Some people think that the money governments spend on space exploration should be used to solve problems here on Earth.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion with relevant points on both sides and sensible examples. Paragraphing is clear, but linking is basic. Ideas aren't fully developed, and there are small errors ('the money of space programmes', 'In my country also').
Governments spend a lot of money on sending rockets and satellites into space. Some people believe that this money should be used to solve the problems on the Earth, like poverty and health. I partly agree with this opinion, and I will explain my view in this essay.
On the one hand, there are many serious problems in the world today. Many people have no food or clean water, and they cannot go to a good hospital. In my country also, many children do not get a good education because the schools have no facilities. If governments used the money of space programmes for these things, then millions of people could have a better life. So I can understand why people think that space is not very important at this time.
On the other hand, space exploration is also useful for people on the Earth. Today we use satellites for many things, such as weather forecasts, mobile phones and maps. Farmers can know about the rain, and people can be warned before big storms. Also, space research has given us many new inventions which are used in our daily life. It is also a good thing for young people, because it can make them interested in science.
In my opinion, governments should spend money on both. They should spend most of their money on important problems such as health and education, but they should not stop the space programmes completely, because these give us useful things for the future.
In conclusion, I partly agree that money should be used for problems on the Earth. However, space exploration is also useful, so a balance is needed.
275 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position with well-developed reasons. Good use of examples, and the point about the small scale of spending is valuable. Language is accurate and appropriate, though less sophisticated than Band 8.
With so many people around the world lacking basic necessities, it is often argued that money spent on space exploration would be better used to solve problems on Earth. Although I have some sympathy with this view, I do not fully agree with it, as space research also brings important practical benefits.
There is certainly a strong moral argument for putting people's immediate needs first. Millions of people still live without enough food, clean water or medical care, and the cost of a single space mission could build a large number of schools or hospitals. In poorer countries particularly, it may seem hard to justify spending huge sums on exploring other planets when many citizens are unable to meet their daily needs.
However, this argument overlooks the fact that space programmes often help to solve these same problems. Satellites provide the information that allows us to forecast the weather, to warn people of approaching storms and to monitor climate change. They are also essential for modern communications and navigation. Moreover, technologies first developed for space have been used in areas such as medical equipment and water purification. It should also be remembered that spending on space is actually very small in comparison with most government budgets, so stopping it would not make a great difference.
In conclusion, although the problems of poverty and disease must be a priority, I do not believe that this means giving up on space exploration. Governments should provide money for both, as the knowledge gained from space can help to improve life on Earth.
259 words
Why this is Band 8: Identifies and challenges the assumptions behind the statement, giving the essay a strong structure. Specific support (NASA's share of the budget), and a careful position that distinguishes between different projects. Language is rich and controlled.
At a time when millions of people lack clean water and basic healthcare, it can seem almost obscene to spend billions of dollars on sending machines to Mars. The argument that this money should be redirected to problems on Earth therefore has an immediate appeal. Nevertheless, I would argue that it rests on two mistaken assumptions: that the money would otherwise be spent on those problems, and that space research does nothing to help solve them.
The first assumption overstates the scale of what is at stake. Even in the United States, the world's largest spender, NASA receives less than half of one per cent of the federal budget. Cancelling it entirely would hardly make an impact on poverty, and there is no guarantee that the savings would go to the poor, rather than to defence or tax cuts. If we are looking for money to tackle hunger, there are many far larger items of spending which deserve to be questioned first.
The second assumption ignores the extent to which life on Earth now depends on space. It is satellites that allow us to track hurricanes and warn coastal communities in time, to measure the melting of the ice sheets and to help farmers plan their crops. Much of what we know about climate change, arguably the greatest problem we face, has been obtained from orbit. Similarly, the search for knowledge cannot always be justified in advance, as many valuable technologies have come from research with no obvious practical purpose.
This is not to say that every project deserves support. Sending humans to Mars, or tourism for billionaires, may well be hard to justify at present. However, a modest and well-chosen programme of research seems to me a sound investment. Rather than treating it as a choice between the Earth and space, we should recognise that one can help the other.
311 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Approach: Band 6 presents both sides; Band 8 attacks the logic of the statement.
Evidence: Band 8 uses a real figure that it can support; Band 6 gives only general examples.
Balance: Band 8 still admits that some projects can't be justified.