From time to time it is proposed that all young people should be made to spend a year in some form of national service, whether military or civilian. The idea has a certain appeal, and its supporters paint it as a cure for many of society's ills. I do not share their enthusiasm. While I can see some value in the scheme, I believe that forcing young people to take part is both wrong in principle and unlikely to achieve what is claimed for it.
Supporters argue that a year of service would teach discipline, responsibility and respect, and would mix together young people from different backgrounds who would otherwise never meet. I will grant that the second of these is a genuine benefit. Bringing together the rich and the poor, the city-dweller and the country-dweller, in a common task could indeed break down barriers, and that is the part of the case I find most attractive.
But my central objection is to the word 'compulsory'. To compel a young adult to give up a year of their life, against their will, for a purpose chosen by the state, is a serious thing, and in my view it needs far stronger justification than the vague benefits usually offered. We do not, as a rule, force adults to labour where the government directs, and I see no good reason to make an exception of the young.
I also doubt that compulsion would deliver the benefits promised. Discipline and public spirit imposed by force are not the same as the real thing, freely chosen, and a year of resented, grudging service may breed cynicism rather than virtue. People made to do good against their will often learn chiefly to resent it, and I suspect many conscripts would emerge from the experience more sullen than improved.
There is, besides, the sheer cost and disruption to consider. Removing an entire generation from work and study for a year, and housing, training and supervising them, would be enormously expensive, and that money and effort might do far more good spent directly on the problems the scheme is meant to solve. A policy that is hugely costly and of doubtful benefit is a poor bargain however noble it sounds.
What, then, would I do instead? I would keep the good idea and drop the compulsion. A well-funded voluntary programme, which made it easy and attractive for young people to spend time serving their communities, could capture most of the benefits without the injustice. Offered rather than imposed, service would draw those who wanted to be there, and their willing effort would be worth more than any amount of forced labour.
So I end where I began: unpersuaded. The goals behind national service - a more united, public-spirited society - are good ones, and I share them. But compulsion is the wrong means to reach them, costly, coercive and probably counter-productive. Let us encourage the young to serve, by all means, and reward them when they do; but let us not force them, for in that force the whole idea is spoiled.
Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer? Write YES, NO or NOT GIVEN.
1. The writer supports making national service compulsory.
2. The writer accepts that mixing young people from different backgrounds is a genuine benefit.
3. The writer's main objection is to the element of compulsion.
4. The writer believes forced service would successfully instil discipline.
5. The writer thinks the scheme would be very expensive.
6. The writer prefers a voluntary programme to a compulsory one.
7. The writer thinks military service is more valuable than civilian service.
8. The writer shares the goal of a more united, public-spirited society.
9. The writer believes other countries' national service schemes have failed.
10. The writer thinks willing effort is worth more than forced labour.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.
Jitender SinghFounder & Managing Director
Vikram SinghHead – Quality & Operations
SanjayHead – Tourist Visa Operations
TejaswaniHead – Counselling Team
MahimaHead – Visa Filing & Processing
Pratigya DuttaHead – Student Visa ProcessingFree, no-pressure guidance from a real counsellor who handles your case end to end — from documents to decision.