Top professional sports players are paid far more than people in other important jobs, such as nurses and teachers.
Do you think that this is fair?
What could be done to change this situation, if anything?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both questions are answered, with a clear opinion and two suggestions. Ideas are simple but relevant. Vocabulary is limited ('very important', 'a lot of money'), but it's well organised.
Today, famous sports players earn a lot of money, for example football players and cricket players. Some of them earn more in one week than a nurse earns in many years. I do not think that this is fair, and I will explain why.
The work of nurses and teachers is very important for society. A nurse saves people's lives, and a teacher helps children to have a good future. They also work very hard, and sometimes they work at night and at weekends. On the other hand, a sports player only plays a game, which is for entertainment. Although they train very hard, their job is not as important as the job of a nurse. So it is not fair that they get much more money.
However, it is not easy to change this. Sports players get a lot of money because many people watch them on TV, and companies pay them to advertise. I think that the government can do two things. First, it can make rich sports players pay more tax. Second, it can use this money to increase the pay of nurses and teachers. Then those people will feel more respected, and more young people will want to do these jobs. This is important, because many hospitals and schools now do not have enough staff.
In conclusion, in my opinion it is unfair that sports players earn so much money while nurses and teachers earn little. The government should use higher taxes to reduce this difference, because these jobs are more important for our society.
259 words
Why this is Band 7: Considers the opposing view fairly, and it makes the useful distinction between why and whether. The suggestions are practical. Good range ('under considerable pressure', 'essential workers').
It is a striking fact that a leading footballer can earn more in a week than a nurse does in several years. In my view, this is difficult to justify in terms of what each person contributes to society, although changing it would not be simple.
There is a strong argument that the situation is unfair. Nurses and teachers do work that is essential, and they often do it for long hours and under considerable pressure. Without them, a society could not function, whereas sport, however enjoyable, is ultimately a form of entertainment. Those who defend high salaries point out that careers in sport are short and that only a tiny number of players reach the top. They also argue that salaries simply reflect the huge amounts of money that fans and television companies are willing to pay. This explains why players are paid so much, but it does not show that it is fair.
As for what could be done, limiting salaries directly would be hard, since top players could move to another country. A more realistic approach would be to raise taxes on very high incomes, and to use the money to improve pay in the public services. Sports organisations could also be required to give a share of their income to community sport and to schools. Perhaps most importantly, governments must recognise that low pay is causing serious shortages of nurses and teachers.
In conclusion, although the market explains these differences, I do not believe that they are fair. Governments cannot control the wages of athletes, but they can make sure that essential workers are properly rewarded.
270 words
Why this is Band 8: Reframes the question in the first paragraph, and it explains the economics clearly ('scarcity and the size of the audience'). Original and well controlled, with natural, confident language.
When a single footballer can earn in a week what a nurse earns in a decade, it is natural to feel that something has gone wrong. I share that feeling, although I think that the problem has less to do with what athletes are paid than with what nurses and teachers are not.
If pay were related to the value of the work, then the unfairness would be obvious. A nurse on a night shift may well save a life, and a good teacher can change the direction of hundreds of them, whereas even the finest cricketer offers little more than pleasure. But pay has never worked in that way. It reflects scarcity and the size of the audience. There are very few people on earth who can do what a top athlete does, and hundreds of millions of people will pay to watch them. The money that does not go to the players would simply stay with club owners and television companies, and it is hard to see why that would be any fairer.
This suggests that attacking the salaries of sports stars would be largely symbolic. Moreover, any country that attempted to cap them would merely see its best players leave. It would be more useful to focus on the other side of the equation. Governments control, or strongly influence, the wages of public sector workers, and they can raise them, funding this if necessary through higher taxes on the very largest incomes of all kinds, not only those in sport.
In short, the gap is unjust, but the injustice lies in the undervaluing of essential work. We should spend less time resenting athletes, and more time deciding what we are prepared to pay for our hospitals and schools.
291 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 8 changes the focus from high pay to low pay.
Argument: Band 7 notes that the market explains but doesn't justify; Band 8 asks where the money would go.
Vocabulary: 'a lot of money' (6), 'huge amounts of money' (7), 'largely symbolic' (8).
Solutions: Band 8 taxes all very large incomes, not only those of athletes.
Ending: Band 8 ends with a memorable thought.
Tips for this task
There are two questions here. Make sure that you answer both.
Don't just say that nurses are more important. Explain why the pay is so different.
Think about what would really happen if your solution were applied.
Use one example from your own country, if you can.
Avoid emotional language, and be fair to the other side.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.