Some people think that the government should be responsible for looking after elderly people who can no longer care for themselves. Others believe that this should be the responsibility of their families.
Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
Why this is Band 6: Both views are discussed with clear reasons, and a sensible 'shared responsibility' opinion. The language is simple but accurate and well organised.
As people live longer, more and more elderly people reach an age where they can no longer look after themselves. There is disagreement about whose responsibility it is to care for them: the government, or their own families. In this essay, I will discuss both views and give my opinion.
Some people believe the government should be responsible. They argue that caring for the elderly is expensive and difficult, and that not every family can do it. Many adults today work full-time, or live far away from their parents, and simply cannot provide the constant care that an elderly person may need. A government, with its hospitals and care homes and trained staff, is far better able to provide proper care for everyone, fairly.
Others believe that families should take responsibility. They argue that it is a basic duty to care for the parents who once cared for you, and that elderly people are happier being looked after by their own loved ones, in a familiar home, rather than by strangers in an institution. In many cultures, caring for elderly parents is a strong and respected tradition.
In my opinion, the responsibility should be shared between the two. Families should provide love, company and as much care as they can, but the government should support them, with money, services and professional help, so that the burden does not fall on the family alone.
In conclusion, although both the family and the government have a role, I believe the best approach is a partnership between them, so that the elderly are cared for properly and with dignity.
266 words
Why this is Band 7: A balanced essay that presents both positions fairly and argues convincingly that the two kinds of care are complementary, not rival. Good vocabulary and a clear, well-reasoned 'partnership' position. (A stray non-English character slipped in, the sort of slip time pressure can produce.)
As lifespans lengthen across the world, the question of who should care for the elderly when they can no longer care for themselves becomes ever more pressing. Some argue the duty falls to the state; others insist it belongs to the family. In my view, the two are not真 rivals, and the wisest answer is a partnership.
The case for state responsibility is a practical one. Proper care for a frail, elderly person is demanding, skilled and often expensive, and many families simply cannot provide it: adult children frequently work full-time, live far away, or lack the training that serious conditions require. A government, with its hospitals, care homes and professional staff, can offer consistent, expert care to everyone, including those with no family at all, which is a matter of basic fairness.
The case for family responsibility is more emotional, but no less real. Many feel a deep moral obligation to care for the parents who raised them, and there is strong evidence that elderly people are generally happier and healthier when looked after by those who love them, in familiar surroundings, rather than among strangers in an institution.
My own view is that framing this as an either/or is a mistake, because the two kinds of care are different in kind. Families are best placed to provide love, company and daily attention; the state is best placed to provide money, medical expertise and professional support when the need exceeds what a family can manage. Each supplies what the other cannot.
In conclusion, rather than choosing between the family and the government, I believe responsibility for the elderly should be shared between them, in a partnership that combines the warmth of the family with the resources of the state.
290 words
Why this is Band 8: A sophisticated, personal essay (the grandmother) that reframes the question, arguing that family and state answer 'different questions' and are complementary rather than rival. Vivid, humane and tightly argued, with excellent control.
My own grandmother spent her last years cared for partly by my mother and partly by a team of state-funded nurses, and the arrangement worked precisely because neither could have managed alone. That experience shapes my answer to the question of who should look after the elderly: not the family or the state, but both, in partnership.
The argument for the state is grounded in hard reality. Caring for a seriously infirm person is exhausting, skilled and costly, and the modern family is often poorly placed to provide it: adult children work, live at a distance, and lack medical training. Only the state, with its hospitals, care homes and professionals, can guarantee a decent standard of care to everyone, crucially including the childless and the isolated, for whom family care is simply not an option. To leave the old entirely to their families is to abandon those who have none.
The argument for the family, however, speaks to something the state can never supply. There is a deep and ancient obligation to care for those who once cared for us, and, more practically, the old are overwhelmingly happier among people who love them, in a familiar home, than among kind but unfamiliar strangers in an institution.
The mistake, I think, is to treat these as competing answers to a single question, when they are really answers to different questions. The family is irreplaceable as a source of love, companionship and daily presence; the state is irreplaceable as a source of funding, medical expertise and relief when the burden grows too heavy. Set against each other, each looks inadequate; combined, they are formidable.
In conclusion, responsibility for the elderly should rest neither solely with families nor solely with the government, but with a genuine partnership between them – the only arrangement, in my experience, that serves the old with both competence and love.
312 words
How the examiner marks this
Four criteria, each worth 25% of the band. Task 2 counts for two thirds of your Writing band.
1Task response
2Coherence and cohesion
3Lexical resource (vocabulary)
4Grammatical range and accuracy
What makes the difference
Argument: Band 6 presents both sides; Band 8 shows why a pure either/or fails.
Examples: Band 7 mentions working adults living far away.
Vocabulary: 'a basic duty' (6), 'a moral obligation' (7).
Depth: Band 7 stresses that the two roles are different in kind.
Conclusion: both favour partnership; Band 7 is more precise.
Tips for this task
Discuss both the state's and the family's responsibility.
Give reasons for each view.
Consider a shared or partnership approach.
Make your own opinion clear.
Use a separate paragraph for each view.
Real people. Real approvals.
A licensed team that has guided thousands of Indians to their visas and admissions.