Some people think that smoking should be banned in all public places.
Do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with reasons, a personal example and a reply to the other side. Language is simple but correct, and it's well organised.
Smoking is a very bad habit, and it causes many health problems. Some people think that it should be banned in all public places, such as restaurants, parks and bus stations. I completely agree with this idea, for several reasons.
Firstly, smoking harms other people, as well as the smoker. When someone smokes in a public place, people around them have to breathe the smoke, and this can cause serious diseases such as cancer. Children and old people are especially at risk. Nobody should have to breathe in someone else's smoke when they are waiting for a bus, or when they are eating in a restaurant. For example, my father does not smoke, but he used to work in an office with many smokers, and he had many problems with his breathing.
Secondly, a ban would encourage smokers to smoke less. If it is more difficult for them to smoke, then they may decide to stop. It would also give a good example to young people. If children do not see people smoking in public, then they will be less likely to think that it is normal.
Some people say that smokers have a right to choose what they do. This is true, but they do not have the right to harm other people. They can still smoke in their own homes, if they want to. In addition, smoking makes parks and streets dirty, because people throw their cigarettes on the ground.
In conclusion, I strongly believe that smoking should be banned in all public places, as it protects people's health and keeps our cities clean.
266 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-developed argument with real evidence (Ireland). Good range of vocabulary ('passive smoking', 'a useful incentive'). Strong final sentence.
Although the dangers of smoking are now widely known, many people continue to smoke in public places. It has been suggested that this should be banned altogether. I fully agree with this view, as the benefits for public health clearly outweigh any loss of personal freedom.
The most important argument is that smoking does not only affect smokers. Passive smoking is known to cause lung cancer and heart disease, and it is especially harmful for children and pregnant women. People who are forced to breathe in other people's smoke while they are waiting for a train or eating a meal have not chosen to take this risk. In countries such as Ireland, which introduced bans in workplaces and restaurants, hospital admissions for heart attacks fell quickly afterwards.
A ban would also help smokers themselves. Many of them would like to give up, and fewer places to smoke could provide a useful incentive. Furthermore, it would send a strong message to young people. If smoking is no longer seen as a normal part of everyday life, then fewer teenagers will start. There would also be a practical benefit, as public places would be cleaner, without the cigarette ends that make streets and beaches so unpleasant.
It may be argued that this would limit people's freedom, and that it would be hard to enforce outdoors. These are fair points, although the same objections were made to bans in restaurants, and these have been highly successful. Smokers would still be free to smoke at home.
In conclusion, I believe that smoking should not be allowed in any public place. People's freedom to smoke ends at the point where it damages the health of others.
281 words
Why this is Band 8: Thoughtful and persuasive, with a striking comparison and very natural language ('reasonable and overdue', 'ceases to appear normal'). It deals fairly with the argument about liberty.
It is not so long ago that people could smoke on aeroplanes, in cinemas and even in hospitals. Looking back, this seems extraordinary. I believe that the same thing will one day be said of smoking in parks and at bus stops, and that a complete ban in public places is both reasonable and overdue.
The central argument is a simple one. A person's freedom to do as they wish ends at the point where it harms somebody else. A smoker in a public place is making a decision on behalf of everyone nearby, including children and people with asthma, who may have no way of avoiding the smoke. We would never accept this from someone who was spraying a poisonous chemical into the air at a bus stop, and tobacco smoke does contain a great many of them. Where bans have been introduced, as in Ireland and Scotland, the evidence is striking. Hospital admissions for heart attacks fell within months, and among people who had never smoked.
There is also a less obvious benefit. Young people tend to copy what they see around them. If smoking becomes something which is rarely seen in public, then it ceases to appear normal or attractive, and the evidence suggests that fewer teenagers begin. As most smokers start before they are twenty, this may be the most effective protection of all. Interestingly, many smokers themselves support such measures, as they wish they could stop.
Those who object on the grounds of liberty have a case, as adults should be able to make their own choices, however foolish these may be. But a ban in public places does not prevent anyone from smoking. It simply asks them to do so where nobody else has to share the consequences. That seems to me to be a very small price to pay.
306 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 reminds us of how normal smoking once was.
Main argument: all mention harm to others, but Band 8 makes a comparison with a poison.
Evidence: Bands 7 and 8 use the example of Ireland.
Vocabulary: 'breathe the smoke' (6), 'passive smoking' (7), 'share the consequences' (8).
Objection: Band 8 accepts that adults may make foolish choices.
Tips for this task
State your opinion clearly, and keep to it.
Give two or three strong reasons, with an example for each.