Some people say that the best way to learn about another country is to live there, not to read books or watch films about it.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with relevant reasons and a personal example, and it considers the other side. Language is clear but basic, with mechanical linking. Few serious errors, though ideas are fairly simple.
Nowadays, many people want to learn about different countries and cultures. Some people say that living in a country is the best way to learn about it, and that books and films are not as good. I mostly agree with this opinion, and I will explain my reasons in this essay.
Firstly, when you live in a country you can see the real life of the people. You can talk to them, eat the food and go to their festivals. For example, my brother moved to Canada two years ago, and he has learned many things that he did not know before, such as how people behave at work, and how they spend their weekends. You cannot get this from a book, because a book only tells you what the writer thinks. Secondly, you can learn the language very quickly, because you must speak it every day in shops and at your job.
However, books and films also have some advantages. They are cheap, and everybody can read books, but not everybody can go and live in another country because it is very expensive and there are visa problems. Books can also teach you about the history of a country, which you may not learn only by living there. Many people who live abroad do not know about the history.
In conclusion, I think that living in a country is the best way to learn about it, because you get real experience. But books and films are also useful, especially for those people who cannot go there, or before going there.
261 words
Why this is Band 7: Well organised, with a qualified opinion and a good example. It has a useful point about people who live abroad but learn little. Good vocabulary ('first-hand experience', 'opens the door'). Accurate overall.
With international travel and migration becoming more common, many people now have the chance to experience other cultures directly. It is often said that this is far more valuable than anything that can be learned from books or films. On the whole, I agree with this view, although I believe that these other sources still have an important part to play.
The main advantage of living abroad is that it provides first-hand experience of everyday life. A resident has to deal with shops, neighbours and government offices, and therefore gains an understanding of how people really think and behave. For example, a friend of mine who worked in Japan told me that she only began to understand the importance of politeness there after making mistakes at work. No guidebook could have taught her this so clearly. Living in a country also makes it much easier to learn the language, which opens the door to a deeper knowledge of its culture.
On the other hand, books and films have certain advantages. They are available to almost everyone, whereas moving abroad is too expensive or difficult for most people. They can also explain a country's history and politics, which an ordinary resident might never learn about. Indeed, some people live abroad for years within a community of people from their home country, and they learn surprisingly little.
In conclusion, living in a country normally gives the deepest understanding of it, as long as a person makes the effort to take part in local life. However, reading and watching films are a valuable addition to this, and they are the only option for many people.
272 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated argument with vivid examples ('a colleague's perhaps actually means no'). It looks critically at both sides, and it ends with a clear, balanced view. Language is natural and precise ('pale imitation', 'inevitably partial', 'vital companion').
There is a widespread belief that a country can only really be understood from the inside, and that books and films offer at best a pale imitation of direct experience. I largely agree with this, since there are aspects of a culture that can only be absorbed by living in it. However, living somewhere does not guarantee understanding, and the most complete knowledge is likely to come from combining experience with study.
Certainly, there is much that no book can convey. It is one thing to read that a society values indirect communication, and quite another to discover that a colleague's 'perhaps' actually means 'no'. These unwritten rules are learned through daily contact, and frequently through embarrassment. Long-term residence also has the effect of correcting the romantic images created by films. Paris looks rather different when you are queuing at a government office in the rain than it does on a cinema screen.
That said, simply being in a place does not automatically teach you very much about it. Many expatriates spend years within a bubble of colleagues from their own country, without ever learning the language or making a local friend. Moreover, a resident's view is inevitably partial, since it is limited to one city and to one social class. It is often through reading that we learn why a nation behaves as it does, as a knowledge of its history can explain what might otherwise seem strange. Some of the most perceptive writing on India, after all, has come from Indian novelists, whose work can be read by anyone in the world.
Overall, then, living in a country is generally the best way to learn about it, but only for those who make the effort to engage with local life. Books and films should be seen not as a poor substitute, but as a vital companion to experience.
310 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Examples: Band 6 mentions a brother; Band 8 uses a small, vivid situation that makes the point.
Thinking: Band 8 says that living somewhere does not guarantee understanding.