In a number of cities, private cars have been banned from the central areas.
Is this a positive or a negative development?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear answer, with both positive and negative points and a personal example. Ideas are relevant, though general, and the language is simple. Few serious errors.
In many big cities, traffic is a serious problem. For this reason, some cities have decided that private cars cannot go into the city centre. In my opinion, this is mostly a positive development, although there are also some problems.
There are many good points of banning cars. Firstly, the air in the city will be cleaner, because there will be less smoke from cars. This is very important for the health of people, especially for children and old people. In my city, Delhi, the air in winter is very bad, and many people have problems with breathing. Secondly, the streets will be quieter and safer. People can walk in the road without worrying about an accident, and they can enjoy shopping and meeting their friends.
However, there are also some negative points. Some shop owners will be worried, because customers cannot come by car and they may go to another place. Also, it is difficult for old people or disabled people, if they cannot drive to the place that they want to go to. So the government should provide good buses and special permission for these people. Without these things, the ban will only help some people, and others will stay away from the centre.
In conclusion, I think that banning cars in the city centre is a good thing, because it makes the air cleaner and the streets safer. But the government must make sure that there is good public transport, so that everyone can still visit the centre easily and shops do not lose their customers.
259 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position with a condition attached. Both sides are developed, and there's a real example (Madrid). Good vocabulary ('limited mobility', 'exemptions'). Very well organised.
A growing number of cities have decided to keep private cars out of their central districts. Although this can cause difficulties for some groups, I believe that it is, on balance, a positive step, provided that good alternatives are available.
The most obvious benefit is an improvement in air quality. Traffic is one of the main sources of pollution in urban areas, and removing it from the centre can have a rapid effect on the health of those who live and work there. This is particularly important in cities like Delhi, where smog has become a serious public health issue. A second advantage is that the streets become far more pleasant. Without traffic, there is room for pedestrians, cyclists and outdoor cafes, and city centres can once again become places where people want to spend time.
Nevertheless, there are genuine concerns. Shopkeepers often fear that they will lose customers, and those with limited mobility may find it harder to reach the centre. These are serious objections, but they can be dealt with. Experience from cities such as Madrid suggests that retail sales do not necessarily fall, and may even rise, when streets are pedestrianised. Exemptions can also be made for disabled drivers and for deliveries outside busy hours.
In conclusion, I consider this trend to be largely positive, because of its benefits for health and for the quality of urban life. However, such a ban will only succeed if it is accompanied by cheap and reliable public transport, as well as careful planning for those who would otherwise be left out.
261 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated argument with an original point about urban land. It deals with the objections and turns them into support for its own position. Language is precise and natural ('should not be dismissed lightly', 'falls unevenly').
Banning private cars from city centres was once considered a radical idea, but it is now a reality in cities from Oslo to Madrid. While the policy undoubtedly has its costs, I am convinced that it represents a positive change, because it corrects a mistake that was made when cities were redesigned around the motor car.
The case for it rests chiefly on health and on the use of space. Road traffic remains a major cause of the air pollution that shortens millions of lives, and in a city like Delhi, the winter smog has become impossible to ignore. Less obvious, but perhaps as important, is the question of how we use urban land. A parked car occupies the space of a small room for most of the day, and it benefits only its owner. If that space is given back to pedestrians, cyclists and trees, then the whole community gains. People tend to linger in such places, and they often spend more money there as well.
The objections should not be dismissed lightly. The burden of a ban falls unevenly, and it is often heaviest on the elderly, the disabled and those who live on the edge of the city, where buses may be rare. A policy that makes the centre pleasant only for those who can afford to live nearby would be deeply unfair. Yet this is an argument for designing such bans carefully, with exemptions and good public transport already in place, and not an argument for abandoning them.
In short, while no city should impose a ban without providing alternatives, the overall effect is positive. A city centre should exist primarily for people, and not for their vehicles.
282 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: all say 'positive', but Band 8 explains why at a deeper level ('corrects a mistake').
Ideas: only Band 8 discusses the use of urban space.
Counter-argument: Band 7 answers it with evidence; Band 8 turns it into a point about design.
Vocabulary: 'cleaner air' (6), 'improvement in air quality' (7), 'the air pollution that shortens millions of lives' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 ends on a clear statement of principle.
Tips for this task
With 'positive or negative', say which you think, and don't sit on the fence.
You can still accept the other side, but say why your view is stronger.
Use a real city as an example only if you're sure of the facts.
Don't write only about pollution. Think of a second, less obvious reason.
Show who wins and who loses from a policy, as this makes your argument more balanced.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.