Some people believe that governments should spend money on the arts, such as music and painting. Others think that this money would be better spent on public services, such as health and education.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both sides are discussed, with a clear opinion and some reasonable points. Language is simple but accurate. It's well organised.
Governments have to decide how to spend their money. Some people believe that they should give money to the arts, like music and painting, while others think that public services such as hospitals and schools are more important. In this essay, I will discuss both views, and I will give my own opinion.
On the one hand, public services are very important for everybody. If people are ill, they need hospitals and doctors, and all children need a good education. In many countries, including India, there are not enough hospitals, and many schools have no good buildings. So it may seem wrong to spend money on paintings when people cannot get medical care. Also, not everybody is interested in the arts, and it is often only rich people who go to concerts and art galleries.
On the other hand, the arts are also important for a country. They show the culture and history of a nation, and they make life more enjoyable for people. Many tourists visit other countries in order to see famous museums and to hear their music, and this brings in money and creates jobs. Without help from the government, many artists could not continue to work, and some traditional forms of music and dance may disappear.
In my opinion, public services should come first, especially in poor countries, but governments should also give a small amount of money to the arts. The arts do not cost very much in comparison with hospitals, but they can give a lot to society.
In conclusion, I think that both are important, although health and education must be the main priority.
271 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-developed and balanced essay. It has good vocabulary ('underfunded', 'a subsidy', 'creative industry') and a good real example.
How governments should divide their limited budgets is a difficult question. While some argue that funding for the arts is a valuable investment, others believe that it cannot be justified when public services are under such pressure. In my view, although essential services must come first, a modest amount of public money for the arts can be defended.
Those who favour spending on public services have a strong case. Hospitals and schools meet the most basic needs of the population, and many of them are seriously underfunded. It is difficult to explain to a patient on a long waiting list why money is being spent on an opera house. There is also an issue of fairness, since audiences for museums and concerts tend to be wealthier and better educated, and so public funding of the arts can sometimes amount to a subsidy for those who could afford to pay.
On the other hand, there are strong arguments for supporting the arts. A country's music, literature and painting are an important part of its identity, and many of its traditional art forms could not survive on the market alone. The arts also have significant economic benefits, as they attract tourists and support a large creative industry. The Edinburgh Festival, for example, brings hundreds of millions of pounds to the city each year. In addition, there is growing evidence that participation in the arts can benefit people's mental health, and it can help children's development.
In conclusion, I believe that health and education should always be the priority. However, arts funding is such a small part of most budgets that ending it would make little difference to those services, while causing great harm to our cultural life.
285 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful, honest and persuasive essay, with a strong opening and an interesting argument about numbers. Very natural and precise language, and an excellent final sentence.
It is hard to make the case for a new theatre to someone who has been waiting a year for a hip operation. Any discussion of this topic has to start by admitting that. Yet I would suggest that the way in which this question is usually put, as a straight choice between hospitals and the arts, is rather misleading, and that a civilised country should be able to do both.
The argument for putting public services first is very simple and very strong. Nobody has ever died from a lack of opera, and in countries where children still sit on the floors of their classrooms, spending money on an art gallery may look like an insult. It should also be admitted that much arts funding does end up benefiting the middle classes, who make up most of the audience, and who could probably afford to pay the full price for their tickets.
But consider the actual numbers. In most countries, spending on culture amounts to well under one per cent of the budget, and if all of this were moved to health, it would pay for only a few days of the service. Meanwhile, its loss would be permanent. An orchestra or a traditional craft which has taken generations to develop cannot be brought back once it has gone. Moreover, the arts are not simply a luxury. They are how a society talks to itself and remembers its past. People who are facing illness and death often turn to music and to stories, as anyone who has worked in a hospital can tell you. They also bring in a good deal of money, and many of Britain's most successful exports began in publicly funded theatres.
I would therefore continue to fund both, while making sure that arts money reaches beyond the wealthy, into schools and into poorer areas. A society that can keep people alive but gives them nothing to live for has only done half of its job.
330 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins by admitting the strength of the other side.
Fairness: Bands 7 and 8 note that the rich may benefit most.
Numbers: only Band 8 uses the small size of arts budgets as an argument.