Some people believe that the money spent on space exploration would be better spent on solving problems here on Earth.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position, with reasons on both sides, and a relevant example. Ideas are fairly common, and the language is simple in places, but it's clear and mostly accurate. A clear structure.
Every year, some countries spend a very large amount of money on sending rockets and satellites into space. Some people think that this is a waste, and that it should be used for problems on Earth, like poverty and diseases. I partly agree with this view, but I also think that space research has benefits.
On the one hand, there are many serious problems in the world today. Millions of people do not have enough food or clean water, and many children cannot go to school. Climate change is also a very big problem. If governments used the money from space programmes for these things, they could save many lives. It seems wrong to spend money to go to Mars while people are dying of hunger on Earth. For example, in India there are still many poor people in villages, though the country has sent rockets to the moon.
On the other hand, space exploration has given us many useful things. Satellites help us to predict the weather, and they give warnings about storms, which can save lives. We also use them for phones, television and GPS. In addition, the research has led to new technology, which is used in medicine and in other areas. Space programmes also make young people interested in science, and they create many jobs.
In my opinion, governments should continue with space research, but they should make sure that the most important problems are dealt with first. The amount of money spent on space is also small compared with other spending, like the military.
In conclusion, although problems on Earth are very important, I believe that we should not stop exploring space, as it also helps people on Earth.
284 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position with two well-developed reasons, and good examples. Vocabulary is good ('expensive luxury', 'early warnings'). It deals fairly with the opposing view. Few errors.
With so many urgent problems facing the world, it is understandable that some people regard space exploration as an expensive luxury. While I accept that these problems must be a priority, I do not agree that money spent on space would necessarily be better used elsewhere, for two main reasons.
Those who oppose space programmes argue that it is morally wrong to spend billions on rockets while people are going hungry. There is clearly some force in this argument. Governments have limited budgets, and the same money could be used to build hospitals and schools, or to provide clean water. It is also difficult to explain to a poor family why a mission to Mars should be more urgent than their own needs.
However, this view overlooks the fact that much of what we do in space directly benefits life on Earth. Satellites are essential for weather forecasting, and they provide early warnings of cyclones which have saved thousands of lives in countries such as India and Bangladesh. They are also vital to monitoring climate change, as well as for communications and navigation. Moreover, the research has often produced useful technologies that were not expected at the start, including improvements in medical imaging and water purification.
The second reason is that the amounts involved are smaller than many people think. Space budgets represent a tiny proportion of government spending, far less than what is spent on defence, for example. Therefore, it is unrealistic to imagine that cancelling them would solve the problem of poverty, which is often due to politics and poor distribution, not a lack of money.
In conclusion, although problems on Earth should come first, space exploration is a worthwhile investment that helps us to solve them.
289 words
Why this is Band 8: Identifies the assumptions behind the question and challenges them systematically. A precise and confident style ('indefensible', 'does not stand up to close examination'). The final sentence ends the argument with force.
To spend billions of dollars on a mission to Mars while a large part of humanity lacks clean water may seem indefensible, and it is not hard to see why many people feel that the money would be better spent at home. However, this argument, attractive as it is, rests on two assumptions which do not stand up to close examination: that space spending is large, and that its benefits are confined to space.
The moral appeal of the argument should not be dismissed. Governments must choose how to spend limited funds, and every pound has an alternative use. When India sent a probe to the moon, there were those who pointed out, quite reasonably, that millions of its citizens were still without proper sanitation. No one should feel entirely comfortable with such contrasts, and those who run space programmes have a duty to justify them.
Yet the sums involved are far more modest than the headlines suggest. Even NASA, by some way the world's largest space agency, receives less than half of one per cent of the American federal budget, a small fraction of what is spent on the military. Cancelling every space programme in the world would release relatively little, and there is no guarantee at all that this money would go to the poor. Poverty today is seldom simply a question of insufficient funds, but rather of governance, conflict and unequal distribution.
More importantly, it is simply not the case that space exploration takes place at the expense of Earth. Satellites have changed how we respond to natural disasters, and much of what we know about the changing climate comes from observations made from orbit. To regard this as a distraction from the world's problems is to misunderstand how many of them are studied in the first place.
I would therefore reject the choice that this question implies. A wealthy society ought to be able to care for its poorest members, and also look beyond its own horizons. If it fails in the first of these, then the reason is unlikely to be found on the launch pad.
351 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Structure: Band 8 identifies two assumptions and deals with each.
Evidence: Band 8 gives a specific size for NASA's budget.
Opposing view: Band 8 treats it with respect before rejecting it.
Vocabulary: 'a waste' (6), 'an expensive luxury' (7), 'indefensible' (8).
Conclusion: Band 8 rejects the choice that the question offers.
Tips for this task
Ask yourself what the question assumes, and whether that is true.
Before you disagree with someone, show that you understand their point.
Use figures only if you are confident that they are correct.
Examples from your own country are useful, and they show that you've thought about it.
Avoid clichés such as 'Nowadays, there is a debate'.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.