Some people think that all children should learn a foreign language from the first year of primary school.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: A clear opinion, relevant reasons, a personal example and a counter-argument. The language is clear but fairly simple, with a few errors ('because of several reasons', 'shy to make mistakes'). Linking is mechanical.
In today's world, many people can speak more than one language. Some people believe that children should start to learn a foreign language when they start primary school. I agree with this idea because of several reasons.
Firstly, young children can learn languages very easily. Their brain is very active at this age and they are not shy to make mistakes. For example, my nephew is only six years old and he already speaks some English, because he learns it in school and he watches cartoons in English. Adults find it more difficult, and they feel shy to speak. So it is better to start as early as possible.
Secondly, knowing a foreign language will help children in their future. Many companies want workers who can speak other languages, and it can help them to get a good job or study in another country. It also helps them to understand other cultures and people, which is very important in this modern world.
However, some people say that small children should learn their own language first, and that a foreign language can confuse them. There is some truth in this, because children also have many other subjects to learn. But I think if the lessons are short and fun, with songs and games, they will not feel any pressure.
In conclusion, I strongly agree that children should learn a foreign language from the first year of primary school. It is easier for them at this age, and it will help them later in their life.
254 words
Why this is Band 7: A clear position with a condition. Ideas are developed and supported, and the counter-argument is dealt with. Vocabulary suits the topic ('pronunciation', 'mother tongue'). It has few errors, but it's less thoughtful than Band 8.
With the world becoming increasingly connected, the ability to speak more than one language is a valuable skill. For this reason, some people argue that foreign languages should be taught from the very first year of primary school. I largely agree with this view, provided that the lessons are suitable for young children.
The main argument for an early start is that young children learn languages more naturally than older people. They are good at copying sounds, so they tend to develop better pronunciation, and they are usually less worried about making mistakes. In my own country, many children who begin English at the age of five are able to speak it confidently by the time they reach secondary school. An early start also means that they have many more years in which to practise.
In addition, learning another language has wider benefits. It can make children more aware of other cultures and more open towards people from different backgrounds. It is also a practical advantage later in life, as many employers and universities look for people with language skills.
On the other hand, some people are concerned that young children should first master their mother tongue, and that the school day is already full. These are reasonable concerns, but they can be dealt with by keeping lessons short and based on songs and games, rather than on grammar and tests.
In conclusion, I believe that children should begin a foreign language in their first year of school, as long as this is done in an enjoyable way that does not put them under pressure.
265 words
Why this is Band 8: A subtle position: the method matters more than the age. Examples are vivid (the six-year-old and the sixteen-year-old), the counter-argument is taken seriously, and language is flexible and precise ('self-consciousness', 'holds back', 'literacy must surely come first').
As international travel and communication have become part of everyday life, knowing a second language is no longer a luxury. Many therefore argue that children should begin learning one as soon as they start school. While I broadly support this view, I would argue that the benefits depend less on the age at which children start than on the way in which they are taught.
There are strong reasons for starting early. Young children are remarkably good at imitating unfamiliar sounds, and they have not yet developed the self-consciousness that holds back so many teenage and adult learners. A six-year-old will happily sing in a language they barely understand, while a sixteen-year-old may be too embarrassed to answer a simple question. Starting early also gives pupils more years of contact with the language, which matters a great deal, since fluency takes time to build. Beyond these practical gains, there is a less obvious one: discovering that other people express ideas differently can help a child to become more curious and more tolerant.
That said, an early start alone guarantees very little. One or two short lessons a week, delivered by teachers with limited language skills, may achieve almost nothing, and children may even learn to dislike the subject before they reach secondary school. There is also a question of priorities in those schools where many pupils are still struggling to read in their first language. In such cases, literacy must surely come first.
Overall, then, I agree that foreign languages should be introduced in the first year, but only where schools have well-trained teachers and enough time to make the lessons worthwhile. An early start is a real advantage, but only when it is done properly.
286 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Position: Band 6 agrees; Band 7 agrees with a condition; Band 8 qualifies it in a thoughtful way.
Support: Band 6 tells a family story; Band 8 uses a general comparison that makes the point.
Counter-argument: Band 8 uses it to shape its final position.
Linking: Band 8 uses 'That said', 'Beyond these practical gains', 'In such cases'.