As populations age, the question of who should care for elderly people becomes more pressing. Some people believe that it is the responsibility of the government, while others think that families should look after their own elderly relatives.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons, and a sensible 'shared responsibility' opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
As people live longer, many countries have more and more elderly people to care for. There is a debate about who should be responsible for this: the government or the family. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, many people believe that the government should care for the elderly. Old people have worked and paid taxes all their lives, so it is fair that the government looks after them when they are old. The government can provide care homes, nurses and pensions, which most families cannot afford on their own. Also, many families today are busy, with both parents working, so they do not have time to care for an elderly relative properly.
On the other hand, some people think it is the family's duty. They believe that children should look after the parents who once looked after them, and that it is a matter of love and respect. In many cultures, it is normal for several generations to live together. Elderly people are often happier living with their family than in a care home, where they may feel lonely.
In my opinion, the responsibility should be shared between the two. Families should give love and support, and should care for their relatives when they can, but the government should provide help, such as money, nurses who visit, and care homes for those who need them. Neither can do it alone.
In conclusion, caring for the elderly is a responsibility for both the family and the government, working together.
258 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced, well-developed essay, rejecting the either/or framing, with good vocabulary ('shoulder the entire burden') and a clear division of roles.
With people living longer than ever before, societies increasingly face the question of who should take responsibility for the care of the elderly: the state or the family. Both views have merit, but in my opinion the answer must be a partnership between the two.
Those who argue for government responsibility make a strong case. Elderly people have contributed to society through a lifetime of work and taxes, and it is only fair that society supports them in return. Moreover, proper care is often expensive and demanding, requiring medical knowledge and facilities that no ordinary family can provide. With modern families frequently having both partners in full-time work, and often living far from their parents, expecting them to shoulder the entire burden is increasingly unrealistic.
On the other hand, there is real value in the view that families should care for their own. Many elderly people would far rather be looked after by those who love them, in familiar surroundings, than by paid strangers in an institution. In many cultures, caring for one's parents is seen as a sacred duty and a natural repayment of the care once received. There is also evidence that elderly people with close family involvement remain healthier and happier.
In my view, framing this as an either/or choice is mistaken. The ideal is a system in which families provide love, company and day-to-day support, while the government provides the money, the professional care and the facilities that families cannot. Each does what it is best placed to do.
In conclusion, caring for the elderly should be a shared responsibility, combining the warmth of the family with the resources of the state.
276 words
Why this is Band 8: A moving personal opening and a subtle argument that love and expertise are partners. Very natural style, with a memorable line ('someone's father rather than room fourteen').
When my grandfather became too frail to live alone, my family held a long and painful discussion that, I later realised, was a small version of a debate now taking place across the whole ageing world. My aunt insisted we must care for him ourselves, as our family always had; my mother, a nurse, pointed out that love was no substitute for a hoist and a trained back. In the end, both were right, which is rather the point.
The argument for state responsibility is powerful and, I think, often underestimated. The elderly are not asking for charity; they are, in a real sense, collecting on a lifetime of contribution, and a decent society honours that debt. Beyond fairness, there is competence: modern elderly care frequently involves complex medical needs that a loving daughter, however devoted, simply cannot meet. And the quiet demographic truth is that families have shrunk and scattered, so that the old model, of a stay-at-home daughter available to care, has largely ceased to exist.
Yet the case for family care touches something the state can never provide. No care home, however excellent, can supply the particular comfort of being known, of being someone's father rather than room fourteen. My grandfather, in his good days, lit up at a familiar face in a way no professional kindness could produce. In many cultures, moreover, caring for one's parents is not a burden but a profound duty, and to outsource it entirely would feel like a betrayal.
My own view, formed at his bedside, is that the question is wrongly put. Love and expertise are not rivals but partners; what the elderly need is both. The state should provide the money, the nursing and the facilities; the family should provide the presence, the history and the love. In conclusion, caring for the old is too large and too tender a task for either the family or the government alone, and a humane society will insist on both.
328 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with the family discussion about the grandfather.
Argument: Band 6 ranks the views; Band 8 says the question is wrongly put.
Depth: Band 8 distinguishes what only family can give from what only the state can.
Vocabulary: 'look after' (6), 'shoulder the burden' (7), 'collecting on a lifetime of contribution' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 insists on both, in vivid terms.
Tips for this task
Discuss both views fairly before your opinion.
Give practical reasons (cost, work, culture, happiness).
A 'shared responsibility' view is fine, if clearly argued.
Use a real example if you can.
Say which side does what, rather than being vague.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.