Many young people today move to other countries to study or work.
What are the reasons for this?
Do you think that this has a positive or a negative effect on their home countries?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both questions are answered, with clear reasons and a relevant local example. Organisation is clear, using simple linking. There are some awkward phrases, but the meaning is always clear.
In the modern world, many young people want to go abroad for their studies or to find a job. In my country, India, and especially in Punjab, this has become very common. In this essay, I will discuss why this is happening and what effect it has on the home country.
There are several reasons why young people go abroad. The main reason is better opportunities. In developed countries, salaries are much higher, and there are more jobs for educated people. In India, many graduates cannot find good work, even after they have spent many years studying. Another reason is the quality of education and of life. Universities in countries like Canada and Australia are famous, and young people want a degree from there. They also want a clean environment and good facilities. Finally, many young people see their friends going abroad, so they also want to go.
In my opinion, this has both good and bad effects on the home country, but the bad effects are bigger. It is true that these people send money home, and this helps their families. They also learn new skills. However, many of the most talented people leave, like doctors and engineers, and the country spent money on their education, but they don't work for it. In Punjab, many villages now only have old people, and the houses are empty. Families also suffer, because parents live alone.
In conclusion, young people go abroad for better jobs and a better life. I think that this has a negative effect on the home country, and that the government should create more jobs, so that young people can stay.
273 words
Why this is Band 7: Both parts are well developed, with a clear opinion and good vocabulary ('open many doors', 'brain drain', 'social cost'). The essay is logical and accurate, with a thoughtful conclusion.
Over the last few decades, it has become increasingly common for young people to leave their home countries in order to study or work abroad. This trend is mainly driven by a desire for better opportunities, and although it brings some benefits, I believe that it has a largely negative effect on the countries they leave.
The most important reason is economic. Salaries in developed countries can be many times higher than at home, and in many developing countries, there are simply not enough good jobs for the number of graduates. Education is another major attraction, as a degree from a well-known foreign university can open many doors. In addition, many young people are looking for a higher standard of living, with better public services, cleaner cities and greater personal freedom. Social pressure also plays a part, particularly in regions such as Punjab, where going abroad has become a sign of success.
There are undoubtedly some positive effects for the home country. Money sent back by workers abroad can be a major source of income for families, and it helps to support the local economy. Some of those who leave also return later with valuable skills and experience.
Nevertheless, I would argue that the negative effects are more serious. Countries lose many of their most able young people, after spending public money on their education. This 'brain drain' is particularly damaging in fields such as medicine. There is also a social cost, with older people left alone and with some rural areas losing their young population altogether.
In conclusion, young people move abroad for understandable reasons, but unless they can be encouraged to return, their home countries are likely to suffer in the long term.
285 words
Why this is Band 8: A nuanced response that questions the 'usual view', using both local and national examples. It is precise ('in effect giving a gift to a far richer nation'), and it has a conclusion that makes a clear, memorable distinction.
For a growing number of young people, particularly in the developing world, a future abroad has become the goal around which their education and even their family's finances are organised. Anyone from a state like Punjab will recognise this. The reasons are not difficult to identify, but the effect on the countries they leave behind is more complicated than is often assumed.
The forces behind this movement are both economic and cultural. In many countries, the economy has simply failed to create enough skilled jobs for the number of graduates that it produces, while wealthy nations with ageing populations are actively looking for workers. A foreign degree offers a route into this market, as well as a level of personal freedom and public services that may not be available at home. Added to this is the power of example. When every family in a village has a relative in Canada, staying at home can begin to look like failure.
The usual view is that this is a straightforward loss, and there is much truth in this. A country that trains a doctor at public expense, only to see her working in another health service, is in effect giving a gift to a far richer nation. In parts of rural Punjab, the effects can be seen in locked houses and elderly parents living alone. Yet this is only one side of the picture. Money sent home by migrants is now worth more to many developing countries than foreign aid, and it goes directly to families. Those abroad also form networks that can bring trade and investment, and those who return often bring skills and ideas that could not have been acquired at home. India's software industry owes a good deal to people who did exactly this.
On balance, I believe that the effect is negative when the movement is one-way, and positive when people, money and ideas flow in both directions. The task for governments, therefore, is not to stop young people from leaving, but to give them good reasons to come back.
342 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Causes: Band 8 links them to richer countries' needs as well.
Effects: Band 8 challenges the idea that it is simply a loss.
Examples: Band 8 uses the software industry and rural Punjab.
Vocabulary: 'talented people leave' (6), 'brain drain' (7), 'a gift to a far richer nation' (8).
Opinion: Band 8's view depends on whether movement is one-way.
Tips for this task
This essay has two questions. Plan one paragraph for the reasons, and at least one for the effects.
Use examples that you know well, such as your own region.
Don't give too many reasons. Explain three properly.
'Brain drain' is a useful term, but explain what it means in your context.
State your opinion clearly in the introduction or the conclusion, or both.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.