Some people believe that the best way to reduce crime is to give longer prison sentences. Others, however, think that there are better ways of reducing crime.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Discusses both views with a clear opinion. Reasons are relevant, but they aren't developed deeply. Organisation is clear, with basic linking, and there are some errors ('the society', 'commit crime'). A satisfactory answer.
Crime is a big problem in all countries and people have different opinions about how to reduce it. Some people think that criminals should get long prison sentences, but other people think there are better ways. In this essay I will discuss both of these views and also give my own opinion.
On the one hand, long prison sentences have some advantages. If a criminal knows that he will go to prison for many years, he may be afraid and he will not commit the crime. Also, when dangerous criminals are in prison, they cannot harm other people, so the society is safe. For example, people who commit murder should stay in prison for a long time, because they are a danger to everyone.
On the other hand, there are other ways which can be better. Many people commit crime because they are poor or they have no education. If the government gives them good education and jobs, they will not need to steal. Prison is also very expensive for a government, and sometimes young people learn more about crime from other prisoners when they are inside. So when they come out, they may commit more crime.
In my opinion, long prison sentences are necessary for dangerous criminals, but for small crimes they are not useful. It is better to give education and training to those people, and to help them to find a job. In this way they can become good citizens.
In conclusion, both views have some good points, but I think that education and jobs are the better way to reduce crime in the long term.
269 words
Why this is Band 7: Well-developed discussion with a clear position, and with a logical flow from reasons to results. Good range of topic vocabulary ('behind bars', 'prospects', 'underlying causes'). Accurate, but a little predictable.
Crime is a concern in every society, and there is considerable disagreement about how it should be dealt with. While some people think that longer prison sentences are the most effective solution, others argue that there are better alternatives. In my opinion, prison has a role to play, but it is not the best way of reducing crime overall.
Those who support longer sentences make two main points. The first is that the threat of many years in prison will discourage people from breaking the law. The second is that keeping dangerous offenders behind bars protects the public, at least for as long as they are there. This is especially important for violent crimes, where victims and their families expect to see justice done.
However, there are strong arguments against relying on this approach. Prisons are extremely costly to run, and many offenders, particularly young ones, come out with more criminal contacts and fewer prospects than they had before. As a result, a high proportion commit further crimes after being released. Many people therefore believe that money would be better spent on education, on programmes to treat drug addiction and on helping former prisoners to find work, since these deal with the causes of crime rather than its results.
In my view, long sentences should be used for serious, violent offenders, for whom public safety is the main concern. For most other crimes, however, tackling the underlying causes is likely to be much more effective. Therefore, while prison will always be necessary, governments should look at prevention as their first priority.
261 words
Why this is Band 8: Analyses the arguments instead of just listing them, separating protection from deterrence. Uses a careful general reference to research, and it has a strong final idea ('rather than simply to appear tough'). Vocabulary and grammar are sophisticated and natural throughout.
Whenever crime rates rise, there are calls for tougher sentences. The appeal of this approach is easy to understand, as it offers a simple answer to a frightening problem. Nevertheless, while long prison terms undoubtedly have their place, I would argue that they are a surprisingly poor means of reducing crime, and that other measures offer far better value.
The case for lengthy sentences rests on deterrence and protection. A person considering a crime, it is argued, will think twice if they face many years behind bars, and a dangerous offender who is locked up can do no further harm. The second point is hard to dispute, particularly in the case of violent or repeat offenders. The first is more doubtful, however. Many crimes are committed on impulse or under the influence of drugs, by people who do not expect to be caught at all. Research in criminology generally suggests that the likelihood of being caught deters people far more than the severity of the punishment.
There is also a heavy price to pay. Prisons are expensive, and they frequently return people to society less employable, more isolated and better connected to other criminals than when they went in. Measures that address causes, by contrast, may produce lasting benefits. Early support for children in deprived areas, treatment for addiction and training for those leaving prison can prevent crimes from happening in the first place, often at a fraction of the cost. Northern European countries, which rely far less on long sentences, have tended to achieve lower rates of reoffending.
In conclusion, society needs to be protected from those who pose a serious danger, and for them long sentences are justified. But if the aim is to have less crime overall, rather than simply to appear tough, then governments should concentrate on effective policing and on prevention.
306 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Analysis: Band 6 lists views; Band 8 accepts one point and doubts another.
Evidence: Band 8 refers to research in general terms, without inventing numbers.
Position: all three give a mixed view, but Band 8's depends on the real aim of policy.
Language: 'they cannot harm' (6), 'protects the public' (7), 'can do no further harm' (8).
Introduction: Band 8 starts with an insight, not a general statement about crime.
Tips for this task
Separate an argument into parts, and judge each one. This is a mark of a high band.
Refer to evidence carefully: 'Research generally suggests'. Don't invent exact figures.
Avoid absolute words such as 'always' and 'never' for complex social issues.
Use topic words like deterrence, reoffending and rehabilitation accurately.
Keep your own opinion clear throughout, not only in the conclusion.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.