In many towns, shops in the town centre are closing because people are buying more goods online.
What problems does this cause?
What can be done to solve these problems?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both parts are answered, with a clear set of problems and solutions. Language is simple but accurate, and it's well organised.
Today, many people buy clothes, books and other things on the internet, as it is cheap and easy. As a result, many shops in town centres have closed. In this essay, I will discuss the problems that this causes, and I will suggest some solutions.
The first problem is the loss of jobs. Shops employ many local people, especially young people and women who work part-time. When a shop closes, these people may find it difficult to get another job. The second problem is that town centres become less attractive. If there are many empty shops, the area looks dirty and unsafe, and fewer people want to go there. This means that the remaining shops and cafes also lose customers. Finally, older people and people who cannot use the internet may find it harder to buy the things that they need, and they lose a place to meet other people.
There are several things that can be done. First, local governments can reduce the taxes on small shops, and they can also make online companies pay more tax. Second, parking in town centres should be cheap or free, so that people can come easily. Third, empty shops could be used for other purposes, such as flats, offices, clinics or community centres, so that there are people in the town centre during the day. Finally, towns can hold markets and festivals to attract people.
In conclusion, the closing of shops causes unemployment and makes our towns less pleasant. However, if governments and local people work together, then town centres can continue to be useful and busy places.
266 words
Why this is Band 7: Well developed, with a good idea ('vicious circle'). It uses good vocabulary and has a clear position about giving town centres a new role.
The rapid growth of online shopping has been convenient for consumers, but it has had a damaging effect on the high street, with many long-established shops being forced to close. This essay will consider the main problems that have resulted from this, and it will suggest some possible solutions.
The most immediate consequence is economic. Retail is a major employer, particularly of young people and part-time workers, and these jobs are not easily replaced by those in distant warehouses. There is also a kind of vicious circle: as shops close, town centres look more neglected and attract fewer visitors, which in turn causes other businesses to suffer. Beyond this, there are social costs. A town centre is a place where people meet, and for older residents, a visit to the shops may be their main contact with other people each day.
However, there are several ways of addressing these problems. Governments could make the tax system fairer, as high street shops often pay heavy property taxes, while large online companies pay relatively little. More fundamentally, I believe that town centres need to find a new purpose, since people are unlikely to stop shopping online. Empty buildings could be turned into housing, clinics, libraries or small workspaces, so that more people have a reason to be there. Local councils could also support markets and events, and improve public transport and pedestrian areas, in order to make the centre a pleasant place to spend time.
In conclusion, the decline of town-centre shops has serious economic and social effects. The answer lies not in trying to bring back the past, but in giving these places a broader role.
275 words
Why this is Band 8: A memorable personal opening, with a shrewd point that consumers have caused the problem. It has an impressive range of language and a thoughtful ending.
The shoe shop where my mother bought every pair I wore until I was fifteen is now a vape store, and it stands between a phone-repair kiosk and a window with a faded 'To Let' sign. Nobody decided that this should happen. It is simply the sum of millions of sensible decisions by people, including me, to save ten per cent and a bus fare. That is what makes the problem so hard, as the people who regret its effects are the same people who have caused it.
The costs go well beyond lost sales. Retail has long been the first job for young people and a flexible one for parents, and the warehouse work that replaces it tends to be elsewhere, and is often worse. Decline also feeds on itself: each closure removes a reason to visit, which makes the next closure more likely, and the emptier streets feel less safe. But the loss that is hardest to measure may be the most important. A town centre is one of the few places where people of different ages and incomes still come across each other by accident, and for an elderly person who lives alone, the conversation at the shop counter may be the only one of the day. Nobody has that kind of chat with a delivery driver.
I do not think that the answer is to try to make people shop as they used to. Taxes could certainly be made fairer, since a bookshop pays heavily for its premises while its online rival pays comparatively little. But the more promising approach is to accept that the centre will never again be dominated by shops, and to bring people back for other reasons. Several British and Dutch towns have converted empty department stores into a mixture of flats, clinics, libraries and workshops. People who live and work in a town centre will buy their lunch there, and small independent shops can survive on that.
The high street of the future will be smaller and more varied than the one I grew up with. It may not sell me any shoes, but it could still give people a reason to leave the house.
364 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with a real shop.
Problems: Band 6 lists them, while Band 8 explains how they feed each other.
Solutions: Bands 7 and 8 say that the centre needs a new role.