Some people believe that university education should be free for all students, and paid for by the government.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear position with reasons on both sides, and a practical solution. Organisation is clear, but ideas are not fully developed. Some minor errors ('if university was free', 'leave their study'), and everyday vocabulary.
Education is very important for each person and also for the country. Some people think that the government should pay for all students to go to university. I partly agree with this opinion, because free education has benefits, but I do not think it should be free for everybody.
There are some good reasons for making university free. Firstly, many clever students come from poor families, and they cannot pay high fees. In my country, I know that some students leave their study after school because their parents have no money. If university was free, these students could become doctors or engineers. Secondly, the whole country gets benefits when people are well educated, because they get better jobs and pay more tax.
However, there are also some problems. University education is very expensive, and if the government pays for all students, it must take money from other things, like hospitals or primary schools. Also, rich families can easily pay the fees, so it is not fair that the government should pay for their children. In addition, some students may not study seriously if they do not pay anything, and they may spend many years at the university.
In my opinion, the best idea is that the government should pay for students who are from poor families or who get very good marks. Other students should pay some of the fees. They can also take a loan from a bank, and pay it back when they get a job.
In conclusion, I think that university should be free for students who need help, but not for all students.
267 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position, with well-developed arguments on both sides and a relevant example. Good vocabulary ('put off by', 'grants', 'overcrowded'). The solution is well linked to the argument, with few errors.
There has been much debate about whether university education should be funded entirely by the government. Although there are strong arguments in favour of free higher education, I only partly agree with this idea, as I believe that those who are able to pay should contribute.
The main argument for free education is that it gives everyone the same opportunity, regardless of their family background. In many countries, talented young people from low-income families are put off by high fees, and society loses out as a result. Moreover, a country benefits from having an educated workforce, as graduates tend to earn more and pay more tax. Countries such as Germany have abolished tuition fees for this reason, and they appear to have a strong economy.
However, free education for everyone also has serious drawbacks. Since universities are expensive to run, governments would have to raise taxes or to cut spending elsewhere, and this could mean less money for primary schools, which arguably help more people. It also seems unfair for taxpayers who never went to university to pay for the education of those who will later earn high salaries. In addition, without fees, universities may become overcrowded, with less money available for each student.
A better solution, in my opinion, would be a system of grants for students from poor families, combined with loans for others that need only be repaid once they are earning a good salary. This would protect access without placing a heavy burden on the public.
In conclusion, while nobody should be denied a place because of a lack of money, I do not believe that it should be free for all.
276 words
Why this is Band 8: Sophisticated argument, which separates the principle from the policy. It introduces the point about who actually benefits, and it links this to early education. Precise, natural language ('disproportionately', 'held up as an example'), and a strong final sentence.
The notion that higher education should be free to all is an attractive one, particularly in societies where a degree is the main route to a secure career. Yet while I strongly support the principle behind it, namely that talent rather than wealth should determine who goes to university, I would argue that universal free tuition is an inefficient and even a rather unfair way of achieving this.
Advocates are right about a number of things. The cost of tuition can deter bright students from poorer homes, particularly where families have no experience of university, and are understandably afraid of debt. Countries also gain from a highly skilled workforce, and it can be argued that graduates repay society through higher taxes. Germany, which abolished tuition fees in the last decade, is frequently held up as an example of how this can work.
The difficulty is that the benefits of free tuition do not fall evenly. In most countries, students at university are disproportionately from better-off families, who could afford to pay, and so universal funding effectively transfers money from the general taxpayer, including many on low wages, to those who are likely to be among the higher earners in the future. Moreover, public money is limited. Every rupee spent on subsidising a wealthy student is one that cannot go to primary schools, where the barriers to later success first emerge. Indeed, by the time most poor children reach eighteen, the damage has already been done.
I would therefore favour a targeted approach: generous grants for those from low-income backgrounds, together with income-linked loans for others, which are repaid only if and when a graduate earns above a certain level. Combined with greater investment in early education, this is much more likely to widen access than simply abolishing fees. Fairness, in short, is not the same as making something free for everyone.
311 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 8 agrees with the principle, while questioning the policy.
Key idea: Band 8 asks who really benefits from free tuition.
Solution: Band 6 'take a loan'; Band 8 'income-linked loans'.