Some people think that individuals should pay for their own healthcare. Others believe that it should be provided free by the government.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, with a clear opinion and a local example. Language is simple but correct, and it's well organised.
Healthcare is very important for everybody. Some people think that people should pay for their own treatment, while others believe that it should be free, and that the government should pay for it. In this essay, I will discuss both views, and I will give my own opinion.
On the one hand, some people believe that individuals should pay for their healthcare. If people must pay, then they will be more careful about their health, and they will not go to the doctor for small problems. Also, private hospitals often give a better service, and patients do not have to wait for a long time. In addition, the government can use its money for other things, such as schools and roads.
On the other hand, many people think that healthcare should be free. Poor people cannot pay for expensive treatment, so they may die from illnesses that could be cured. For example, in India, many families have to sell their land when a family member becomes very ill. Free healthcare can help people to stay healthy, and they can go on working. It also helps to stop the spread of diseases, and this is good for everyone.
In my opinion, healthcare should be free for everyone, or at least for those who are poor. Being healthy is a basic human right, and it should not depend on how much money you have. People who are rich can choose to go to private hospitals, if they want to. The government should collect taxes in order to pay for this.
In conclusion, although there are some arguments for paying for healthcare, I believe that the government should provide it free of charge.
280 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced discussion, using good examples (the UK, the US, India). Good range ('bear the cost', 'at the expense of'). A clear conclusion.
How healthcare should be paid for is one of the most important questions facing any society. While some people argue that individuals should bear the cost themselves, others believe that it should be provided free by the state. In my view, governments have a clear duty to ensure that everyone has access to basic treatment.
Those who favour a private system make a number of reasonable points. They argue that when people pay directly, they are likely to use services more responsibly, and to take better care of their own health. Competition between private hospitals can also lead to higher standards and shorter waiting times. Moreover, government health services can be very expensive, and they are often criticised for being inefficient, as is sometimes said of the National Health Service in Britain.
However, the arguments for free healthcare are stronger. Illness is often a matter of bad luck, and not of personal choice, and nobody should be denied treatment simply because they are poor. In countries without a proper public system, a serious illness can ruin a family financially. India, for example, sees millions of people pushed into poverty each year by medical bills. Free healthcare also benefits society as a whole, as a healthy population is more productive, and diseases are less likely to spread. It is also notable that countries with public systems often spend less per person than the United States, and they get better results.
In conclusion, although private healthcare has some advantages, I believe that basic treatment should be free for all citizens. Those who want extra comfort or faster service should be able to pay for it, but this should not be at the expense of those who cannot.
285 words
Why this is Band 8: A powerful and thoughtful essay, explaining why healthcare is different from other services ('they cannot shop around when they are having a heart attack'). Very natural and precise.
A serious illness is one of the few misfortunes that can happen to anybody, and how a society responds to it says a great deal about its values. Some people argue that healthcare is a service like any other, for which people should pay, while others regard it as a right which the state must provide. My own view is firmly with the second group, although I accept that the first has some real points to make.
The case for individual payment rests on incentives. Something that appears to be free is likely to be overused, and governments have little reason to run services efficiently, as anyone who has waited a year for an operation will confirm. Competition, on the other hand, can encourage higher standards. These are not trivial arguments, and the difficulties of Britain's National Health Service show that public systems are far from perfect.
Yet healthcare differs from other services in ways that make the market a poor guide. People do not choose to have cancer, and they cannot shop around when they are having a heart attack. Nor are they in any position to judge the treatment they are being offered. The result of leaving this to the market can be seen in the United States, which spends far more per person than any other country, and yet which has a shorter life expectancy than most of its wealthy neighbours. In India, where most people pay for their own treatment, medical bills push tens of millions into poverty each year. I have seen a family sell its land in order to pay for an uncle's surgery, and he died anyway.
I would therefore argue that basic healthcare must be paid for collectively, through taxation. Those who are lucky enough to be healthy should help those who are not, since none of us knows when we may need the same help ourselves.
315 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with a general thought about illness.
Key idea: only Band 8 explains why the market doesn't work for healthcare.
Evidence: Bands 7 and 8 compare countries.
Vocabulary: 'pay for' (6), 'bear the cost' (7), 'paid for collectively' (8).
Personal touch: Band 8 uses a very short, strong family example.
Tips for this task
Give both views a full paragraph before you state your own view clearly.
Use country examples only if you're sure of the general facts.
Words such as 'taxation', 'insurance' and 'public system' are useful here.
Accept the strengths of the other side.
Don't write only about your family's experience.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.