Some people think that the government should spend money on public services such as hospitals and schools, rather than on the arts, such as music and painting.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position (partial agreement) with relevant reasons on both sides and a sensible economic point. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
Governments have limited money, and they must decide how to spend it. Some people believe that it should all go to essential public services, like hospitals and schools, and that the arts should not be funded. I partly agree with this, but I do not fully agree.
It is certainly true that public services must come first. Hospitals and schools are essential for everybody, and they can save lives and give children a future. If a government has to choose between funding a hospital and funding an orchestra, then clearly the hospital is more important, because health and education are basic needs, while the arts are not.
However, I do not think this means that the arts should receive no money at all. The arts are also important for society, although in a different way. They make life enjoyable and meaningful, they are part of our culture and history, and they can bring people together. Many museums and theatres would close without some public support, because they cannot survive on ticket sales alone, and this would be a great loss.
I also think that the arts can bring economic benefits. Many tourists visit a country because of its museums, its music and its historic buildings, and this brings in money that can then be spent on hospitals and schools.
In conclusion, I agree that public services should be the first priority for government spending. However, I believe that the arts also deserve some support, because they are valuable to society and can even help the economy.
256 words
Why this is Band 7: A well-structured essay that concedes the priority of public services while arguing convincingly that the choice is misleadingly framed, supported by points about relative cost, cultural value and tourism. Good vocabulary and a clear, qualified position.
Faced with limited budgets, governments must constantly choose where to direct public money, and many argue that essential services such as hospitals and schools should always take precedence over the arts. While I accept that health and education must come first, I disagree with the implication that the arts therefore deserve nothing, and will explain why.
The case for prioritising public services is undeniably strong. Hospitals and schools meet the most basic human needs, saving lives and equipping the next generation for the future. When resources are scarce, it would be indefensible to fund a new concert hall while patients wait on trolleys in corridors, and in any direct contest between the two, the hospital must win.
Yet this way of framing the issue is, I believe, somewhat misleading. The sums involved in arts funding are tiny compared with health and education budgets, so cutting the arts entirely would barely affect the larger services, while doing real damage. Museums, orchestras and theatres often cannot survive on ticket sales alone, and without modest public support many would simply close, impoverishing the cultural life that is part of the fabric of a nation.
Moreover, the two are not wholly separate. A country's artistic heritage draws millions of tourists, generating income that helps to pay for the very hospitals and schools in question, and the arts have well-documented benefits for mental health and education themselves.
In conclusion, while I firmly agree that essential public services should be the priority, I disagree that this justifies abandoning the arts. The wiser course is to fund services generously and the arts modestly, recognising that a good society needs both.
273 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that accepts the priority of public services but dismantles the 'false opposition', using sharp points about the relative size of arts budgets and the ultimate purpose of public spending ('a life worth living'). Assured, persuasive and original.
Whenever budgets are tight, a familiar argument resurfaces: that money spent on art galleries and orchestras would be better spent on hospital beds and classrooms. It is an argument with obvious emotional force – few would defend a violin over a child's education – and yet I believe it rests on a false opposition, and that a country can and should fund both.
Let me first grant what is true in it. Health and education are the foundations of a decent society, meeting needs so fundamental that nothing should come before them. If the genuine choice were between a cancer ward and a sculpture, only one answer is possible, and I would give it without hesitation. To that extent, the priority of essential services is beyond argument.
But this stark either/or is, I think, a kind of trick of the imagination. The entire national arts budget in most countries is a rounding error beside health and education spending; abolishing it would add almost nothing to a hospital's resources, while stripping a nation of its galleries, its music and its theatres. We would suffer an enormous cultural loss in exchange for a negligible financial gain – a spectacularly bad bargain.
There is also the matter of what services are for. We fund hospitals and schools not as ends in themselves but so that people can live full, meaningful lives – and art, music and literature are a central part of what makes a life meaningful. A society that kept its citizens alive and educated, but gave them nothing beautiful to live for, would have missed the entire point of the exercise.
In conclusion, I agree wholeheartedly that public services must come first, but I reject the notion that the arts must therefore come nowhere. The real choice is not between hospitals and art, but between a narrow view of what a society is for and a fuller one; and I know which I would choose.
324 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 partly agrees; Band 8 argues the choice itself is a false one.
Argument: Band 8 stresses how small arts budgets are compared with health.
Examples: both mention tourism; Band 7 adds the closure of theatres.
Vocabulary: 'make life enjoyable' (6), 'the fabric of a culture' (7).
Conclusion: both support some arts funding; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Make your position clear: how far do you agree?
Acknowledge the strong case for public services.
Give reasons why the arts might still deserve support.
Use an example, such as tourism or local theatres.
A balanced position is fine, if clearly argued.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.