Some people believe that children should begin formal schooling at a very young age, such as five. Others think that children should start school later, at the age of seven.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are covered and a clear opinion is given, with a relevant example (Finland). The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
People have different opinions about the right age for children to start school. Some think that five is best, while others believe that seven is better. In this essay, I will look at both views and give my opinion.
On the one hand, many people think that children should start early, at five. One reason is that young children learn very quickly, so it is a waste of time if they stay at home. If they start reading and writing early, they will be ahead when they are older. Another reason is that school helps children to make friends and to learn how to behave with other people. It is also useful for parents, because they can go back to work.
On the other hand, some people believe that seven is a better age. At five, children are still very young, and they may not be ready to sit still and study for a long time. These people think that young children should learn through play, not through formal lessons. In some countries, such as Finland, children start school at seven, and their results are very good.
In my opinion, both sides have good points, but I think that starting a bit later is better. Before seven, children can go to a kindergarten, where they learn through games and play. This is good for them, and they will still learn to read and write quickly once they start proper school.
In conclusion, although there are advantages to starting at five, I believe that it is better for children to begin formal schooling a little later.
265 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced, well-structured discussion, with a clear position and good vocabulary ('rapid development', 'a dislike of learning').
There is considerable debate about the age at which children should begin formal education, with some favouring an early start at around five, and others preferring to wait until seven. Both positions have merit, but on balance I believe that a later start is better.
Those who support starting at five point to the speed at which young children learn. The early years are a period of rapid development, and supporters argue that it would be wasteful not to make use of this for reading, writing and numbers. An early start also allows children to develop social skills, and, from a practical point of view, it enables parents to return to work, which benefits the whole family and the economy.
Those who favour a later start, however, question whether formal lessons suit such young children at all. At five, many children struggle to concentrate and to sit still, and being pushed too soon may create anxiety and a dislike of learning. Advocates of this view argue that what young children need is play, through which they naturally develop language and curiosity. The example of countries such as Finland, where formal schooling begins at seven yet results are excellent, is often cited.
In my view, the second argument is the stronger. A later start does not mean that children learn nothing beforehand; rather, they can attend a kindergarten where learning happens through play. This builds a love of learning, on which formal study can later be built. Children who begin at seven typically catch up very quickly.
In conclusion, while an early start has some benefits, I believe that most children are better served by beginning formal schooling a little later.
280 words
Why this is Band 8: A vivid personal opening and a subtle argument that reframes the question. Very natural style, with a thoughtful condition attached to the writer's view.
I learned to read at four, taught by an impatient grandmother, and I have been grateful for it ever since. My younger cousin, by contrast, could barely recognise her own name at six, and now, at twenty, reads far more than I do. Whenever I am tempted to think that there must be one correct age to start school, I remember the two of us, and I am forced to admit that the question is less simple than it looks.
The argument for an early start, at five, rests on a genuine truth: young children are astonishing learners, soaking up language and skills at a rate no adult can match. It seems only sensible to harness this, and there is an undeniable practical benefit to parents, who can return to work. Set against this is the case for waiting until seven. Its supporters argue, rightly, that 'learning' and 'sitting at a desk' are not the same thing, and that forcing formal lessons on a restless five-year-old may do real harm, teaching them chiefly that school is a place of frustration. The success of countries like Finland, which starts late and plays early, is hard to dismiss.
My own view is that the debate is slightly misframed. The real question is not when children start learning, which they do from birth, but when we should replace play with formal instruction. On that, I side with the later camp, but with a condition. A delayed start is only beneficial if the earlier years are spent in rich, play-based settings; a child left in front of a screen until seven is not better off. The danger of the 'start at five' approach is not the age itself, but the temptation to make five-year-olds behave like ten-year-olds.
So I would start formal schooling later, while insisting that the years before it are anything but idle. My grandmother, I think, would have approved, provided the reading was disguised as a game.
326 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Opening: Band 8 contrasts the writer and a cousin.
Framing: Band 8 argues that the real question is when to replace play with formal lessons.
Example: all use Finland, but Band 8 weaves it in more smoothly.