In some societies, parents choose or strongly influence what career their children follow.
Do you think that this is a good or a bad thing?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion with both sides and a good family example. Language is simple but correct, and it's well organised.
In many countries, including India, parents often decide what their children should do when they grow up. Some parents want their children to become doctors or engineers, even if the children would like to do something else. In my opinion, this is mostly a bad thing, although parents can give some useful advice.
There are some reasons why parents want to help with this choice. They have more experience of life, and they understand which jobs are safe and well paid. Young people may not think about the future, and they may choose a job that sounds exciting, but which has low pay. Also, parents often pay for their children's education, so they feel that they should have a say about this. For example, my uncle wanted to be a musician, but his father made him study engineering, and now he has a very good salary.
However, I believe that this can cause many problems. People who do a job that they do not like will not be happy, and they may not do it very well. My uncle says that he still regrets not trying to become a musician. In addition, the pressure from parents can make young people very stressed. Some students who are forced to study medicine fail their exams, and they feel that they have let their family down.
In conclusion, I think that it is a bad thing if parents choose their children's careers. Parents should give advice and support, but young people must make the final decision for themselves, because they are the ones who will have to live with it.
267 words
Why this is Band 7: Well-developed reasons on both sides, and it has good points about old age and about change. Good range ('major say', 'financially secure').
In many cultures, it is common for parents to have a major say in what their children do for a living. While their intentions are usually good, I believe that this influence does more harm than good when it goes beyond advice, and that young people must have the final say.
It is easy to see why parents feel that they should be involved. They have a far better understanding of the job market than a seventeen-year-old does, and they want to see their children financially secure. In countries where there is little state support, a good job for the children may also be the only security that parents will have in their old age. Besides, many families make great sacrifices to pay for their children's education, and they naturally want this investment to be well used.
However, the disadvantages are serious. A career lasts for about forty years, and someone who has been pushed into a field that they dislike may spend all that time feeling frustrated. People also tend to do better in work which interests them, so that forcing a talented artist to study medicine may simply produce a poor doctor. The pressure can also be very damaging. In India, there are regular reports of students who suffer from severe stress and depression, because of their fear of disappointing their parents. Moreover, the world of work is changing so quickly that parents' experience may no longer be a reliable guide.
In conclusion, parents have a valuable role to play in advising their children, and in making sure that they consider the practical side of their choices. In the end, however, the decision has to belong to the person who will actually do the job.
287 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful and humane essay, with an excellent opening joke and insight ('what looks like control is usually fear'). It has very natural language, and it deals with a serious subject carefully.
There is an old joke in India about a mother who introduces her two small children as 'the doctor' and 'the engineer'. People laugh, but they also recognise it. In a society where parents may sacrifice everything for a child's education, a career is rarely seen as a private decision. I can understand why this is the case, but I believe that it causes a good deal of quiet unhappiness, and that it should be changed.
It would be unfair to dismiss the parents' point of view. Most of them have known real insecurity, and what looks like control is usually fear. They have seen what happens to those who follow their dreams with no money behind them, and they know how few people make a living as musicians. In a country without much of a welfare system, a child's secure job may also be the only pension that they will ever have. A seventeen-year-old, for that matter, knows very little about what any job actually involves.
The cost of this approach, however, is paid by the child, and it can last for a lifetime. Those who are sent into a career that they did not choose may do it competently, but they are unlikely to do it with any real enthusiasm, and that matters to their patients or clients as much as to themselves. Every year, newspapers here report on students who have suffered serious breakdowns under the pressure of exams for a course that they never wanted. Besides, parents' knowledge is rapidly becoming out of date. Many of today's best-paid jobs did not exist when they were young.
What is needed, I think, is not less involvement, but a different kind. Parents should share what they know, and they should insist that a child thinks seriously about money and about risk. But they must then be prepared to step back, as the life in question is not theirs.
320 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with a joke that makes a serious point.
Parents: Band 8 shows real understanding: 'what looks like control is usually fear'.
Change: Bands 7 and 8 mention that new jobs have appeared.