Some people believe that using animals for medical research is necessary. Others think that it is cruel and should be stopped.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, with a clear opinion. It gives relevant examples, and the language is simple but mostly correct.
Using animals in medical research is a very difficult subject. Some people believe that it is necessary to find new medicines, while others think that it is cruel, and that it should be stopped. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my own opinion.
On the one hand, many scientists say that animal research is necessary. Before a new medicine is given to people, it must be tested to make sure that it is safe. Many important medicines and vaccines were developed by using animals, such as treatments for diabetes and polio. Without this research, millions of people might have died. It is better to test a dangerous drug on a mouse than on a human being.
On the other hand, some people think that this is very cruel. Animals can feel pain and fear, just as we can, and they cannot agree to take part. Many of them are kept in small cages, and they are killed at the end of the tests. In addition, animals are different from humans, so a medicine that is safe for a mouse may not be safe for a person. Today, scientists can also use computers and other methods in some cases.
In my opinion, animal testing should only be used when it is really necessary for human health, and when there is no other way. It should never be used for things like cosmetics. Scientists should also make sure that animals do not suffer more than they have to, and they should try to find other methods.
In conclusion, I think that some animal research is still necessary, but it should be strictly controlled.
275 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-developed, balanced discussion. Good range of vocabulary ('morally unacceptable', 'giving their consent', 'outweighed'). It has a clear and sensible conclusion.
The use of animals in medical research has long been a subject of heated debate. While many people regard it as essential for developing new treatments, others believe that it is morally unacceptable. In my view, it can be justified in some cases, but only under strict conditions.
Those who defend the practice point to its many achievements. Nearly all of the major medical advances of the last century, from insulin to the polio vaccine, relied on research on animals. New drugs must be tested on a living body before they are given to humans, as it would be irresponsible to do otherwise. It is argued that the suffering of a small number of animals is outweighed by the many human lives which can be saved, and that this is a price worth paying.
Opponents, however, make some powerful points. Animals are capable of feeling pain and distress, and they have no way of giving their consent. Many spend their lives in small cages, and they are subjected to painful procedures. There is also a scientific objection, as the results from animals do not always apply to humans. It has been reported that more than nine in ten drugs that pass animal tests later fail in human trials. New technologies, including computer models and cells grown in the laboratory, could reduce the need for animals.
Overall, I believe that animal research should continue for the time being, but only where there is no alternative, and only where it is likely to bring serious medical benefits. Governments should invest more heavily in other methods, with the aim of ending the practice altogether in the long term.
275 words
Why this is Band 8: A sensitive and thoughtful essay that takes both sides seriously. It has very natural language ('in the abstract', 'a regrettable necessity'), and a strong final idea about future generations.
Anyone who has seen a child saved by a modern medicine, or a monkey in a laboratory cage, is likely to feel strongly about this question. It is one of those rare debates in which both sides have a truly serious moral argument, and I do not think that either of them should be dismissed. On balance, however, I would accept animal research as a regrettable necessity, for the moment.
The case for it is built on results. Insulin, antibiotics, vaccines and modern surgery all depended on it, in one way or another, and it is hard to imagine anyone who has not benefited from this work. If a new cancer drug has to be tested on something before it is given to a dying patient, then few parents would hesitate to choose a mouse over their own child. It is easy to oppose animal testing in the abstract, and rather harder to do so in a hospital.
Yet the argument is not as simple as that. An animal's suffering is real, and the fact that it cannot speak does not make it any less so. We are no longer able to say, as earlier scientists did, that animals are simply machines. The scientific case is also weaker than it is often claimed to be. A very large proportion of drugs which are shown to be safe in animals go on to fail in humans, which suggests that a mouse is often a poor model for a person. Rats, after all, were not the point of the exercise.
The sensible response is to treat this as a temporary compromise. Research should be permitted only when the medical need is serious and no alternative exists, and governments should spend far more on developing methods, such as human cells on chips, that may make it unnecessary. A future generation may look back at our laboratories with the same discomfort that we feel about earlier forms of cruelty. We should do what we can to get there sooner.
335 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 shows that both sides have real feelings.
Examples: all mention medicines, but Band 8 discusses the choice between a mouse and a child.
Science: Bands 7 and 8 point out that many drugs fail in humans.