Some people believe that schools should be responsible for teaching children to be good members of society. Others believe that this is the responsibility of parents.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons and a sensible 'shared responsibility' opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
An important question in education is who should teach children to be good members of society, with good values and behaviour. Some people think this is the job of schools, while others believe it is the responsibility of parents. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who believe it is the school's job argue that schools have trained teachers and reach all children, including those whose parents may not teach them good values at home. Children also spend a huge amount of their time at school, mixing with others, so school is a natural place to learn how to behave, to share, and to respect other people. Schools can also teach these things in a consistent, organised way.
Others argue that it is really the parents' job. They point out that parents are the first and most important teachers in a child's life, and that children learn their deepest values at home, by copying their parents, long before they ever go to school. They also argue that values are a private, family matter, and that it is not right for schools to impose their own ideas of right and wrong.
In my opinion, this should not be a case of one or the other; both have an essential role. Parents must provide the foundation of good values at home, but schools should support and build on this, especially in teaching children how to live alongside others. The two should work together.
In conclusion, although parents have the primary responsibility, I believe that schools must share it, and that children learn best when home and school teach the same values.
275 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that rejects the 'false choice' and argues that parents and schools play different, complementary roles, with good vocabulary ('the moral foundation') and a clear, well-reasoned position.
Who should take responsibility for raising children to be decent, responsible members of society – their schools or their parents? Opinion is divided, and both sides make a strong case. In my view, the question sets up a false choice, and the truth is that the task must be shared.
The argument for the school is a practical one. Schools employ trained professionals and, crucially, reach every child, including those whose home life is troubled or whose parents, for whatever reason, fail to teach them well. Since children spend so many of their waking hours at school, surrounded by others, it is the natural arena in which to learn the everyday skills of living together: cooperation, fairness, respect and self-control.
The argument for the parents is, if anything, deeper. Parents are a child's first and most powerful teachers, and children absorb their fundamental values at home, largely by imitation, long before school begins. Many also feel, with reason, that values are a private and even sensitive matter, and are uneasy about schools imposing a particular moral outlook on other people's children.
My own view is that these two roles are different in kind, and both are essential. Parents lay the moral foundation – the basic sense of right and wrong – in the early years at home. Schools then build upon it, teaching children how to apply those values among dozens of others from different backgrounds, which no family can replicate. Neither can succeed fully without the other.
In conclusion, while parents bear the primary responsibility for their children's values, I believe schools must share the task, and that children thrive when home and school reinforce the same lessons rather than pulling in opposite directions.
285 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that reframes the question as a 'division of labour' rather than a competition, distinguishing the home's role (the moral foundation) from the school's (social application) with a sharp image of the school as 'a miniature society'. Insightful and tightly argued.
Whenever children behave badly in public, two culprits are usually blamed in the same breath: the schools, for not teaching them better, and the parents, for the same failing. The very fact that we instinctively name both is a clue to the answer to this question of who is responsible for turning children into good members of society. It is, I would argue, a responsibility that cannot be assigned to one or the other, because the two are doing fundamentally different jobs.
The case for the school rests on reach and expertise. A school gathers in every child, including those whose homes teach them nothing good, and it does so with trained staff and in the company of others. And it is precisely that company that matters: a school is a miniature society, the first place a child must get along with dozens of near-strangers, and so the natural school for the social virtues – fairness, tolerance, cooperation – that can only really be learned among people.
The case for the parents runs deeper still. Long before a teacher enters the picture, children have absorbed their bedrock values at home, chiefly by copying the adults around them. You cannot outsource this; a warm, honest home produces, on the whole, warm, honest children, and no school can fully undo the damage of a bad one.
The mistake, then, is to treat this as a competition. Parents supply the moral foundation – the conscience, the basic instincts of right and wrong; schools supply the social application – how to live those values out among others. Each is doing what the other cannot.
In conclusion, the responsibility is genuinely shared, not as a vague compromise but as a division of labour: the home builds the person, and the school teaches that person how to live alongside the rest of us.
307 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 presents both sides; Band 8 distinguishes values from the skills of living together.
Examples: Band 7 mentions children copying parents.