Some people believe that zoos are cruel and should be closed down, while others think that zoos are useful and should be kept.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons and a sensible 'it depends on the zoo' opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
Zoos, where wild animals are kept for people to see, are popular places, but they are also the subject of much debate. Some people believe that zoos are cruel and should be closed down, while others think they are useful and should be kept. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Those who want to close zoos argue that it is cruel to keep wild animals in cages, far from their natural homes. They say that animals which are used to roaming free over huge distances suffer greatly when kept in a small space, and that no cage, however good, can replace the wild. They believe it is wrong to keep animals prisoner simply for our entertainment.
On the other hand, many people believe zoos do important work. Good modern zoos help to protect animals that are in danger of dying out in the wild, by breeding them safely. They also teach millions of people, especially children, about animals and about the importance of protecting them, which may make people care more about nature. And zoos raise money for conservation.
In my opinion, it depends on the zoo. I believe that bad zoos, which keep animals in poor conditions just for profit, should certainly be closed. But good zoos, which look after their animals well and do real conservation and education work, are valuable and should be kept and supported.
In conclusion, although some zoos are cruel and should close, I believe that good, modern zoos do important work and should be kept.
258 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that gives both views their due and argues convincingly that the question is really about good versus bad zoos. Good vocabulary ('a pale imitation of the wild') and a clear, qualified position.
Zoos are among the most popular of family days out, yet they raise an uncomfortable question: is it right to keep wild animals confined for our benefit? Some say zoos are simply cruel and should be abolished; others defend them as valuable. In my view, the honest answer depends almost entirely on the kind of zoo we are talking about.
The case against zoos is a serious one. There is something troubling about keeping a wild creature, built to roam over great distances, confined far from its natural habitat in a space that can only ever be a pale imitation of the wild. Critics argue, with real force, that many animals suffer in captivity, showing signs of boredom and distress, and that to keep them so for our entertainment is hard to justify.
Yet the defenders of zoos point to genuine benefits. The best modern zoos are no longer mere menageries but centres of conservation, breeding endangered species that might otherwise vanish, and in some cases returning them to the wild. They also educate millions, especially children, giving them a real connection to animals that a screen cannot, which may create the very people who will fight to protect nature.
My own view is that the debate should not be about zoos in general but about which zoos. A bad zoo, keeping animals in cramped, barren cages purely for profit, deserves to be closed. A good zoo, which gives its animals spacious, well-designed homes and does genuine conservation and education, earns its place.
In conclusion, while cruel zoos should certainly be shut down, I believe that good, modern zoos do important work and deserve to be supported, not abolished.
279 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated essay that opens with the genuine unease of the zoo, reframes the question as 'what kind of zoo?', and weighs the animal's suffering against the survival of species and the education of the young. Humane, balanced and persuasive.
There is a real unease at the heart of the zoo – the sight of a great animal, made for wide plains or deep forest, pacing a space a fraction of the size – and that unease is the honest starting point for this question. Should zoos be closed as cruel, or kept as useful? My own answer is that the question itself is slightly wrong, because everything depends on which zoo we mean.
The critics are not to be dismissed. To confine a creature built for freedom, far from its natural home, in an enclosure that can never truly match the wild, is a genuine moral cost, and the signs of boredom and distress seen in badly kept animals are real. If the only purpose served were our idle entertainment, I think the critics would simply be right.
But the best modern zoos have changed almost beyond recognition, and they offer something weighty on the other side of the scale. They breed animals whose species are being wiped out in the wild, sometimes providing the last refuge of a creature on the edge of extinction; and, perhaps as importantly, they bring millions of people, especially children, face to face with living animals, forging a connection and a care that no documentary quite achieves. Those children may become the adults who save the wild itself.
So I would not ask 'should zoos exist?' but 'what kind of zoo is this?'. The cramped, profit-driven menagerie, keeping miserable animals for gawping crowds, should be closed without hesitation. The spacious, thoughtful, conservation-minded zoo, which treats the animal's welfare as seriously as the visitor's enjoyment, earns its keep and more.
In conclusion, cruelty should close a zoo, but good zoos do real and valuable work, and the task is not to abolish zoos but to insist that every one of them is worthy of the animals it holds.
314 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 lists points; Band 8 weighs the animal's suffering against the species' survival.
Examples: both mention breeding and education; Band 7 develops them.
Vocabulary: 'kept in cages' (6), 'confined far from their natural habitat' (7).
Depth: Band 7 stresses the difference between good and bad zoos.
Conclusion: both 'it depends'; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Discuss both the 'cruel' view and the 'useful' view.
Give reasons and examples for each.
Consider the difference between good and bad zoos.
Make your own opinion clear.
Use a separate paragraph for each view.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.