban them. Teachers also have to waste valuable time checking that students are not secretly using their phones during lessons. For this reason, removing them altogether would make life easier for everyone.
A further point is the effect on students' social lives. In many schools, phones are used for bullying, with photos being taken and shared without permission. They can also reduce real contact, as students spend their breaks looking at a screen and not talking to one another. When phones are removed, children are more likely to play games and to make friends in the traditional way.
It is true that parents like to be able to reach their children, particularly in an emergency. However, the school office can easily take messages, and children can be allowed to use their phones as soon as they leave the building. Some teachers also use phones for learning, but schools can provide computers for such activities.
In conclusion, I agree with this policy. School should be a place in which children can concentrate on learning and on each other, without being disturbed.
267 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful essay, with original points (phones are designed to capture attention). Language is natural and precise, and it has a strong conclusion.
A generation ago, the idea of a school banning telephones would have seemed absurd. Today, as more and more schools are forbidding students to bring smartphones through the gate, I find myself firmly on the side of those schools, although I accept that the policy has some costs.
The case rests mainly on attention. A phone is designed by some of the cleverest people in the world to capture a person's interest, and it is hardly fair to expect a twelve-year-old to resist it during a lesson on fractions. Research suggests that simply having one nearby reduces concentration, even if it remains switched off. Several countries have now introduced bans, and although the results vary, there are signs that weaker students in particular benefit, as they are the ones who are most easily distracted.
The second argument concerns what happens outside lessons. Breaks used to be a time for students to run around, argue and make friends, all of which teach skills that are at least as important as those in the classroom. In schools where phones are allowed, you can often see rows of silent children looking down at their screens. There is also the serious matter of online bullying, which, thanks to phones, can now follow a child into every corner of the building.
The usual objection is about safety, since parents understandably want to be able to contact their children. But in a real emergency, it is the school office which needs to know what is happening, and hundreds of children all calling home at once would help nobody. Those who need a phone for the journey can simply leave it at the office during the day.
For these reasons, I believe that such a policy is sensible. It does not reject technology. It simply gives children a few hours each day without it.
307 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Introduction: Band 8 starts with a comparison with the past.
Ideas: only Band 8 says that phones are designed to capture attention.
Evidence: Band 8 mentions weaker students.
Vocabulary: 'stop students from paying attention' (6), 'a major distraction' (7), 'reduces concentration' (8).
Objection: Band 8 gives a clever answer about emergencies.
Tips for this task
Make your opinion clear in the first paragraph.
Give two main reasons, with an example for each one.
Mention the other side, and say why you disagree.
Use your own experience, but also think about people in general.
Check that you've written at least 250 words. Don't write much more than 300.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.