Some people believe that individuals should be responsible for saving for their own retirement. Others think that this should be the responsibility of the government.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, and it gives a clear opinion. The language is simple but accurate. There are some relevant examples.
As people live for longer, the question of how to pay for their retirement is becoming more important. Some people think that everybody should save money for themselves, while others believe that the government should pay for this. I will discuss both of these views in this essay, and I will give my own opinion.
On the one hand, some people believe that individuals should save for themselves. Everyone knows that they will get old one day, so they should plan for it, and they should not expect other people to pay. It also teaches people to be careful with money. If the government pays for everyone, taxes must be very high, and this is hard for young workers. As there are more and more old people, it may become too expensive.
On the other hand, many people cannot save enough money. Those who have low wages need all of their income for food and for rent, so they have nothing left. Some people may also lose their savings, because of illness or a bad investment. In India, many old people who worked on farms or in small shops have no pension at all, and they depend on their children. The government should help these people, as they have worked hard all their lives.
In my opinion, both of them should share the responsibility. The government should give a basic pension to everybody, so that nobody is very poor in old age. But people who earn more should also save some money for themselves, if they want to have a more comfortable life.
In conclusion, I think that a mixture of government and individual saving is the best system.
279 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-developed essay, using a good example (Japan). Good vocabulary ('burden on taxpayers', 'ratio', 'financial crisis'). It has a clear and sensible position.
With people living longer than ever before, there is growing debate about who should pay for their old age. While some people argue that individuals should take responsibility for their own future, others believe that it is a duty of the state. In my opinion, the fairest approach is one in which both have a part to play.
The case for personal responsibility is an attractive one. Everyone knows that they will eventually stop working, and those who save throughout their lives are entitled to enjoy the benefits of this. It encourages people to plan ahead, and it reduces the burden on taxpayers. This is becoming an increasingly urgent matter, as the number of working people who support each pensioner is falling in many countries. In Japan, for example, this ratio has dropped sharply, which has put great pressure on public finances.
However, relying on individuals alone has serious drawbacks. Many low-paid workers simply cannot afford to save, and others may be affected by illness, unemployment or a financial crisis, none of which are their fault. Research has also shown that people tend to be very poor at planning for the distant future, and that they often leave it until it is too late. Without some state support, a large number of elderly people would be left in poverty, and this would be unacceptable in any decent society.
In conclusion, I believe that governments should provide a basic pension for everyone, which would be enough to live on. At the same time, people should be encouraged to save more, and employers should be required to contribute, so that they can enjoy a higher standard of living when they retire.
279 words
Why this is Band 8: Excellent, with a personal story that makes the point about luck. It deals with both sides with real understanding, and it has a very natural style and a neat ending.
My grandfather spent forty years as a clerk in the Indian railways, and he retired on a government pension which has kept him in modest comfort ever since. A taxi driver of the same age in my neighbourhood, who has worked just as hard for even longer, has no pension at all, and he is still driving at seventy-four. Neither of them made any particular decisions about this. It seems to me that any discussion of who should pay for old age has to begin by recognising how much depends on luck.
Those who argue for individual responsibility have a point. It is reasonable to expect adults to think about their own future, and a government which promises too much will end up passing on the costs to young workers, who are already struggling. With ageing populations, this is a growing problem, and countries such as Japan and Italy are finding that there are not enough workers to pay for all of those who have retired. Money that is saved also tends to be invested, which can benefit the economy as a whole.
The weakness of this argument, however, is that it assumes that people are able to save, and that they will do so. A cleaner on a minimum wage has nothing left at the end of the month, and even those who could save are notoriously bad at it. We all find it hard to take seriously the needs of the old person whom we will one day become. Besides, private savings can be wiped out overnight by a financial crisis, as many discovered in 2008.
The most sensible model, in my view, is the one that is used in countries such as the Netherlands. The state provides a basic income for all, and on top of this, workers are automatically enrolled in a savings scheme, from which they may opt out. It would allow the taxi driver to stop working, without asking my grandfather's grandchildren to pay for everything.
332 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 compares two real people.
Reasons: Band 7 mentions poor planning, and Band 8 explains it in a human way.
Examples: Band 7 uses Japan, and Band 8 adds the Netherlands.
Vocabulary: 'cannot save enough' (6), 'cannot afford to save' (7), 'notoriously bad at it' (8).
Solution: Band 8 explains a real system, with automatic enrolment.
Tips for this task
Discuss both sides, and don't forget to give your view.
Think about those who earn low wages.
Use useful words: 'pension', 'retirement', 'taxpayers', 'ageing population'.
A mixed answer is fine, as long as it's clearly explained.
Plan so that each side gets enough space.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.