Artificial intelligence is now doing many tasks that were previously done by humans, such as writing, translation and customer service.
Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position with both sides, and two good examples. The arguments are relevant, although they are somewhat general. Vocabulary is adequate, and there are few serious errors.
Nowadays, artificial intelligence is used in many jobs. It can write letters, translate languages and answer the questions of customers. In my opinion, this has many advantages, but I think that the disadvantages are also serious, and they are a little greater.
There are clear advantages of using AI. Firstly, it is very fast and cheap. A company can answer thousands of customers at the same time, and it does not need to pay a salary. Secondly, it helps ordinary people. For example, my uncle does not know English very well, but he can now use a translation app to understand documents from his bank. It also works for twenty-four hours, so people can get help at night.
However, there are important disadvantages. The biggest problem is that many people will lose their jobs. Call centres, for example, give employment to many young people in India, and if these jobs disappear, it will be very difficult for them to find new work. Another problem is that AI sometimes makes mistakes, and people may believe these mistakes because the answer looks correct. Finally, if students use AI to write everything, they will not learn how to think and write by themselves. This could be a serious problem for the next generation.
In conclusion, AI is very useful and we cannot stop it, but I think that the disadvantages outweigh the advantages at present, mainly because of the loss of jobs. Governments should train people for new types of work, and schools should teach students to use AI carefully.
257 words
Why this is Band 7: Well-organised with a clear position, and it uses a helpful historical comparison. Good range ('frees up', 'round-the-clock', 'underestimated'), and it answers the counter-arguments.
Artificial intelligence is rapidly taking over work that has traditionally been done by people, from writing reports to answering customer enquiries. While the risks are real, I believe that the benefits of this development will outweigh its drawbacks, as long as it is properly managed.
The most obvious advantage is in terms of productivity. Tasks that would once have taken hours can now be finished in minutes, and this frees up workers to concentrate on more complex and interesting responsibilities. It also makes services far more accessible. A farmer who speaks only Punjabi, for instance, can now read an official notice in English by using a translation tool, and a small business can offer round-the-clock support, which it could never have afforded before.
The main concern, of course, is employment. Translators, call centre staff and junior writers are already seeing a reduction in demand for their work, and many of them may struggle to retrain. There are also worries about reliability, since these systems can produce errors with complete confidence. Such problems should not be underestimated. However, earlier technologies, such as the computer, also destroyed many jobs while creating new ones, and there is no reason to believe that this time will be entirely different. Errors can also be reduced if humans check the results.
In conclusion, although this development will be painful for certain workers, its overall effect is likely to be positive. Governments must invest in retraining, and employers should use AI as a support for their staff, and not simply as a replacement for them.
258 words
Why this is Band 8: A thoughtful essay with original points (how junior work trains future experts). Language is flexible and precise ('unevenly distributed', 'by no means guaranteed'), and it ends strongly.
Machines that can draft a contract or hold a conversation would have seemed like science fiction not long ago, yet they are already changing the way that many people work. I believe that the benefits of this change are likely to exceed its costs, but that this outcome is by no means guaranteed, as it depends on who receives those benefits.
The case in favour is strong. By taking over routine tasks, AI allows people to do more of what requires judgement, and it brings expert help within reach of those who could never have paid for it. A villager who has received a confusing letter from a government office can now have it translated and explained in seconds, for free. The value of this to people who have always been shut out by language or by lack of education is easy to overlook, particularly for those of us who have never needed such help.
The costs, however, are unevenly distributed. It is true that previous waves of automation created more jobs than they destroyed, but those new jobs did not always go to the same people, or to the same places. A woman of fifty who has spent her career in a call centre is unlikely to be comforted by the thought that new industries will appear in time. There is a more subtle danger as well. Junior work has always been the way in which people learned a profession, and if it disappears, it is not clear how anyone is to become a senior lawyer or editor.
Overall, then, I consider the development to be positive, on the condition that some of the gains are used to support those who lose out. Technology does not decide who benefits from it. People do.
294 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 says that disadvantages win, and Bands 7 and 8 say that advantages win. All are acceptable if they're well argued.
Example: 'my uncle' (6), 'a farmer' (7), 'a villager' used to make a wider point (8).
History: Band 7 says that new jobs appear, and Band 8 adds that they may not go to the same people.
New idea: only Band 8 raises the problem of how young people will learn a profession.
Vocabulary: 'lose their jobs' (6), 'a reduction in demand' (7), 'those who lose out' (8).
Tips for this task
With 'outweigh', you must compare and decide. Don't just list both sides.
State your view early, and make sure that the conclusion agrees with it.
Name the tasks in the question. Don't drift into general talk about robots.
Think about who benefits and who loses.
Don't make predictions as if they were facts. Use 'is likely to' or 'may well'.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.