Some people believe that zoos are cruel and should be closed down. Others think that they are useful for protecting wild animals and for educating people.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed, with clear examples, and a clear opinion. The language is simple but accurate, and it's well structured.
Zoos have been popular places to visit for many years. However, some people now believe that they are cruel and that they should be closed, while others think that they have an important role. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, some people say that it is wrong to keep animals in cages. Wild animals need a lot of space, and in a zoo they cannot run or hunt as they do in nature. For example, a lion or an elephant travels a long way every day in the wild, but in a zoo it only has a small area. Some animals become unhappy, and they walk up and down all day. In addition, people can now watch very good films about wild animals, so they do not need to go to a zoo to learn about them.
On the other hand, zoos do many useful things. They protect animals which are in danger of disappearing, and some of these animals have been returned to the wild. They also help scientists to study animals and to learn how to care for them. Moreover, zoos are a good place for children to learn. When a child sees a real elephant, it can make them care about nature much more than a film can.
In my opinion, zoos should not be closed, but they must change. They should give the animals much more space, and they should keep only those animals that can live well there. Governments should also check them regularly.
In conclusion, although some zoos are cruel, good zoos can help animals and teach people, so I believe that they should stay open.
282 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear, balanced essay with relevant examples. Good vocabulary ('abnormal behaviour', 'emotional impact'). The conclusion follows clearly from the discussion.
For generations, a trip to the zoo has been a favourite family outing, but in recent years, the idea of keeping wild animals in captivity has become increasingly controversial. While I understand the concerns of those who oppose zoos, I believe that well-run ones still have a valuable part to play.
Those who want to close zoos argue that captivity is cruel in itself. Large animals such as elephants and polar bears naturally travel great distances, and no enclosure can come close to providing that. As a result, some of them develop abnormal behaviour, such as repeatedly walking along the same path. Critics also point out that, thanks to wildlife documentaries, people can now see animals behaving naturally without causing them any harm.
However, there are strong arguments on the other side. Many modern zoos are heavily involved in conservation, and they have played a key part in saving species which were close to extinction, such as the Arabian oryx. They also fund research and support projects in the wild. In addition, I would argue that seeing a living animal has an emotional impact on children that a screen cannot match, and this may encourage them to care about the natural world when they become adults.
In my view, the answer lies not in closing all zoos, but in raising standards. Zoos which cannot provide suitable conditions for large animals should stop keeping them, and they should focus on species that can do well in captivity.
In conclusion, although the concerns about animal welfare are justified, a total ban would mean losing an important tool for conservation and education.
269 words
Why this is Band 8: A powerful personal opening that contains the whole argument. It has precise examples and a thoughtful position ('must earn the right to exist'), and its style is very natural.
The first time that I saw a tiger, I was six, and I was standing outside its cage in a zoo in Chandigarh. I remember being struck by how huge it was. I also remember that it was walking up and down the same few metres, turning at exactly the same spot each time. It took me about thirty years to understand what I had been looking at. That memory contains both sides of this debate.
The case against zoos is a serious one. Many animals simply cannot have anything like a natural life within an enclosure. Elephants walk for many kilometres a day, and the repetitive movements that I saw in that tiger are now recognised as a sign of distress. It is hardly an answer to say that animals born in zoos do not know any better. Nor is the educational argument as strong as zoos claim, as it is not clear that a visitor learns much by looking at a bored animal for ninety seconds on the way to the ice-cream stand.
And yet I find that I cannot agree with closing them all. Without captive breeding, the Arabian oryx and the California condor would very probably no longer exist, and as wild habitats shrink, the list of such animals is likely to grow. Good zoos also pay for a great deal of conservation work in the wild, using the money that those ice-cream buyers bring in. As for that six-year-old, nothing that I have seen on a screen has ever made me feel what I felt in front of that tiger, and it did at least make me care.
What I would argue for, therefore, is that zoos must earn the right to exist. An institution that keeps a species for conservation, and that gives it room to live properly, can be justified. One that keeps a tiger in a small cage for the sake of ticket sales cannot be, and it should be closed.
329 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 begins with a personal memory.
Examples: Bands 7 and 8 name particular species.
Argument: Band 8 questions the educational claim.
Vocabulary: 'unhappy' (6), 'abnormal behaviour' (7), 'a sign of distress' (8).
Position: Band 8 states a clear test for zoos.
Tips for this task
Give each view its own paragraph.
Think about conservation, education and welfare.
Use a real species as an example, if you know one.
Don't simply say 'some zoos are good and some are bad'.
Make your own opinion clear at the end.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.